Tim Dierkes' and Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Tim Dierkes' and Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' founder Tim Dierkes and writer Steve Adams that occurred on November 7. (If you like Steve, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

This was a chat focused on their just published/annual Top 50 free agent prediction article. Enjoy the conjecture and their answers to all the questions. I added 1 bonus Q&A about their biggest disagreement.

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/2025-26-t ... 22893.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Grisham accepts the QO, do the Yankees still pursue Bellinger/Tucker?

Tim Dierkes
Yes, I think they feel the Grisham risk is worth taking whether it's him accepting or getting a draft pick. But Belli/Tucker are bigger fish and I'd say fully in play regardless.

Steve Adams
They wouldn't have made the QO if they weren't comfortable with a scenario that sees Trent accept.
And that's not going to impact them chasing the bigger-fish OFs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which free agent left-handed starting pitcher will end up in Pittsburgh this year?

Tim Dierkes
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/10/ ... gents.html
I hadn't really considered them adding an SP much. Can I interest you in Nestor Cortes though?

Steve Adams
Feels like there's always one! Haha. But I don't think they'll reprise the Rich Hill, Tyler Anderson, Andrew Heaney, Martin Perez signing this year.
Money has to go to bats.

Nestor would be a decent cheap option for midseason depth though, sure, if they want to carry on the tradition.
Maybe give Kyle Hart a minor league deal, haha.

Tim Dierkes
I think the signature move will be a trade for a bat, but I threw the Pirates on Jorge Polanco anyway. I assume he'll have better options, but maybe others will be reluctant to go to three years and the Pirates can break precedent and actually do a market value multiyear deal.

Steve Adams
I had the Bucs on Mullins before he was bumped from the list when the Rays declined Fairbanks' option last-minute.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Predicting Pete Alonso to come to the Queen City is quite bold, isn’t it?

Tim Dierkes
It kind of is, but it's mostly the idea that the Mets have a good chance of moving on and the contract will not be prohibitive. For the most part I've seen larger contract predictions elsewhere and if that happens then it's probably not the Reds. It'll be interesting to see if the market responds differently to him. Seemed like no one gave a decent four or five-year offer. I know it was a better year but I don't think he's drastically different moving forward.

Steve Adams
It's bold in the sense that the Reds don't spend like this in free agency, but not in the sense that Alonso just isn't going to cost THAT much by today's standards. Cincinnati has enough payroll capacity to make one big move in free agency and would free up more if they trade Singer (unless they do the Singer-Taylor Ward swap I have been manifesting for weeks, haha).

There's no clear option at 1B. The team is desperate for offense. We expect the Reds to try for Schwarber, a Cincinnati native they love, and when they fall short pivot to the next-best bet in terms of power bats.

I wound up putting Alonso on the Red Sox, but I was between them and the Reds primarily for him. We'll see if they actually pull the trigger, but it feels feasible based on payroll.
And hey, they gave Votto twice what we're predicting for Pete -- and that was more than a decade ago.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Looks like the Cubs won't be shopping at the top, am I wrong?

Tim Dierkes
I can't tell yet. Logically payroll should be up this year, at least closer to the CBT. The Kittredge trade was weirdly cheap for a bullpen that basically just has Palencia, but maybe they just don't like him at that money for next year. I'm guessing the Cubs would prefer to trade for a good SP than sign one. They've rarely done the latter, but Hoyer was there for Lester and Darvish. Lester was a Cubs legend and Darvish was solid for most of the six years even though Hoyer dealt him halfway through.

Steve Adams
The Cubs never want to shop at the top. I don't really understand why. They're the Cubs. They print money.

I could see them adding one of the bigger starters but not quite the top of the market. Did I put them on Ranger Suarez? I think I did. Ha. Something in that just-over-100 price range.

I also put them on Kazuma Okamoto, simply because I don't think Matt Shaw did anything in 2025 to seize the 3B job, and if they're not going to shell out for an absolute top-of-market free agent, Shaw, Caissie, etc. are going to be popular asks on the trade market.

I think the Cubs will be in on Joe Ryan, MacKenzie Gore -- basically all the big trade names this winter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does Kyle Tucker end up in red pinstripes in south Philly this coming season?

Steve Adams
I can see it. Phils were on my short list of plausible Tucker spots, along with the Giants, Jays, Yankees and Dodgers.

Tim Dierkes
Darragh predicted that. I think it's reasonable enough, particularly if Schwarber leaves.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Your estimate of $400m/11y for Tucker seems high to me, maybe because I’m not as familiar with him, because he doesn’t seem to have the impact of other players who have reached that number. How much of his estimated guarantee is due to the weakness of the FA class?

Tim Dierkes
I don't think weakness of the FA class had much to do with it. Tucker is a very good player. The idea that he might sign the fourth-largest contract in MLB history is deceiving, because of inflation.

I am in the Chicago area and saw firsthand how weird and disappointing Tucker's second half was. I don't feel great about the 400 mil prediction, but also did not have the conviction to put him lower. My colleagues helped make his case and it remains strong.

I wrote some stuff in my mailbag about how I can see Tucker's market failing to materialize, but at that point I hadn't given enough consideration to the Blue Jays. I think he has the Jays, Dodgers, and Yankees as three fairly likely big market suitors. If for whatever reason two of those take different paths, Tucker will not get 400 mil, in my estimation.

Steve Adams
Tucker is 29 and does everything well. He's had a couple pretty fluky injuries that were exacerbated certainly by Houston's ... less-than-stellar ... track record with managing injuries (and, to a lesser extent, that also happened in Chicago).

He probably is the quietest superstar in the game, but Tucker is a bankable source of 4-5 WAR every season even including the past two injury-shortened years. A full season of a healthy Tucker is probably comfortably worth 6+ wins. Teams pay for youth.

Tim wanted him lower, and I can't say I'll be shocked if he signs for "only" 350 or so, but this player is so, so good, and with teams like the Giants, Jays, Yankees, Phillies and Dodgers all standing as viable landing spots, yeah I think he gets a mega-deal.

As Tim is referencing, focusing on the trade market for bats or simply prioritizing pitching for some of his major potential suitors could throw a wrench into the 400+ contract, but I don't see any real way he signs for under 300.
And I tend to prefer erring on the side of aggression when it comes to the very top free agent(s).

Tim Dierkes
I did come in at 400 mil in my independent Tucker prediction. But when we all kind of landed there as a consensus, I stress-tested that a lot because I'm really not sure. I have also written in my mailbag, Excel Sports Management hasn't really had guys where taking the Boras path of three years and $120MM with two opt-outs was chosen. We don't know if Excel would accept something in that 300 range for Kyle.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I know the projected landing spots are as much fun as meaningful but Woodruff to the Mets got me thinking about a larger issue. If they trade for a frontline starter wouldn't they want to avoid the 2 pick/$1m IFA penalty since the trade would deplete the farm?
2nd thought: Is the comp penalty price for a Woodruff greater than the likely prospect cost for a trade for say Alcantara?

Tim Dierkes
My assumption is that the Mets will only bring in one front-rotation type. If Woodruff qualifies as that for Stearns, then giving up the second and fifth round picks and the international pool money is part of the calculus. 3/66 is a fairly light contract if Woody can pitch like he did in the regular season this year and most importantly, by healthy for the most part come October (which of course he was not in 2023 and '25).

The Alcantara price I think would require players with relative certainty and proximity to the Majors. It just seems like a different kind of way of paying than forfeiting picks, most of which bust.
You don't want to continually wipe out all your draft picks, it's a numbers game, but a lot of fifth rounders don't become anything.

I assume the three of us picking the Mets on Woodruff couldn't resist the Stearns connection and his tendency thus far to not sign SP to long-term deals. We sometimes grasp at straws a little bit to decide why this team should get this SP and this other one that one.

Steve Adams
Not convinced the Marlins trade Sandy this winter. At all. Though it's possible enough that he ranked prominently on the Trade Candidate list. He will 100% be talked about and sought after all offseason.

It gets a little murky, answering questions like this. You're making short-term talent acquisition concessions by signing Woodruff. You're making a different kind of concession to add Alcantara (or another veteran SP on the trade market), but there's the implied future value of making him a QO years down the line as well, if all goes according to plan.

More to the specific Mets question ... their farm is great. They can stomach the loss of two picks and some international money. And it's feasible they can get some extra picks in the future, pending possible QOs for Clay Holmes, David Peterson etc.

Tim Dierkes
My last thought on Woodruff is that he's gonna need a clean physical. The late lat strain was likened to a hamstring strain. I ain't a doctor, so we will see.

Steve Adams
One more Woodruff point from me: I'd be surprised if he accepts. I think the very fact that the Brewers made the QO suggests they believe the injury is not major. They're already paying him a $10MM buyout, so this is Milwaukee of all teams risking a $32MM payout to a pitcher. Yikes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Cards sign any free agents at all?

Tim Dierkes
Seems like they'll add some SP innings and a veteran reliever. I had them on Adrian Houser before we cut him from the list, although he doesn't really feel like a Bloom type signing. I think they'll do low-level value stuff in FA this winter.

Steve Adams
I almost gave them Giolito but that feels like too heavy an expenditure. I do think they'll sign some cheap innings and maybe make an upside play or two in the bullpen.

But I also expect them to trade Donovan, Gray and Romero at the very least. Probably Nolan Gorman. I don't think this is a team that's going to make any exciting win-now moves.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Every year the Cubs seem to wait to choose from the fell-between-the-cracks guys. Who do you think they're hoping to see in that group this year?.

Tim Dierkes
I suppose Bregman again, maybe King, Gallen, D Williams?

Steve Adams
Feels like a Tim/Chicago question here. Haha.
I can see any of those pitchers. They're not paying Bregman.
Helsley maybe.

Tim Dierkes
If the Cubs simply don't want to do the long-term SP deals, then lying in wait to see if King/Gallen will take two years seems like something they'd do.

Steve Adams
Fairbanks
Agree on that.

Tim Dierkes
That said, the Cubs could've had Bregman by putting an opt-out after Year 1 and they did not, perhaps feeling burned by the Belli thing. So I'm not positive they want to keep doing that.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who should Bob Nutting pursue at a high-ceiling level in free agency?

Steve Adams
"Pirates owner Bob Nutting" and "high-ceiling free agent" do not compute.

Tim Dierkes
I don't really know how to answer this, haha.

Steve Adams
If you're at all a believer in a potential Cedric Mullins bounceback, then I can see that.
(I'm not really, but maybe some folks are!)

Tim Dierkes
usually the high ceiling deals are for SPs, they don't really need that. So I guess Okamoto could be an answer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Brewers have anymore flexibility this year with some contracts coming off the books and Chourio's big numbers not kicking in yet? Think there is any all-in moves they could explore? I know I know... they won't.

Steve Adams
Yoan Moncada? Luis Rengifo? That sort of bat (re: Rockies).

Tim Dierkes
I had Gleyber in Milwaukee before he got the QO.
A Quintana-esque signing if Peralta and Woody leave. A trade for Paredes maybe. Moncada works there. Geno was my long shot pick for them.

Steve Adams
Eh, Hoskins is off the books sure, but they're also paying big a big arb raise to Contreras and now have an unexpected (but very welcome) semi-notable $8MM or so to pay Andrew Vaughn following that hilarious breakout. That'll eat up a fair bit of the payroll that's coming off the books.

I don't expect them to spend much. Operate on the trade market, bring in some sneaky value free agents. The typical Brewers playbook.

Not a bad thing. If it ain't broke.......
Turang also arb-eligible for the first time. Megill gets a raise. Payroll already looks similar to 2025.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
This one's for Tim - why did you select the Cubs for Imai? How do you think he could fit in their rotation? And for both you and Steve - what are realistic expectations for his first year in MLB?

Tim Dierkes
I picked Imai for the Cubs bc they have a strong Japanese presence, he's younger than other FA starters, he can add some velo to the rotation, and you can dream on him becoming a #2. Whether they feel that way I have no idea.
hmm first season...150 innings, sub-4 ERA, 25 K%?

Steve Adams
Imai has the widest range of opinions on basically any of the prominent NPB names who could (we still don't 100% know he's being posted) come over. I frankly have zero clue what to expect. He's the hardest thrower in NPB. I've seen plenty of "He's No. 2 SP!" reports and also talked to a scout who said his breaking stuff won't miss bats and he's a 4th starter or high-leverage reliever.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which free agent caused the biggest disagreement among you all?

Steve Adams
A lot of them! Haha.

Tim Dierkes
Hmm. Let's throw some out there. I had to fight to get Robert Suarez a third year.

Steve Adams
Who was our biggest? Dylan Cease maybe?

Tim Dierkes
We pushed Bellinger up to $140 late.

Darragh and I had Cease on a long-term deal, Anthony and Steve short. Long won out but that can go either way.

Steve Adams
You didn't "fight" for it. You just overrode the rest of us and gave him the third year haha.

Tim Dierkes
Haha fair.
I do that once in a while, with limited success haha.

Steve Adams
Yeah, I came around on Cease long-term eventually. I like the pitcher and think he SHOULD get paid. I just am wary with the ERA fluctuations.

A few more...

Tim Dierkes
I had Murakami a lot lower, but I get why we came up.

Steve Adams
Tim and I had a hilariously impassioned back-and-forth over one year versus two for Raisel Iglesias of all people. I did not expect to be a passionate Raisel Iglesias truther, but this list does weird things to us.
Devin Williams we were all over the map on.

Tim Dierkes
I had King and Gallen on two-year opt-out deals but came around to the four years.

Steve Adams
He's another in the Cease bucket of "this ERA is a fluke, he's one of the best in baseball ... will he get paid based on the rate stats?"

Tim Dierkes
I might still take the under on Devin, but we argued so much back and forth that my brain turned to mush.

Steve Adams
Eventually we decided yes.

I was heavy on Zac Gallen despite not liking the pitcher much. It's hard to take that stance with much vigor.... "I don't think this guy is that good, but I do think he's going to get paid because XYZ".

Tim Dierkes
Yeah, we have guys like that every year. I remember the year Hosmer was a FA, we knew he'd get paid and none of us would like it. That proved true.

Steve Adams
None of us are very big on Gallen. I think we all feel he's a landmine. But we thought the same about Madison Bumgarner, predicted him to get paid anyway, and we were right.

Cuts both ways though. We all thought Alonso would be hung out to dry last winter but didn't have the guts to predict a short-term deal for him. Wish we would have stuck to our guns.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Post Reply