Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on September 16. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

Lots more questions than last week, and 2 bonus Q&As to boot. Enjoy!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... at-76.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
I don’t think the Ricketts will pay for Tucker after this year.

Steve Adams
This has pretty steadily been my stance all season. The Cubs would need to exceed their franchise record contract by $200MM+ to re-sign Tucker. I just don’t see it.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is the Cards payroll going to be below $100 million for 2026?

Steve Adams
The Cardinals only have $75MM on the books for 2026, and that’s including Nolan Arenado and Sonny Gray, both of whom will be trade candidates (although STL would have to eat a fair bit of money in either case — especially Arenado). Then you have arb raises for guys like JoJo Romero, Alec Burleson, Lars Nootbaar, Brendan Donovan, etc.Some of those guys could be traded, but the Cards will probably bring in some short-term free agent vets. I’d say over $100MM but not by a large margin.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you believe service time manipulation has gotten better or worse under this CBA?

Steve Adams
It’s just changed. Bubba Chandler probably would’ve been up months sooner, for instance, whereas guys like Drake Baldwin, Cam Smith, Jacob Wilson, etc. just landed in the majors from the jump. Teams are always going to game the agreed-upon rules to some extent in the name of good business.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Reds need a thumper. What does Hunter Greene bring back? I know people would say I’m crazy to trade Hunter but I think he brings back what we need.

Steve Adams
He’d bring back more than one premium bat, but that’s true of plenty within Cincinnati’s system. I’m not trading Greene or Chase Burns. You could get a quality bat for either Nick Lodolo or especially Andrew Abbott as well. I do think dealing from their pitching stash makes some sense, as I alluded to last week for subscribers:
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... bbott.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are we heading towards a Nolan Arenado release this off season? Doesn’t seem like there is much trade value left.

Steve Adams
I’d be surprised if they straight up release him. The trade value’s in the tank, but if they pay him down to like $4-5MM per year, they could at least salvage some cash.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Nico Hoerner: Traded or extended by the Cubbies?

Steve Adams
If he’s open to it, extend him again. I don’t think they’ll trade him this winter, though with so few shortstop options out there, some team might try to get a bit creative and pry him away with a position change in mind.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Woodruff: over/under 99.5mm?

Steve Adams
Under, but I think he can get a pretty weighty three-year contract.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
RE:Collins not being a top prospect. Isn’t that ridiculously arbitrary that you have to be a top-prospect when those ratings are incredibly subjective? I get the idea that they are the ones suffering most from service time manipulation, but the idea that teams should only benefit for not manipulating top prospect service time is silly.

Steve Adams
I agree, sure, but the rules are the rules.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Cade Horton: Legit chance to win Rookie of the year?

Steve Adams
Yup.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Arenado and Gray have each been adamant about not waiving their no-trade privileges.

Steve Adams
Arenado suggested just yesterday that he knows he’ll be a trade candidate this winter as the Cardinals move even more toward the young side of things. Gray didn’t waive his NTC last offseason, but he’s down to one year now and the Cardinals will revisit the idea. Contreras still seems to be holding firm on staying in STL though, at least based on reporting coming from the Cards’ beat.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who do you think ends up with the 3rd NL WC spot out of NYM, AZ, CIN, and SF? If you had to exclude the Mets, who do you think has the best chance to catch and surpass them out of those other teams?

Steve Adams
I’d still pick the Mets, but this is another topic we discussed a good bit on the podcast episode that’ll run tomorrow morning. I chose the Reds as my favorite to upset the field, if the Mets’ insane swoon persists.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Woodruff: does he stay or leave Milwaukee?

Steve Adams
He’ll decline the mutual option and get a larger deal than the Brewers will offer elsewhere.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
% chance Peralta is dealt in the offseason? How would you see the package comparing to the Burnes trade?

Steve Adams
Certainly feels possible now that he’s down to one year. I think the package would be comparable to that of Burnes, despite the latter having more name value. Peralta will be earning around half what Burnes had coming in arbitration, and his rate stats/velo aren’t really trending down the way Burnes had been.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Have MLB execs ever reached out to you guys regarding your opinions or anything on the site etc?

Steve Adams
I don’t think they care too much about our opinions, but they certainly read the site and would let us know if we botched something particularly egregious regarding their organization. Thankfully that doesn’t happen much. They’re generally more complimentary, though I know there are a handful of teams that don’t especially care for MLBTR haha. Or rather, there have been some teams in the past who did not under since-dismissed bb ops leaders. I’ll leave it at that and let you speculate wildly the rest of the way, haha.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which do we see first? An 80 home run season, 300 hit season, or a .400 batting avg season by a player?

Steve Adams
None of the above? But 80 homers feels more doable than 300 hits or a .400 average. Today’s pitching and defense is too good to get 300 hits or a .400 average ever again. But I’d say 80 homers is only slightly more plausible (again, because pitching is just so good now).
-----------------------------------------------------------------

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by phins »

Suggesting Arenado down to $4-5M is pretty laughable. Owners still care about selling tickets and Arenado is probably worth that in extra ticket sales alone. He screwed the Cards by not agreeing to the trade this year, but that was his right to do so. Not to mention the Cardinals once again grossly misvalued another internal player and how they'd age/develop.

Gray, he's been worth his deal, even if not being a deal.

Seeing the Cardinals projected at a $100M payroll is just sad. That is bottom-10 levels for the freaking St. Louis Cardinals...

Post Reply