These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on August 10.
It's been a while since he's had a chat, so he held two over the weekend. This is the 2nd. A lot of questions in this one, including 3 bonus questions: one about eggs, one about openers and one about the player he'd like to have seen the most. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/08/ ... at-67.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Brewers for real???
Mark Polishuk
They’ve been “for real” for the better part of the decade. Whether this is the Brewers team that breaks through to make some serious noise in October remains to be seen, but is is remarkable how this team keeps reinventing itself and remaining competitive.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How good are the M’s? Legitimate World Series contender?
Mark Polishuk
Absolutely. Seattle might be the best overall team in baseball right now, give or take the Brewers. So many other contenders have a clear weakness or two, but not the M’s (on paper).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think if a miracle occurred and the Pirates offered Paul Skenes a market value contract that he would sign with them despite their annual second-division status?
Mark Polishuk
Only Skenes knows the answer to this for sure. He’s made a solid amount of money in his career already via signing bonus and endorsements, so he could choose to bet on himself if he has doubts about Pittsburgh’s ability to compete.
However, betting on yourself and turning down a $200MM (or probably more) extension offer are two different things. If the Pirates actually did go all in on making Skenes their guy and offering him a mega-deal, I would lean towards him taking it, just to lock in some generational wealth for himself.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which NL teams do you have making the postseason? Any surprise team that could sneak in?
Mark Polishuk
Even with the Mets in freefall and the Cubs being shaky recently, the Reds are the only team that is in decent position right now to break into the playoff picture. Cincinnati is the only non-playoff NL team with a winning record, since the Giants and Cardinals are both exactly .500
The way the Mets look right now, I’m hard-pressed to think much of their chances down the stretch. Meanwhile, the Reds get Hunter Greene back this week.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who will land the biggest free agent deal this coming off-season?
Mark Polishuk
Tucker, by a comfortable margin.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Arenado should’ve moved on. And you told him to stay…. Ugh
Mark Polishuk
Arenado probably wasn’t checking in on the Weekend Chat when weighing his decisions about accepting a trade or not.
In all likelihood, Arenado probably has some regrets about not just accepting that trade to Houston. That’s a real sliding doors moment that would’ve completely changed 2025 for both organizations.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Cubs/SD end up tied for WC seeds 4/5, who gets home field since season series went 3-3?
Mark Polishuk
The next tiebreaker is intra-division record.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Odds of Cards signing Helsley in the offseason?
Mark Polishuk
Most players say they like playing for their old club, but Helsley was so particular about it that I think there’s a decent chance of a reunion. Only Helsley or his agents know if Helsley’s interest extends to the point of perhaps being willing to give the Cardinals a minor hometown discount, but we’ll see how his market plays out.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I think Drake Baldwin is not a lock for ROY at all, Isaac Collins has had a lot to say about that the last two months. Nearly all stats favor Collins.
Mark Polishuk
Forgot to put this as an addendum to that previous post, but you’re right, I think Collins will win NL ROY. He’s gotten himself in line for an everyday role with a Brewers team that is conquering baseball.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is PCA’s post-ASG slump a normal second half regression, or something worse?
Mark Polishuk
His strikeout and walk rates were both really rough even when he was crushing the ball in the first half, so some regression was inevitable.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Cardinals sign any one this winter or do they stand pat?
Mark Polishuk
A blockbuster signing is doubtful, but I’m sure Bloom will bring in some talent in his first offseason in charge.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Over easy eggs or scrambled eggs? Who ya got Mark?!
Mark Polishuk
Scrambled eggs all day every day.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Why don’t we see more (or any) teams using openers? It seems like it worked wonders for teams like the Tigers and Rays in recent years. Does the data show otherwise?
Mark Polishuk
Deploying an opener/bulk pitcher for a regular turn in the rotation makes things harder on a pitching staff’s depth. Over a short period or even a couple of months it can work fine, or even work wonders. Over a full season, however, it has some drawbacks.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which player of all time do you wish you could see play in person?
Mark Polishuk
Babe Ruth is the obvious answer. Plus all of the great Negro League legends that most fans even of that era didn’t get a chance to see play.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments
Online
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11774
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois