A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31085
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by Popeye_Card »

Rant away.

User avatar
booger71
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5776
Joined: June 19 18, 5:36 pm

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by booger71 »

Seems to me ownership instead of trying to build a winning team, used their TV money to build another stadium including the Ballpark village. Now they reaping the benefits of low attendance. Couldn't happen to a better bunch of scumbags

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43332
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by heyzeus »

Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
August 5 25, 9:19 am
Rant away.
Ok, well, you showed me.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31085
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by Popeye_Card »

cardsfantx wrote: ↑
August 5 25, 10:33 am
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
August 5 25, 10:24 am
Owners would of course like a salary cap. High revenue teams get to keep more revenue. Low revenue teams can count on it curbing the price on free agent players. I don't think in any scenario would it be good for the veteran players who control the MLBPA. I just don't think it is a cure for what ails MLB.
how would high revenue teams get to keep more revenue? they get to keep 50% and the other 50% goes to the players...and the yankees revenue would be the same as the Rays as it shared by all teams equally...that's how salary caps work in all sports and the owners for the yankees and dodgers seem to be fine with that, as not one has come out against it?

and for low revenue teams (again with a salary cap, there are no "low revenue teams"), but for example the rays. as with other sports, they HAVE to spend 90% towards the salary cap to meet the "floor"

so if you just used a 200 mil salary cap, the rays HAVE to spend at least 180 mil on payroll

there is no scenario where the players would earn less under a salary cap system
Relocating to the other thread.

IF all (or most) MLB revenue was shared, you would be correct. But it is not, and the higher revenue owners likely will never let it.

Case in point, using round estimates. MLB made a reported ~$12B last year, a figure that does NOT include revenue from RSN's or side projects (like Ballpark Village). The Dodgers made a reported $1B, and their lucrative local TV deal pays ~$334MM per season (which *is* included in that figure).

Splitting the $12B across 30 teams equally is $400MM per team. The Dodgers are clearly punching above their weight in revenue, bringing in closer to $600MM or more (plus the $334MM TV revenue, getting them to the ballpark of $1B). They won the World Series, so there's the additional postseason revenue in there. They've invested in Japanese superstars, which brings in additional revenue. They're going to generate more revenue with in-stadium advertising in LA than a Cleveland or Milwuakee would. They also likely have higher operating expenses.

There are going to be teams at the opposite end of the spectrum too, that offsets the Dodgers, Yankees, etc. Safe to bet that teams like the Guardians or Brewers, despite being generally well ran, are pulling in closer to $300MM or less in revenue.

So let's run a pooled revenue scenario. WITHOUT pooling the RSN revenue, 50% of the MLB revenue sets the salary cap. $6 billion divided by 30 teams = $200MM salary cap. Each team's share of the revenue is also $200MM. After covering operating costs, Cleveland and Milwuakee are going to make a greater profit than the Dodgers who carry a higher operating cost. That's not really fair. But the Dodgers get that extra RSN revenue so maybe they are OK. But they are still making likely $100MM-$200MM less per year in profit than they would be under the current system, plus de-incentivizing them to keep their strong/expensive player development system, invest in Japanese superstars, etc.

Pooling RSN revenue makes it even worse for teams like the Dodgers. No way are they going to agree to that. The only way the Dodgers, Yankees, etc. would want a salary cap now is if revenue is NOT shared. That caps their player expenses, and only increases their bottom line.

NFL is totally different. Their revenue sharing system has been different for so long that it is engrained into the league and the valuations of the teams. They also don't pay much for player development, whereas MLB has to support the entire minor league system.

I'm not saying a salary cap and floor system can't work in baseball. I just think there is no way it is a solution to the league's problems without blowing up the whole system, which the owners will never, ever come to an agreement on.

User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

Sometimes I think of all the silly things this organization has done for the past decade. None of these were truly awful but seem like harbingers now of how inept this franchise would become. Like giving Matheny a new contract literally the day after the Cubs won the World Series in 2016. Or acquiring Juan Nicasio in 2017 but only after he would've been ineligible to join the playoff roster (which of course didn't happen.)

WAR God
Veteran Player
Posts: 1171
Joined: August 2 22, 8:47 am

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by WAR God »

Firing Mike Shildt in a very unprofessional manner. he goes on to coach a better team and get better results. Poetic.

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by dmarx114 »

WAR God wrote: ↑
August 8 25, 5:42 am
Firing Mike Shildt in a very unprofessional manner. he goes on to coach a better team and get better results. Poetic.
How was it unprofessional?

User avatar
GeddyWrox
Caught you a delicious bass
Posts: 14718
Joined: April 20 06, 8:43 pm
Location: Please use blue font for the sarcasm impaired.

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by GeddyWrox »

Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
August 5 25, 11:51 am
Relocating to the other thread.

IF all (or most) MLB revenue was shared, you would be correct. But it is not, and the higher revenue owners likely will never let it.

Case in point, using round estimates. MLB made a reported ~$12B last year, a figure that does NOT include revenue from RSN's or side projects (like Ballpark Village). The Dodgers made a reported $1B, and their lucrative local TV deal pays ~$334MM per season (which *is* included in that figure).

Splitting the $12B across 30 teams equally is $400MM per team. The Dodgers are clearly punching above their weight in revenue, bringing in closer to $600MM or more (plus the $334MM TV revenue, getting them to the ballpark of $1B). They won the World Series, so there's the additional postseason revenue in there. They've invested in Japanese superstars, which brings in additional revenue. They're going to generate more revenue with in-stadium advertising in LA than a Cleveland or Milwuakee would. They also likely have higher operating expenses.

There are going to be teams at the opposite end of the spectrum too, that offsets the Dodgers, Yankees, etc. Safe to bet that teams like the Guardians or Brewers, despite being generally well ran, are pulling in closer to $300MM or less in revenue.

So let's run a pooled revenue scenario. WITHOUT pooling the RSN revenue, 50% of the MLB revenue sets the salary cap. $6 billion divided by 30 teams = $200MM salary cap. Each team's share of the revenue is also $200MM. After covering operating costs, Cleveland and Milwuakee are going to make a greater profit than the Dodgers who carry a higher operating cost. That's not really fair. But the Dodgers get that extra RSN revenue so maybe they are OK. But they are still making likely $100MM-$200MM less per year in profit than they would be under the current system, plus de-incentivizing them to keep their strong/expensive player development system, invest in Japanese superstars, etc.

Pooling RSN revenue makes it even worse for teams like the Dodgers. No way are they going to agree to that. The only way the Dodgers, Yankees, etc. would want a salary cap now is if revenue is NOT shared. That caps their player expenses, and only increases their bottom line.

NFL is totally different. Their revenue sharing system has been different for so long that it is engrained into the league and the valuations of the teams. They also don't pay much for player development, whereas MLB has to support the entire minor league system.

I'm not saying a salary cap and floor system can't work in baseball. I just think there is no way it is a solution to the league's problems without blowing up the whole system, which the owners will never, ever come to an agreement on.
I don't disagree with ANY of what you said.

However, the Yankees and Dodgers (and few other teams) are going to let the quality of the product rot in ~25 other cities, while leagues like the NFL and NBA continue to soar. Hell, even the NHL might wind up more popular than baseball in the US.

User avatar
GeddyWrox
Caught you a delicious bass
Posts: 14718
Joined: April 20 06, 8:43 pm
Location: Please use blue font for the sarcasm impaired.

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by GeddyWrox »

All this talk of why the richest teams wouldn't want a salary cap is feeling more and more like the "Capitalism running amok" thread over in politics.

Online
cardsfantx
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12220
Joined: November 6 10, 10:58 am

Re: A general thread for criticizing the Cardinals organization and MLB

Post by cardsfantx »

You cannot have a salary cap without revenue sharing; you just can’t; And the Yankees and Dodgers have never came out and said they’re opposed to it, so not sure why we’re even discussing it?

And even if the top 2-3 spending teams end up do having an issue with it, you don’t need all 100% of the owners approval to pass a new cba

Anyways, we’re heading towards another lockout anyways based on every experts opinion, so the teams and players are screwing over the fans (again), and I’m not sure it’s going to be the same afterwards.

Take me for example. Never missed a game growing up if I could help it, even when moving to TX 25 years ago. I’ve always had extra innings then MLB.tv so I didn’t miss a game. It was ALWAYS the cards first and then the blues. In the spring and fall if the cards and blues were on at the same time, it was always the cardinals. Then after 2023 I just couldn’t take it anymore. Stopped paying for MLB.tv, and with all the blues games on espn+, it was a no brainer to watch them since I already had it due to the Disney package.

Since 2023 I’ve not watched 1 entire cardinals baseball game. If they happen to be on mlb network or espn, I will watch a few innings and then find something better to watch. The blues have taken their place, and I will schedule my watching around them (and I was never a big hockey guy. Never played it but played baseball through college)

The cards don’t even cross my mind anymore. I just come here because I enjoy the people here; it just happens to be a cards site. I only pay attention to the draft and somewhat the minors.

If a guy who’s nearly 50, who was a die hard cards fan who never missed a game and paid extra to watch the cards for 20+ year in a different state, doesn’t care to follow/keep up/watch games anymore? What chance to they have to capture the casual fan? (who they really need)

And to screw it up even more by not caring about the product on the field, AND probably have a lockout in a year which is going to cancel games? Sorry, I really will not care at that point.

I’m not even mad, I just don’t care (and that’s even worse)

And with all the different streaming options and shows, movies, etc? There’s just too many options to think you can put a subpar product on the field and think people will care and tune in…

Post Reply