We won't be getting anything good back for any of the players we're trading. We probably would for Helsley and Fedde; everything else would jut be saving the Dewitts cash, which is all we'll get for Arenado or Matz. We're doing a rebuild but without the "stockpile young talent" part of the equation. This is a truly demoralizing time to be a Cardinals fan. At least in the early 90s they were trying, but just being generally bad at it.
Unless several of the Gorman/Walker/Matthews/Hence/Saggese/McGreevy pan out bigly, we're in for multiple years of suckitude. And be certain that the suckitude will be sold to us by ownership as reason not to invest in the free agent market in future seasons.
Speaking for myself, I'm definitely not demoralized. I felt this was a long time coming. They kicked the can down the road for a long time, but eventually the rebuild has to come. Unless you're the Dodgers or the Yankees, it's unavoidable. Cardinals had a hell of a run, but the fact they maintained that competitiveness for so long without being a big spender is actually remarkable. Maybe part of it is I am a fan of teams that have truly been horrific for decades in other sports, that a few lean years after pretty much 20+ years of prosperity really isn't that big a deal to me. So we'll suck until 2027? My football team has sucked for 22 years lol. My basketball team just got good 2 years ago after sucking since the late 90s.
I'm at the point where I like to see the young guys play, and hope a few of them turn into stars and build from there. I can't speak for others, but I don't feel hopeless or despondent.
I feel the same, but I think I could also go either way. To me this is not a necessary decision but we've historically built ourselves on a competent, fundamentally sound farm system supplemented by trades and free agency, almost never going after the big fish. I think our younger players are still pretty good, but obviously not enough to pick up the slack when the stars have major drops in production.
Long term, I think a reasonable goal should be the Brewers, and then stack on a few big stars on top of that. They're consistently well behind us in payroll the last several years, while generally outperforming us. So in theory I don't see why it can't be done.
Earlier this offseason, the Cardinals declined an offer from the Yankees that could’ve sent Marcus Stroman to St. Louis for Nolan Arenado, according to a report from Mark Feinsand, John Denton and Bryan Hoch of MLB.com. It’s unknown whether Arenado would have approved that trade. MLB.com reports that the Cardinals never brought it to the star third baseman because they were uninterested in acquiring Stroman.
This article suggests a 3 year trade of Arenado to the Phillies, Alec Bohm to the Mariners and Colt Emerson to the Cardinals. Emerson is a SS who's 19 years old and was #22 overall pick by the M's in 2023. Emerson is at A+ now and just got done playing in Arizona Fall League.
This article suggests a 3 year trade of Arenado to the Phillies, Alec Bohm to the Mariners and Colt Emerson to the Cardinals. Emerson is a SS who's 19 years old and was #22 overall pick by the M's in 2023. Emerson is at A+ now and just got done playing in Arizona Fall League.
This article suggests a 3 year trade of Arenado to the Phillies, Alec Bohm to the Mariners and Colt Emerson to the Cardinals. Emerson is a SS who's 19 years old and was #22 overall pick by the M's in 2023. Emerson is at A+ now and just got done playing in Arizona Fall League.
Emerson sounds like a good prospect, but can he Thoreau?
This article suggests a 3 year trade of Arenado to the Phillies, Alec Bohm to the Mariners and Colt Emerson to the Cardinals. Emerson is a SS who's 19 years old and was #22 overall pick by the M's in 2023. Emerson is at A+ now and just got done playing in Arizona Fall League.
Emerson sounds like a good prospect, but can he Thoreau?
This article suggests a 3 year trade of Arenado to the Phillies, Alec Bohm to the Mariners and Colt Emerson to the Cardinals. Emerson is a SS who's 19 years old and was #22 overall pick by the M's in 2023. Emerson is at A+ now and just got done playing in Arizona Fall League.
The Cardinals aren't getting a prospect even in the same stratosphere as Colt Emerson.
Adjust your expectations accordingly. They will get a fringe 40-man player and maybe a lottery ticket.
Arenado has no surplus value and can choose his destination. He is probably an underwater asset.
This article suggests a 3 year trade of Arenado to the Phillies, Alec Bohm to the Mariners and Colt Emerson to the Cardinals. Emerson is a SS who's 19 years old and was #22 overall pick by the M's in 2023. Emerson is at A+ now and just got done playing in Arizona Fall League.
The Cardinals aren't getting a prospect even in the same stratosphere as Colt Emerson.
Adjust your expectations accordingly. They will get a fringe 40-man player and maybe a lottery ticket.
Arenado has no surplus value and can choose his destination. He is probably an underwater asset.
So, some prospect who was recently in the Atlantis League?