StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
Fat_Bulldog
likes to grate his own cheese
Posts: 12878
Joined: May 9 06, 12:41 pm
Location: Drunk

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by Fat_Bulldog »

Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 1:30 pm
heyzeus wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 12:41 pm
We won't be getting anything good back for any of the players we're trading. We probably would for Helsley and Fedde; everything else would jut be saving the Dewitts cash, which is all we'll get for Arenado or Matz. We're doing a rebuild but without the "stockpile young talent" part of the equation. This is a truly demoralizing time to be a Cardinals fan. At least in the early 90s they were trying, but just being generally bad at it.

Unless several of the Gorman/Walker/Matthews/Hence/Saggese/McGreevy pan out bigly, we're in for multiple years of suckitude. And be certain that the suckitude will be sold to us by ownership as reason not to invest in the free agent market in future seasons.
Speaking for myself, I'm definitely not demoralized. I felt this was a long time coming. They kicked the can down the road for a long time, but eventually the rebuild has to come. Unless you're the Dodgers or the Yankees, it's unavoidable. Cardinals had a hell of a run, but the fact they maintained that competitiveness for so long without being a big spender is actually remarkable. Maybe part of it is I am a fan of teams that have truly been horrific for decades in other sports, that a few lean years after pretty much 20+ years of prosperity really isn't that big a deal to me. So we'll suck until 2027? My football team has sucked for 22 years lol. My basketball team just got good 2 years ago after sucking since the late 90s.

I'm at the point where I like to see the young guys play, and hope a few of them turn into stars and build from there. I can't speak for others, but I don't feel hopeless or despondent.
I'm the same way. I feel more hopeful now than I have in a long time. Let's see what the kids can do (even if they're not the right ones for now).

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by ghostrunner »

I think/assume the intent is 1) Cut payroll and 2) Give the kids places to play regularly and see who develops

Tough to play Donovan, Nootbaar, Walker, Siani, Scott, Burleson, and Gorman regularly if Arenado is stuck at third almost every day, and I think that's what they want to do.

C - Herrera/Pages
1b - Contreras
2b - Gorman
SS - Winn
3b - Donovan
LF - Noot
CF - Siani, Scott
RF- Walker
DH- Burleson

Without Arenado, you can find most of these guys a routine and give them a shot to work things out and I think that's their goal.


I don't know what the hell Arenado wants if he won't go to Houston. Maybe he wants assurances like Bregman being gone first.

Magneto2.0
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 18100
Joined: June 16 07, 2:12 pm

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by Magneto2.0 »

Fat_Bulldog wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 1:35 pm
Magneto2.0 wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 1:30 pm
heyzeus wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 12:41 pm
We won't be getting anything good back for any of the players we're trading. We probably would for Helsley and Fedde; everything else would jut be saving the Dewitts cash, which is all we'll get for Arenado or Matz. We're doing a rebuild but without the "stockpile young talent" part of the equation. This is a truly demoralizing time to be a Cardinals fan. At least in the early 90s they were trying, but just being generally bad at it.

Unless several of the Gorman/Walker/Matthews/Hence/Saggese/McGreevy pan out bigly, we're in for multiple years of suckitude. And be certain that the suckitude will be sold to us by ownership as reason not to invest in the free agent market in future seasons.
Speaking for myself, I'm definitely not demoralized. I felt this was a long time coming. They kicked the can down the road for a long time, but eventually the rebuild has to come. Unless you're the Dodgers or the Yankees, it's unavoidable. Cardinals had a hell of a run, but the fact they maintained that competitiveness for so long without being a big spender is actually remarkable. Maybe part of it is I am a fan of teams that have truly been horrific for decades in other sports, that a few lean years after pretty much 20+ years of prosperity really isn't that big a deal to me. So we'll suck until 2027? My football team has sucked for 22 years lol. My basketball team just got good 2 years ago after sucking since the late 90s.

I'm at the point where I like to see the young guys play, and hope a few of them turn into stars and build from there. I can't speak for others, but I don't feel hopeless or despondent.
I'm the same way. I feel more hopeful now than I have in a long time. Let's see what the kids can do (even if they're not the right ones for now).
Exactly. If Mo was staying and they didn't recognize they needed to change their methods, I would feel down. But them recognizing they needed to make a big overhaul in how they been running the team over the last 5 years is a sign of growth that they haven't shown in forever.

jagtrader
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12659
Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by jagtrader »

There are plenty of at-bats available with Arenado around. The Cardinals can convince fans of anything.

Good teams keep Arenado and trade a young player package for something better. The Cardinals can’t evaluate their talent so they’re paralyzed into playing all of them until they turn into Carlson.

They’re in the barrel again. This time with a future Hall of Famer. Maybe they end up in the worst bargaining position all the time because they’re incompetent.
Last edited by jagtrader on December 19 24, 2:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

I am not demoralized but I still am afraid of rebuild being code for just stop spending. The Cubs still spent big on Lester during their rebuild, probably a year before everyone thought they should add, and it’s hard to argue that wasn’t the right mov

And I am just not particularly excited about most of the kids. Their appeal seems directly tied to their salaries, by and large.

Magneto2.0
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 18100
Joined: June 16 07, 2:12 pm

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by Magneto2.0 »

MrCrowesGarden wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 2:20 pm
I am not demoralized but I still am afraid of rebuild being code for just stop spending. The Cubs still spent big on Lester during their rebuild, probably a year before everyone thought they should add, and it’s hard to argue that wasn’t the right mov

And I am just not particularly excited about most of the kids. Their appeal seems directly tied to their salaries, by and large.
This is a fair concern. I do think the payroll cutback is something to closely watch.

I would think Bloom, someone who would have multiple opportunities with other teams, would have some sort of understanding of what the payroll will look like in the upcoming years before agreeing to take the position. But then again, wouldn't be the first time Dewitt said one thing and did the opposite.

dmarx114
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 25482
Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by dmarx114 »

heyzeus wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 12:41 pm
We won't be getting anything good back for any of the players we're trading. We probably would for Helsley and Fedde; everything else would jut be saving the Dewitts cash, which is all we'll get for Arenado or Matz. We're doing a rebuild but without the "stockpile young talent" part of the equation. This is a truly demoralizing time to be a Cardinals fan. At least in the early 90s they were trying, but just being generally bad at it.

Unless several of the Gorman/Walker/Matthews/Hence/Saggese/McGreevy pan out bigly, we're in for multiple years of suckitude. And be certain that the suckitude will be sold to us by ownership as reason not to invest in the free agent market in future seasons.
Free agency will only be a way to supplement the team. The only way this team competes year to year is through the draft.

User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

dmarx114 wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 2:44 pm
heyzeus wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 12:41 pm
We won't be getting anything good back for any of the players we're trading. We probably would for Helsley and Fedde; everything else would jut be saving the Dewitts cash, which is all we'll get for Arenado or Matz. We're doing a rebuild but without the "stockpile young talent" part of the equation. This is a truly demoralizing time to be a Cardinals fan. At least in the early 90s they were trying, but just being generally bad at it.

Unless several of the Gorman/Walker/Matthews/Hence/Saggese/McGreevy pan out bigly, we're in for multiple years of suckitude. And be certain that the suckitude will be sold to us by ownership as reason not to invest in the free agent market in future seasons.
Free agency will only be a way to supplement the team. The only way this team competes year to year is through the draft.
This is really all they ever did tbf.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by ghostrunner »

jagtrader wrote: ↑
December 19 24, 2:17 pm
There are plenty of at-bats available with Arenado around. The Cardinals can convince fans of anything.
Not really necessary to convince anyone. This is what they said they planned to do.

We are going to find pathways to give our younger players a chance to play and see what they can do.”
“In the past, we couldn’t keep trying,” Mozeliak said. “We’d have to go out and address those needs. Now what we’re saying is we’re going to let (the players) go play and find out if they can make those adjustments. Let’s see if they can do it for us, instead of us giving up on them and now they’re doing it for someone else.”
“We were always rushing to find the next better thing,” Mozeliak said. “Now we’re going to say we’re going to give this time to see what we really have.”

User avatar
TGantz
R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
Posts: 6698
Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
Location: The Lou

Re: StL will guage Arenado trade interest

Post by TGantz »

I have no issue with letting the kids play, in theory.

Why are Scott II and Siani both on the roster? They are identical players. We can't have both on the team. Flip Siani after his almost GG season and get prospects. That would cost zero dollars.

Why is Fedde still on the roster? Add Helsley or Matz to that list. Those guys make sense to trade. Get a major league CF, a few prospects, and save some money.

Arenado, Contreras, and Gray are all signed until 2027. That's the window, especially with Winn and Walker around. So keep the team competitive until then. The core is set. Build around them.

Work on overhauling player development over the next few years during that window. Hopefully Wetherholt and others can take over the franchise by then.

SS-Winn
2B-Donovan
1B-Contreras
DH-Burleson
3B-Arenado
LF-Nootbaar
RF-Walker
C-Herrera
CF-Scott

That's not a bad team. Winn has broken out. Donovan gets on base. Contreras might have his best offensive season playing at 1B. Burly mashes RH pitching. Arenado might have been battling an injury and might put up 3 WAR with his defense. Nootbaar might stay on the field all season. Walker might break out. Herrera might break out even more. Scott might have figured out how to hit. Saggese might be a factor on offense too.

I'm frustrated that saving money is the motivation behind all of this. We'll have to bet on Gorman suddenly being consistent enough which won't go well, Scott II and Siani being a black hole at #8 and #9 after Noot misses time, and watch Helsley walk without adding to the farm.

Post Reply