I joke about Girsch, but also seriously - what calls is he making? Any? Or is he just reaching out to various players and "doing the paperwork" when the time comes? I suppose ideally you should can him if you fire Mozeliak, just because of learned behavior/shared ethos or whatever, but I bet they probably won't do both.
I don't think the DeWitt's do either. It will take new ownership to change their approach, IMO.
While I believe 100% the owner needs to invest more in the team, there's plenty of GMs that can build a more competitive roster than Mo has within the exact same payroll restrictions. Mo has had some good moves and some terrible moves. I'm not saying he's all bad, but modern baseball philosophies have left him in the dust. We have a roster of pitchers who can't strike people out and have no command, with a mediocre defense behind them, which is why we blow games so often. In big spots, they have no out pitch. We have a bunch of hit first guys, with no position, redundant bats. It's just a mess of a roster. It's not talentless, we have some really good player, but they just don't fit with each other. And he never even thought to consolidate some of these pieces and turn them into pitchers, relievers or outfielders to fill in holes where we're weak at. He's just not good anymore.
Things I agree with in this post:
1. The owner needs to spend more.
2. The organization needs to develop more starting pitchers who can strike guys out. This is the fairest criticism of Mo right now. Now to be fair, MLB changed the rules with banning the shift, which likely hurts the Cardinals more than most teams. The other fair criticism of Mo right now is trading Alcantara, Gallen, Arozarena, and Garcia.
Things I disagree with in this post:
1. The defense, when healthy is not mediocre. It's typically exceptional (Walker not withstanding). Losing Noot and O'Neill (and Carlson for a couple weeks) is causing guys to play out of position in the outfield.
2. The bullpen has out pitches. Helsley, Gio, and Hicks can all get strikeouts. But they just haven't consistently pitched well. And it seems like the times they pitch poorly are the times we are either tied or have a 1-2 run lead.
3. A constant theme on this board is we have a bunch of hit first guys with no position. I assume this is in reference to Yepez, Burleson, and Baker. I do not understand for the life of me why this gets brought up. These are either bench players or AAA players that have had such a small impact on the team's record. Replacing them with other bench players (who are presumably better defensively) won't change the 27-42 record. Is anyone giving a valuable pitcher for Yepez and Burleson? No, no they are not.
1) Fair enough on the defense, but they're not healthy and the current roster is fielding a mediocre defensive team behind a staff of pitchers who can't get strikeouts. When balls are put in play often, they're eventually going to find holes. Add on to the fact the game has changed so starters typically don't go long, the 5-6-7 innings are typically pitched by guys who are bad. Which goes back to the bad roster construction.
2) 2 guys out of a bullpen of 7-8 being able to get Ks isn't good enough (Not counting Gio because his 24 K% is very unimpressive for a late game reliever). Add on to the fact that along with those Ks comes significant command issues which negates any net positives that come with the Ks. It doesn't matter if you have a 30-34 K% when you walk 10-15% of batters you face.
3) Yepes and Burelson are not just depth guys, they were expected to be used to make significant contribution to the team in the DH role. They both should've been traded when they had more value. That ship left the dock. Walker is blocked at his natural position by Arenado, why they waited so long to give him reps in the outfield when he was in the minors when they already had Arenado, makes no sense. Gorman is not good defensively either. That's 5 guys who are bat first, not even counting Contreras, who is probably going to have to be a DH within the next couple of years.
my understanding of the jocketty firing is that the cardinals wanted to focus on rebuilding their farm system and rely more on analytics than old school scouting. it worked because they had 1 surefire HOFer and two fringe HOFers to maintain stability. it worked because the cardinals were ahead of the curve on that approach.
now they are way behind and since the fans are content for the most part with 85 surefire wins and about 5 lucky wins, dewit won't really do anything about it. cards are his nice little piggy bank that he can sale for billions at any time.
that time is now. nothing will change so long as they are owners.
my understanding of the jocketty firing is that the cardinals wanted to focus on rebuilding their farm system and rely more on analytics than old school scouting. it worked because they had 1 surefire HOFer and two fringe HOFers to maintain stability. it worked because the cardinals were ahead of the curve on that approach.
now they are way behind and since the fans are content for the most part with 85 surefire wins and about 5 lucky wins, dewit won't really do anything about it. cards are his nice little piggy bank that he can sale for billions at any time.
that time is now. nothing will change so long as they are owners.
It was definitely a philosophical difference but the Jocketty part was also because he let the change bother him outwardly. If he would've played nice, he would've kept his job. But he didn't like the idea of DeWitt undermining him, which lead to him and Luhnow's relationship being bad along with his and DeWitt's.
Sadly I think you're right. I believe they're going to look at this season as an anomaly and keep doing the same thing
Well, this season is shaping up to absolutely be an anomaly, so I can understand why management would feel this way.
Truly, if our front office looks at this disaster and decides they can just stay the course and pray for "normal" results, it will reveal how cynical their attitude is toward their own fan base.
“My personal opinion? I think Oli has been dealt a tough hand the last two years, I really do believe that. Last year, we were young, and if it wasn’t for (the team signing) Albert Pujols, I don’t know where we’d be.”
“It’s a young team. And it’s hard to win with a lot of young players. Doesn’t mean we can’t, because we’ve done it, we did it last year and we can go out and do it again, but we really have to step up and play at a better level. Oli has been great. The coaching staff has been great. I just think it’s not easy to come in and try to put this together.”
Tough times for the resident front office Pollyannas.
Jocketty was fired after one anomaly of a season which was preceded by the most successful 7-year run in the club's modern history.
I think the main difference is, Jocketty mainly got fired because once DeWitt promoted Luhnow without Jocketty's support, it lead to a bad relationship between Jocketty and DeWitt and Jocketty and Luhnow. He probably would've stayed if he played nice with DeWitt.
I don't think Mo is the type to ruffle feathers of his boss like Jocketty was.
Agreed. Mo clearly knows how his bread is buttered. Priority #1 is to make his bosses happy and keep his job, while constructing a winning roster is only a priority in that it supports #1 by keeping the turnstiles moving.
I joke about Girsch, but also seriously - what calls is he making? Any? Or is he just reaching out to various players and "doing the paperwork" when the time comes? I suppose ideally you should can him if you fire Mozeliak, just because of learned behavior/shared ethos or whatever, but I bet they probably won't do both.
I don't think the DeWitt's do either. It will take new ownership to change their approach, IMO.
While I believe 100% the owner needs to invest more in the team, there's plenty of GMs that can build a more competitive roster than Mo has within the exact same payroll restrictions. Mo has had some good moves and some terrible moves. I'm not saying he's all bad, but modern baseball philosophies have left him in the dust. We have a roster of pitchers who can't strike people out and have no command, with a mediocre defense behind them, which is why we blow games so often. In big spots, they have no out pitch. We have a bunch of hit first guys, with no position, redundant bats. It's just a mess of a roster. It's not talentless, we have some really good player, but they just don't fit with each other. And he never even thought to consolidate some of these pieces and turn them into pitchers, relievers or outfielders to fill in holes where we're weak at. He's just not good anymore.
Things I agree with in this post:
1. The owner needs to spend more.
2. The organization needs to develop more starting pitchers who can strike guys out. This is the fairest criticism of Mo right now. Now to be fair, MLB changed the rules with banning the shift, which likely hurts the Cardinals more than most teams. The other fair criticism of Mo right now is trading Alcantara, Gallen, Arozarena, and Garcia.
Things I disagree with in this post:
1. The defense, when healthy is not mediocre. It's typically exceptional (Walker not withstanding). Losing Noot and O'Neill (and Carlson for a couple weeks) is causing guys to play out of position in the outfield.
2. The bullpen has out pitches. Helsley, Gio, and Hicks can all get strikeouts. But they just haven't consistently pitched well. And it seems like the times they pitch poorly are the times we are either tied or have a 1-2 run lead.
3. A constant theme on this board is we have a bunch of hit first guys with no position. I assume this is in reference to Yepez, Burleson, and Baker. I do not understand for the life of me why this gets brought up. These are either bench players or AAA players that have had such a small impact on the team's record. Replacing them with other bench players (who are presumably better defensively) won't change the 27-42 record. Is anyone giving a valuable pitcher for Yepez and Burleson? No, no they are not.
1) Fair enough on the defense, but they're not healthy and the current roster is fielding a mediocre defensive team behind a staff of pitchers who can't get strikeouts. When balls are put in play often, they're eventually going to find holes. Add on to the fact the game has changed so starters typically don't go long, the 5-6-7 innings are typically pitched by guys who are bad. Which goes back to the bad roster construction.
2) 2 guys out of a bullpen of 7-8 being able to get Ks isn't good enough (Not counting Gio because his 24 K% is very unimpressive for a late game reliever). Add on to the fact that along with those Ks comes significant command issues which negates any net positives that come with the Ks. It doesn't matter if you have a 30-34 K% when you walk 10-15% of batters you face.
3) Yepes and Burelson are not just depth guys, they were expected to be used to make significant contribution to the team in the DH role. They both should've been traded when they had more value. That ship left the dock. Walker is blocked at his natural position by Arenado, why they waited so long to give him reps in the outfield when he was in the minors when they already had Arenado, makes no sense. Gorman is not good defensively either. That's 5 guys who are bat first, not even counting Contreras, who is probably going to have to be a DH within the next couple of years.
Yepez didn't even make the team out of spring training. He was never a top prospect. Everyone in the world knows his limitations on defense. You make it seem like trading him in the off season would have brought back a good player. I just don't think that is a likely scenario.
Burleson is still a rookie and likely has more upside. But he's really just a bench player who was forced into an earlier larger role due to OF injuries. Again, I don't think he was ever bringing back a major piece on his own, or combined with someone like Yepez.
I agree the bullpen is probably 1-2 arms short of where we need to be. But Helsley and Gio haven't been good enough, and they were expected to be much better than they are. That's on them. They have combined for 5 losses when leading after 8 innings. That's unbelievably bad for June 15th.
Sadly I think you're right. I believe they're going to look at this season as an anomaly and keep doing the same thing
Well, this season is shaping up to absolutely be an anomaly, so I can understand why management would feel this way.
Truly, if our front office looks at this disaster and decides they can just stay the course and pray for "normal" results, it will reveal how cynical their attitude is toward their own fan base.
I think realistically they've spent over a decade putting in systems and procedures for how they go about their business and building a model that's been pretty successful (depending how you look at it) and it will be hard to let go. They'll first fire the front line coaching staff, who are presumably tasked with implementation.
It feels like to me that they've gone too far in squeezing every half win out of every position from non-prospects turning into solid major leaguers to mediocre pitchers getting good results, all the pixie dust [expletive] in the past that when it falls apart it's incredibly ugly. Or it's just a season where everyone is underperforming and unlucky with babip on both sides of the ball or all of the above.
It just feels overcomplicated. This roster should win baseball games without a coach. Like you could just scrap all the [expletive] the entire coaching staff and front office, get a couple of better pitchers and have Goldschmidt fill out the lineup card and they'll win games.
I'm pretty sure lineups and bullpen management are mainly handled by the computer these days. It isn't hard to program various political constraints (Goldschmidt isn't batting 6th, or Jeter isn't moving off SS even if that means Brendan Ryan's at 1b), so it's still so much easier for the computer to optimize than a field manager. I'd guess these days the coaching staff literally spends more time making sure everybody is sober than on roster utilization.