Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
It’s not sustainable at all. They shoot enormous lasers at a single tiny pellet compressing it into fusion and “generating” a small amount of energy. Then you need a reset process, including letting the lasers cool down, before going again. The net energy claim is also a bit of a con in that it is the fusion output over the laser output. But the energy input actually far exceeds the laser output because the lasers are super energy inefficient, you have to fabricate these intricate pellets, etc.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30871
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
Read this thread earlier and it's a more sober take
A couple chunks out of too many to copy:
A couple chunks out of too many to copy:
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
Yeah, the more I look into it, I don't think we/they should go sucking each other off just yet.
Seems like there are some things, in no particular order, that we don't currently have:
1. The ability to produce a sustained fusion reaction
2. A containment vessel for that reaction to occur in
3. The materials/design to create that vessel
4. Other stuff I'm not smart enough to think of (like the ability to convert the reaction into electricity though this is presumably easy).
This accomplishment, while I guess good, is none of those things.
Seems like there are some things, in no particular order, that we don't currently have:
1. The ability to produce a sustained fusion reaction
2. A containment vessel for that reaction to occur in
3. The materials/design to create that vessel
4. Other stuff I'm not smart enough to think of (like the ability to convert the reaction into electricity though this is presumably easy).
This accomplishment, while I guess good, is none of those things.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
1-3 are sort of not relevant to this design at least not in a conventional sense. The reaction occurs in a tiny pellet one pellet at a time. It would be “sustained” by a fresh pellet being being fused. Also, the energies per shot are not exactly enormous. The net energy release in this shot is approximately what you’d get burning 1/4 cup of gasoline. That said, the energy gets concentrated over a tiny area and an even tinier time, so obviously it is possible to damage stuff, and the fusion produces a bunch of neutrons that make the surrounding material radioactive and damaged. You also have to get the heat out, which does not seem simple to do in a way that doesn’t interfere with the whole setup, and you have to convert that heat to electricity, which probably means an inefficient steam turbine setup much like fission power.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote: ↑December 13 22, 4:05 pmYeah, the more I look into it, I don't think we/they should go sucking each other off just yet.
Seems like there are some things, in no particular order, that we don't currently have:
1. The ability to produce a sustained fusion reaction
2. A containment vessel for that reaction to occur in
3. The materials/design to create that vessel
4. Other stuff I'm not smart enough to think of (like the ability to convert the reaction into electricity though this is presumably easy).
This accomplishment, while I guess good, is none of those things.
Perhaps most glaringly, the net energy here not counting the massive losses powering the lasers, from the hypothetical thermal extraction, not to mention overhead for whatever other systems was equal to ~1/4 a cup of gasoline. That amount of electricity sells for ~$0.03 and comes from a pellet manufactured with exotic materials at insane tolerances. Seems wildly implausible that they can be produced in bulk for a few cents each.
I’m really suspicious that the fusion power hype is about about sustaining funding. The real purpose that this tool can actually accomplish is nuclear weapons research.
- BottenFieldofDreams
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 4759
- Joined: June 4 17, 10:04 pm
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
I’m assuming there’s an appropriate response somewhere between ‘holy [expletive] we landed on the [expletive] moon’ and ‘if you didn’t do this some other nerd would have.’ This has been a weird whiplash kind of a news story.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
Exactly. If the moon landing is commercially feasible fusion tech, we just launched the first ever rocket.
First rocket was 1926. Moon landing was 1959. It's the first practical step.
First rocket was 1926. Moon landing was 1959. It's the first practical step.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
Maybe. I kind of vaguely assume fusion power will someday get worked out, but this particular concept, giant lasers used to induce fusion in tiny pellets, I think is unlikely to ever be viable.
Looking at this “first step”, it’s an exercise in defining not particularly meaningful metrics so that they can be met. The first post in this thread is regarding similar claims from 2014 for the same facility. At that time, they defined for themselves success when the fusion output exceeded the amount of laser power deposited in the pellet. But the amount of laser energy that gets deposited in the pellet is a tiny fraction of laser output, so it is completely unclear of what practical significance this is. The recent announcement is just another largely meaningless metric. No output power has actually been captured and the input power still vastly exceeds the theoretical total output power. Surely, the minimum criteria should be actually capturing more output power than input power, and we are nowhere close to that. And achieving that step would be at best a proof of concept. For viable power generation, a huge number of practical problems must be solved, which are not necessarily easier to solve than the proof of concept problems.
Reading about this, it seems like it was never likely to work for power generation. Back in the “just doing some idealized physics calculations” concept phase, you could already see that if everything worked out as hoped, to make it work, you’d need to be able to make exotic fusion material pellets for a few pennies each to get a positive incremental output when operating, and this excludes the enormous capital costs that would be needed to construct and maintain the facilities.
Could there be a series of incredible breakthroughs to produce super high efficiency giant lasers on the cheap, ultra efficient pellet manufacturing, some way to get large quantities of cheap tritium, materials that are sufficiently cheap and durable for the reactor, a high speed ultra accurate firing system, and an efficient viable method for heat extract and conversion? The probability in our lifetimes is non-zero but pretty close to it.
With the rocket analogy, I think it was pretty clear early on that building big rockets was going to be possible. On the other hand, it was also clear early and remains true today that rockets would never be a viable mechanism for large fractions of the human population to travel away from Earth.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
Great post. I understand what you're saying, and it seems clear that the most promising current tech is the magnetic plasma reactor, which emerged long after the laser concept. Much like rockets vs whatever propulsion eventually emerges as an actual solution for space travel within the solar system. Still seems like those more "in the know" about these things are being overly dismissive of this result.Arthur Dent wrote: ↑December 14 22, 12:16 pmWith the rocket analogy, I think it was pretty clear early on that building big rockets was going to be possible. On the other hand, it was also clear early and remains true today that rockets would never be a viable mechanism for large fractions of the human population to travel away from Earth.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
I definitely appreciate that there has been a bit of a return to grand dreams. Hopefully, some of them will work out!
This one seems like it’s mostly a front for nuclear weapons research, but hopefully I’m wrong.
This one seems like it’s mostly a front for nuclear weapons research, but hopefully I’m wrong.
- GeddyWrox
- Caught you a delicious bass
- Posts: 14719
- Joined: April 20 06, 8:43 pm
- Location: Please use blue font for the sarcasm impaired.
Re: Nuclear Fusion closer to becoming a reality?
I know I've seen (in the past and again recently) articles stating that fusion could NOT be used for weaponry. So that's untrue?? Sorry if I missed an explanation up thread.Arthur Dent wrote: ↑December 14 22, 2:03 pmI definitely appreciate that there has been a bit of a return to grand dreams. Hopefully, some of them will work out!
This one seems like it’s mostly a front for nuclear weapons research, but hopefully I’m wrong.

