We're not allowed to mention [expletive] [expletive] right?
NEVER!
Why not? It's an interesting conversation. If comparison is impossible, at least it's fascinating we have to dig so far back and to such great heights.
Prince Fielder would have had 20 WAR seasons in whites only Beer league softball 20s and 30s. To be fair. Have you seen footage of those games? It’s funny how slow they pitched and ran. Imagine Ankiel though if we wanted to get into two way players.
Ohtani rules though. An insane and rare talent. I’m wondering what Winn can be for the Cardinals.
Something something modern training and “nutrition.”
All of those things are true, though. MLB'ers today have to face the best athletes in the entire world, who have been training (both physically and mentally) practically since birth. Babe Ruth had to face whatever white guys lived more or less east of the Mississippi who spent their offseasons picking beets or whatever. Ruth was so far beyond his peers that he'll be a legend forever. It's inherently unanswerable what he'd be in today's game, if you also assume he'd benefit from the same technology and training that other players have. But can't deny he was playing against a JV squad compared to today's game.
You either die the WAR hero, or live long enough to see your accomplishments belittled by the next generation. Hope Ohtani doesn’t get to see it when it happens to him.