New Job, Should I Take It?
- Swirls
- gone fission
- Posts: 8299
- Joined: December 11 07, 4:15 pm
- Location: South Korea
New Job, Should I Take It?
Long post coming, and I need to get some stuff off my chest.
Let me preface this with the statement that I am quite happy at my current job, my wife and I love living in the Twin Cities, and we have both made some terrific friends here.
I am in a union position, which is odd since I'm an engineer. In my entire professional career spanning 13 years (4 jobs in 4 different states) this is the only time I've not been an exempt, salaried employee. Since it's a union position, I'm an hourly employee that gets overtime pay (again something I'm not used to). Because it's a union job, I make a ton more than my industry peers, and adding overtime pay just rubs salt in the wound. Here's the kicker though - the company is cutting a ton of engineering jobs in order to save money across the entire nuclear fleet. My position is safe through at least 2019, however I personally am not - union jobs go by seniority, and there are a lot of other engineers here with more service time at the plant than me - despite me having a decade more overall experience than some of the guys here, a schmuck that started here fresh out of college a week before me would take my seat, leaving me laid off without a job. I could be replaced as early as 1Q19. After 2019 my position could go away entirely, whether or not I'm still employed there or not.
Knowing this, I've been casually looking for another job. I'm quite confident I could find an engineering job fairly quickly here in the Twin Cities, however it would likely be with a more generic mechanical engineering discipline rather than nuclear engineering like I've been in for my entire professional career. And as such, the pay would likely be roughly half of what I'm making right now.
I had an interview last week at a national laboratory in New Mexico, and a job offer came through yesterday. It's for ~$10k less per year than I'm making now (including overtime), but I'm confident I can negotiate up and get it closer to my current pay. The job would be cool as hell, and would let me stay in the nuclear industry - instead of having a parent company mission statement of "keep the lights on safely and affordably" it is "protect the US nuclear weapons arsenal." And it comes with top secret/classified security clearance. How crazy is that? Literally one of the coolest engineering jobs ever. It is a US government job, so assuming they still have it, I would get a sweet government pension after 20 years. And as long as the US maintains a nuclear weapons program, I would have a job. So pretty much guaranteed job security as long as I'm not a terrorist.
My wife is quite happy at her current job, and it pays great. And they're fine with her working remotely permanently as her boss is getting transferred to Charlotte anyway. So she's fine to move and not need to search for a new job.
However, we just bought a house about six months ago. A great lakefront log cabin on five acres, and less than a 30 minute drive to both downtown St Paul and downtown Minneapolis. Perfect perfect perfect location. And we have awesome friends here. They won't go so far as to actually buy our house from us, but the relocation package is pretty solid (they'll move us down there and pay all of our closing costs/commissions associated with selling our house, and pay up to like $10k in closing costs/fees associated with buying a new house there).
Note that the cost of living in New Mexico is cheaper than the Twin Cities. But there is a lot less to do - we would likely be living in Santa Fe or right outside of it (~150k population) whereas right now we are in a southern suburb of the Twin Cities (~4M population). Events/concerts/activities would be much less in New Mexico, obviously.
Obviously my wife and I are having these discussions ourselves, and trying to weigh the pros and cons of each. But what are your thoughts? What is your monetary threshold for leaving? What's your threshold for staying? Would you take the major pay cut and potential unemployment (and overall job change to something you're not familiar with) to not move and make new friends/sell the house/yada yada yada? Would you take the slight pay cut and move to the mountains?
Side note: until I got there I didn't realize that most of New Mexico was in the Rocky Mountains at ~7500' elevation with a VERY moderate climate and a ton of annual snowfall - I originally thought it was like most of Arizona.
TL;DR: I could get laid off in a few months and have a job offer 1000 miles away that pays (slightly) less but would be cool as hell. Do I uproot my family (wife, 2 dogs, 1 horse, no kids) and move or stay and take a major pay cut and find a job elsewhere?
Let me preface this with the statement that I am quite happy at my current job, my wife and I love living in the Twin Cities, and we have both made some terrific friends here.
I am in a union position, which is odd since I'm an engineer. In my entire professional career spanning 13 years (4 jobs in 4 different states) this is the only time I've not been an exempt, salaried employee. Since it's a union position, I'm an hourly employee that gets overtime pay (again something I'm not used to). Because it's a union job, I make a ton more than my industry peers, and adding overtime pay just rubs salt in the wound. Here's the kicker though - the company is cutting a ton of engineering jobs in order to save money across the entire nuclear fleet. My position is safe through at least 2019, however I personally am not - union jobs go by seniority, and there are a lot of other engineers here with more service time at the plant than me - despite me having a decade more overall experience than some of the guys here, a schmuck that started here fresh out of college a week before me would take my seat, leaving me laid off without a job. I could be replaced as early as 1Q19. After 2019 my position could go away entirely, whether or not I'm still employed there or not.
Knowing this, I've been casually looking for another job. I'm quite confident I could find an engineering job fairly quickly here in the Twin Cities, however it would likely be with a more generic mechanical engineering discipline rather than nuclear engineering like I've been in for my entire professional career. And as such, the pay would likely be roughly half of what I'm making right now.
I had an interview last week at a national laboratory in New Mexico, and a job offer came through yesterday. It's for ~$10k less per year than I'm making now (including overtime), but I'm confident I can negotiate up and get it closer to my current pay. The job would be cool as hell, and would let me stay in the nuclear industry - instead of having a parent company mission statement of "keep the lights on safely and affordably" it is "protect the US nuclear weapons arsenal." And it comes with top secret/classified security clearance. How crazy is that? Literally one of the coolest engineering jobs ever. It is a US government job, so assuming they still have it, I would get a sweet government pension after 20 years. And as long as the US maintains a nuclear weapons program, I would have a job. So pretty much guaranteed job security as long as I'm not a terrorist.
My wife is quite happy at her current job, and it pays great. And they're fine with her working remotely permanently as her boss is getting transferred to Charlotte anyway. So she's fine to move and not need to search for a new job.
However, we just bought a house about six months ago. A great lakefront log cabin on five acres, and less than a 30 minute drive to both downtown St Paul and downtown Minneapolis. Perfect perfect perfect location. And we have awesome friends here. They won't go so far as to actually buy our house from us, but the relocation package is pretty solid (they'll move us down there and pay all of our closing costs/commissions associated with selling our house, and pay up to like $10k in closing costs/fees associated with buying a new house there).
Note that the cost of living in New Mexico is cheaper than the Twin Cities. But there is a lot less to do - we would likely be living in Santa Fe or right outside of it (~150k population) whereas right now we are in a southern suburb of the Twin Cities (~4M population). Events/concerts/activities would be much less in New Mexico, obviously.
Obviously my wife and I are having these discussions ourselves, and trying to weigh the pros and cons of each. But what are your thoughts? What is your monetary threshold for leaving? What's your threshold for staying? Would you take the major pay cut and potential unemployment (and overall job change to something you're not familiar with) to not move and make new friends/sell the house/yada yada yada? Would you take the slight pay cut and move to the mountains?
Side note: until I got there I didn't realize that most of New Mexico was in the Rocky Mountains at ~7500' elevation with a VERY moderate climate and a ton of annual snowfall - I originally thought it was like most of Arizona.
TL;DR: I could get laid off in a few months and have a job offer 1000 miles away that pays (slightly) less but would be cool as hell. Do I uproot my family (wife, 2 dogs, 1 horse, no kids) and move or stay and take a major pay cut and find a job elsewhere?
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
Take that Government job - Pensions are nothing to sneeze at.
Besides - Top Secret Baby!
Besides - Top Secret Baby!
- MAGA
- All-Star
- Posts: 1323
- Joined: November 10 16, 10:22 am
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
How sure are you about this potential layoff?
It sounds like a matter of time. And the government thing sounds amazing, at least right now.
This is really tough. Good luck.
It sounds like a matter of time. And the government thing sounds amazing, at least right now.
This is really tough. Good luck.
- Swirls
- gone fission
- Posts: 8299
- Joined: December 11 07, 4:15 pm
- Location: South Korea
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
I don't know that it would have a true pension or not. It may just be "we match your 401k and then put in $X each year into a retirement account" rather than a *real* pension. Real pensions pretty much don't exist these days for new hires.
They sent me about 50 pages of docs between the offer letter/attachments/relocation policies/benefits policies, and I haven't had a chance to go through all of it yet.
They sent me about 50 pages of docs between the offer letter/attachments/relocation policies/benefits policies, and I haven't had a chance to go through all of it yet.
- Swirls
- gone fission
- Posts: 8299
- Joined: December 11 07, 4:15 pm
- Location: South Korea
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
The company's labor steward said my job and me personally were safe from the layoffs at least through 2019. Our union head said I personally would be affected, but my position would stay as long as the company kept the job in the org chart.MAGA wrote:How sure are you about this potential layoff?
It sounds like a matter of time. And the government thing sounds amazing, at least right now.
This is really tough. Good luck.
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
Sounds like a tough choice. Fortunately it's balancing some good to great options.
Do you guys plan on having kids? What are schools like, in general, in NM?
My sister-in-law lived in Santa Fe for a while and really liked it. But MN lake life can be pretty sweet and It sounds like you have a good set-up.
Do you guys plan on having kids? What are schools like, in general, in NM?
My sister-in-law lived in Santa Fe for a while and really liked it. But MN lake life can be pretty sweet and It sounds like you have a good set-up.
- Schlich
- Don't tone police me bro!
- Posts: 10841
- Joined: July 1 06, 7:24 pm
- Location: Lost in the Cloud
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
I went to high school in Albuquerque. New Mexico is pretty cool. Will you be working for Sandia? They have a great reputation. Depending on your priorities the relocation could be a real blessing. The family thing (and the horse) make me feel like it'd be a good fit for you.
- Schlich
- Don't tone police me bro!
- Posts: 10841
- Joined: July 1 06, 7:24 pm
- Location: Lost in the Cloud
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
Minneapolis sounds cool as hell but also cold as hell
Online
- CardsofSTL
- All Hail the GDT Master
- Posts: 70105
- Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
- Location: Columbus, OH
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
I'd personally take the NM job and pension. You want all the retirement income you can get. I'd also look into renting your lakefront cabin so that if you decide you want to move back in retirement it's an option, and you're also generating rental income to compensate for any decrease in salary. You'd probably have to get an agent to help manage the property though since you'll be out of town, but I imagine that can be factored into the rent. Plus... Moving to a new place is an adventure. All depends on what will make you and your wife happy though.
- stlouie_lipp
- Hallelujah Brother
- Posts: 13380
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm
Re: New Job, Should I Take It?
Personally, the older I get the more I can't stand winter in Northern Illinois. Has to be much worse up by you. That would factor heavily into my decision. You didn't say anything about family, so I assume they don't live up by you. Would this take you farther or closer to family?




