Great question and I'd love to hear Tim's thoughts too.Diddy wrote:Is there a difference between being depressed and depression? What is the difference? Same with having suicidal thoughts and being suicidal? Probably more aimed @ Tim with his profession but asking everyone.
Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
- IMADreamer
- Has an anecdote about a townie he overheard.
- Posts: 12909
- Joined: December 6 10, 1:09 am
- Location: Illinois
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
- Tim
- Consider him admonished
- Posts: 8320
- Joined: March 25 15, 9:59 am
- Location: The South
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
There are certain criteria for different types of depression.
Classic, Major Depressive Disorder, is characterized by debilitating anhedonia, sleep, appetite, and energy disturbances, loss of focus/concentration, irritability and can lead to suicidal thinking or acute psychosis. This is different than “my wife left me and my boss is an ass” and now I’m depressed. Now that too can lead to suicidal thinking and is no less serious, however treatments are different. No amount of Zoloft or Celexa is going to bring your wife back or boss stop being an ass. I wouldn’t necessarily start meds on someone with an Adjustment Disorder like the latter.
Now the latter may require a brief hospitalization for safety reasons, but long term treatment may not be needed.
Major Depressive Disorder is best treated with medication and therapy, though that combination modality can be hard to find.
Also, when someone presents to the ER saying they’re depressed I find it smart to ask, “Depression means different things to different people. What’s it mean to you?” You’ll get some good insight into what people are dealing with.
Classic, Major Depressive Disorder, is characterized by debilitating anhedonia, sleep, appetite, and energy disturbances, loss of focus/concentration, irritability and can lead to suicidal thinking or acute psychosis. This is different than “my wife left me and my boss is an ass” and now I’m depressed. Now that too can lead to suicidal thinking and is no less serious, however treatments are different. No amount of Zoloft or Celexa is going to bring your wife back or boss stop being an ass. I wouldn’t necessarily start meds on someone with an Adjustment Disorder like the latter.
Now the latter may require a brief hospitalization for safety reasons, but long term treatment may not be needed.
Major Depressive Disorder is best treated with medication and therapy, though that combination modality can be hard to find.
Also, when someone presents to the ER saying they’re depressed I find it smart to ask, “Depression means different things to different people. What’s it mean to you?” You’ll get some good insight into what people are dealing with.
Last edited by Tim on June 8 18, 7:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Tim
- Consider him admonished
- Posts: 8320
- Joined: March 25 15, 9:59 am
- Location: The South
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
Millions of people live with daily, chronic, suicidal thoughts. When there’s been a change, or they’re new, or there is now a plan or combined with worsening depression I will admit 99% of the time
- Tim
- Consider him admonished
- Posts: 8320
- Joined: March 25 15, 9:59 am
- Location: The South
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
Then there are people that are afflicted with Bipolar Disorder. Their depression is more severe and so hard to treat. My heart breaks for the first break manic that presents to the ER.
- MAGA
- All-Star
- Posts: 1323
- Joined: November 10 16, 10:22 am
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
Can you shed any insight on Bipolar II? Many of my clients identify as “bipolar” after being diagnosed but few demonstrate the extreme polarity warranting a life altering diagnosis like BP. Their mood problems appear rooted in trauma, PTSD, etc manifesting itself vs a full blown neurodevelopmental/hardwiring problem (BP1). No delusions and that stuff. Seems different enough to warrant totally different labels. Am I wrong here?Tim wrote:Then there are people that are afflicted with Bipolar Disorder. Their depression is more severe and so hard to treat. My heart breaks for the first break manic that presents to the ER.
- Tim
- Consider him admonished
- Posts: 8320
- Joined: March 25 15, 9:59 am
- Location: The South
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
Ahh yes. The ol' "Borderpolar." Most likely not Bipolar Disorder, but more likely a personality disorder like Borderline Personality. Haphazardly diagnosing people has consequences. When someone tells me that they are Bipolar, yet have never been prescribed an atypical or mood stabilizer and I can't tease out any history of mania, I begin to think more in terms of a personality disorder.MAGA wrote:Can you shed any insight on Bipolar II? Many of my clients identify as “bipolar” after being diagnosed but few demonstrate the extreme polarity warranting a life altering diagnosis like BP. Their mood problems appear rooted in trauma, PTSD, etc manifesting itself vs a full blown neurodevelopmental/hardwiring problem (BP1). No delusions and that stuff. Seems different enough to warrant totally different labels. Am I wrong here?Tim wrote:Then there are people that are afflicted with Bipolar Disorder. Their depression is more severe and so hard to treat. My heart breaks for the first break manic that presents to the ER.
The easiest way to describe BPAD II is that mania never reaches full mania, rather the patient will have periods of hypomania and their depression may not be as bad to warrant hospitalization. We probably don't diagnose BPAD II enough and instead label someone as having some type of depression.
As far as the root of their mood problems, it is hard to say. Trauma is a risk factor for both types as well as Borderline Personality Disorder.
- 33anda3rd
- Replies Authoritatively
- Posts: 8390
- Joined: April 7 13, 9:45 am
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
Love this tweet.
Bourdain wasn't interested in talking to some tattooed white hipster in the Next Hot Food City, like Bon Appetit and Eater and all the other precious food media we have now. He was interested in the food and people of micro-cultures and he tricked people who thought they were watching Food TV into watching Get To Know Another Culture TV. He didn't look for Filipino food, rather Sisig at this particular street food stall in Manila at 1AM after a night of beers and rock music with these specific people from the area who have been eating or making this Sisig their whole lives.
Bourdain didn't go to Mexican resorts populated by other Americans, he went to Oaxaca and ate tortillas rolled out by old ladies. The former is relaxing, the latter is [expletive] living. The former is vacation, the latter is traveling. Bourdain's death, if we are fans, is an opportunity to ask ourselves if we're seeing enough of the world. Should I spend my time and money on that beach vacation in the Dominican where I'll be confined to a resort and see nothing but sand and water and I'll drink the same crap and eat the same stuff I eat at home, or should I head out to Belgium for 10 days, rent a car, and see the Abbeys and drink beers I would otherwise never have the chance to drink? The very first episode of No Reservations, within the first 5 minutes that we see Bourdain in a TV series of his own, he's in France and a language teacher tells him "this is a good restaurant, all the tourists go there" and Bourdain replies in French "This restaurant is grotesque." He didn't have time for popularity contests or following the herd he was too busy looking for something real that could make him feel or think.
Bourdain knew that getting to know and enjoy (rather than fear) The Other is a key to enlightenment, a way to enjoy life, a path to maxing out our time on earth, a way to enrich our lives.
Bourdain wasn't interested in talking to some tattooed white hipster in the Next Hot Food City, like Bon Appetit and Eater and all the other precious food media we have now. He was interested in the food and people of micro-cultures and he tricked people who thought they were watching Food TV into watching Get To Know Another Culture TV. He didn't look for Filipino food, rather Sisig at this particular street food stall in Manila at 1AM after a night of beers and rock music with these specific people from the area who have been eating or making this Sisig their whole lives.
Bourdain didn't go to Mexican resorts populated by other Americans, he went to Oaxaca and ate tortillas rolled out by old ladies. The former is relaxing, the latter is [expletive] living. The former is vacation, the latter is traveling. Bourdain's death, if we are fans, is an opportunity to ask ourselves if we're seeing enough of the world. Should I spend my time and money on that beach vacation in the Dominican where I'll be confined to a resort and see nothing but sand and water and I'll drink the same crap and eat the same stuff I eat at home, or should I head out to Belgium for 10 days, rent a car, and see the Abbeys and drink beers I would otherwise never have the chance to drink? The very first episode of No Reservations, within the first 5 minutes that we see Bourdain in a TV series of his own, he's in France and a language teacher tells him "this is a good restaurant, all the tourists go there" and Bourdain replies in French "This restaurant is grotesque." He didn't have time for popularity contests or following the herd he was too busy looking for something real that could make him feel or think.
Bourdain knew that getting to know and enjoy (rather than fear) The Other is a key to enlightenment, a way to enjoy life, a path to maxing out our time on earth, a way to enrich our lives.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21913
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
Sadly, none of those things were enough to make him want to live. On the surface, it appeared that he had it figured out. He obviously did not.
We'll probably never understand.........
We'll probably never understand.........
- Joe Shlabotnik
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 24296
- Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
- Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
- Contact:
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
Maybe he heard he had a terminal disease. Or he felt age catching up with him more than he wanted.
I'm telling you - and I've told my kids - I don't want to be useless. If I'm incapacitated, just put me down. No reason to let a god-damned hospital have my money. I'd rather they do.
I'm telling you - and I've told my kids - I don't want to be useless. If I'm incapacitated, just put me down. No reason to let a god-damned hospital have my money. I'd rather they do.
- 33anda3rd
- Replies Authoritatively
- Posts: 8390
- Joined: April 7 13, 9:45 am
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: Anthony Bourdain dead from apparent suicide
I'm not talking about his suicide, I'm talking about his life. If all we take from Bourdain is "Killed himself, yet seemed to have it all, I guess we'll never understand...." then that would be a shame and a pitiful way to remember a great man who tried to tell us a little bit about ourselves by telling us about the little nooks and crannies of the world.Socnorb11 wrote:Sadly, none of those things were enough to make him want to live. On the surface, it appeared that he had it figured out. He obviously did not.
We'll probably never understand.........



