Popeye_Card wrote:
I'm not sure kids affect these equations either. I'm thinking each kid takes $10k-20k a year off the bottom line. Maybe that's high.
Do you mean bottom line as in gross income or net income?
I'd say kids like most anything else can vary wildly. But, I'd guess that you are correct that's a reasonable assumption on how much kids cost per year on average. AT one point I heard over the course of their life, kids cost their parents around $250k which seems right.
$250k per kid seems low tbh
I think national statistics of household income have too much noise-to-signal ratio when cost of living varies widely across the country. Not sure it's always a reasonable choice to live where it's cheaper - everyone has their own circumstances to deal with (job opportunities, family, etc)
Poor 0-20k. I seriously don't know how you survive at this level of income. You can't build net worth at this income level.
lower middle class. 20-40k. You aren't living high on the hog but you might be able to build some net worth and survive emergencies.
middle class: 40-80k You should be doing ok here. The American dream is easily doable at this income.
upper middle class: 80-120k Life should be pretty easy. The big house and nice car are yours if you want it. You should be able to build serious wealth at this income.
rich: 120-up. Balla.
These ranges are probably more calibrated for a small town. When I lived in St. Louis as a single guy, I was near the $80k mark, and I wouldn't say I was anywhere near life being easy. I had an OK house in a good neighborhood, I had paid off all other debts (car, school, credit cards), and maxing my 401(k). All good things. Other than that, I wasn't building hardly any wealth or spending very lavishly.
I'm not sure kids affect these equations either. I'm thinking each kid takes $10k-20k a year off the bottom line. Maybe that's high.
Oh definitely skewed for a small town. I have no barometer on the numbers that would work in a city.
transportation costs are big factor for the poor in a city. no jobs in the neighborhood you live, what to do? Big Box retail or FF at closest inner burb (like mine). CNA or healthcare work? need to get there in an affordable timely fashion. if you are only part time you need to string together 2 gigs like this. complicated as all [expletive]. i know USA likes to celebrate bootstrap stories. but that is an exception. the new economy is brutal for most the have nots.
Popeye_Card wrote:
I'm not sure kids affect these equations either. I'm thinking each kid takes $10k-20k a year off the bottom line. Maybe that's high.
Do you mean bottom line as in gross income or net income?
I'd say kids like most anything else can vary wildly. But, I'd guess that you are correct that's a reasonable assumption on how much kids cost per year on average. AT one point I heard over the course of their life, kids cost their parents around $250k which seems right.
I've also read that figure of $250K over the course of their lifetime. Kids have a huge impact on my perception of how wealthy I am. My kids are a bit spread out, so we've been paying at least $12K (sometimes more) per year for day care for the past 12 years. I have one more year to go. We also bought a bigger house a few years ago, which increased our mortgage payment. Granted that was more of a choice than a necessity like day care, but add in food, etc, and kids easily "cost" us over $20K. The kids out of day care cost less, but I also don't think we're saving enough for college so that cost will be there eventually.
Popeye_Card wrote:
I'm not sure kids affect these equations either. I'm thinking each kid takes $10k-20k a year off the bottom line. Maybe that's high.
Do you mean bottom line as in gross income or net income?
I'd say kids like most anything else can vary wildly. But, I'd guess that you are correct that's a reasonable assumption on how much kids cost per year on average. AT one point I heard over the course of their life, kids cost their parents around $250k which seems right.
$250k per kid seems low tbh
I think national statistics of household income have too much noise-to-signal ratio when cost of living varies widely across the country. Not sure it's always a reasonable choice to live where it's cheaper - everyone has their own circumstances to deal with (job opportunities, family, etc)
It was probably 5 years ago or more when I heard that number, so it may have increased.
Like I said, kids can vary wildly and cost $10k/year to get through kindergarten to high school, then $50k/year for 4+ years after that. Obviously, that right there is $330k without ever eating, wearing clothes/diapers, being watched, etc. At the same time, those same years of schooling can cost little to nothing.
Popeye_Card wrote:Well you have to be pretty well off to *live* in Webster Groves, so maybe this checks out.
Maybe there is some sarcasm in your answer, Popeye, but this is why it's hard to generalize about geography. I grew up in a small house on the south side of Webster. Neighborhood would remind you more of Affton than WG. But when the answer to "WDYGTHS?" is WGHS there is usually an assumption of privilege (and don't get me wrong, I went to school with some rich MFers...)
My perception of wealth has varied depending on stage of life. Income when younger shifting to net worth as the years went by. We've gone from being DINKs to a 2-income family to a single-income couple on the doorstep of retirement. Our income today is half what it was when we both worked, but we made some adjustments (downsizing, moving to area with cheaper cost of living, cutting back on expenses) and are doing okay despite the reduced income. Main thing is we're fortunate to be in good enough shape financially to enjoy retirement and traveling.
Popeye_Card wrote:Well you have to be pretty well off to *live* in Webster Groves, so maybe this checks out.
Maybe there is some sarcasm in your answer, Popeye, but this is why it's hard to generalize about geography. I grew up in a small house on the south side of Webster. Neighborhood would remind you more of Affton than WG. But when the answer to "WDYGTHS?" is WGHS there is usually an assumption of privilege (and don't get me wrong, I went to school with some rich MFers...)
I also get to answer Webster for the WDYGTHS question... and I grew up in Rock Hill. Solidly blue collar middle class.
Popeye_Card wrote:Well you have to be pretty well off to *live* in Webster Groves, so maybe this checks out.
Maybe there is some sarcasm in your answer, Popeye, but this is why it's hard to generalize about geography. I grew up in a small house on the south side of Webster. Neighborhood would remind you more of Affton than WG. But when the answer to "WDYGTHS?" is WGHS there is usually an assumption of privilege (and don't get me wrong, I went to school with some rich MFers...)
I also get to answer Webster for the WDYGTHS question... and I grew up in Rock Hill. Solidly blue collar middle class.
Yep, there's south Webster and then there's old Webster. There's Rock Hill and then there's Warson Woods, amiright?
Popeye_Card wrote:Well you have to be pretty well off to *live* in Webster Groves, so maybe this checks out.
Maybe there is some sarcasm in your answer, Popeye, but this is why it's hard to generalize about geography. I grew up in a small house on the south side of Webster. Neighborhood would remind you more of Affton than WG. But when the answer to "WDYGTHS?" is WGHS there is usually an assumption of privilege (and don't get me wrong, I went to school with some rich MFers...)
I also get to answer Webster for the WDYGTHS question... and I grew up in Rock Hill. Solidly blue collar middle class.
Yep, there's south Webster and then there's old Webster. There's Rock Hill and then there's Warson Woods, amiright?