Hurricane Harvey

Chat about non-baseball topics. No political discussions!
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by Socnorb11 »

Yeah, I'm not a fan.

The point here is that I think people recognize him as a "Christian", and jumped right on the opportunity to be critical of "a Christian", whether it's justified in this case or not. That's how it feels, anyway.

User avatar
Schlich
Don't tone police me bro!
Posts: 10841
Joined: July 1 06, 7:24 pm
Location: Lost in the Cloud

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by Schlich »

You have a point, but who cares if some mean ppl made a snap judgement about him on the internet. He doesnt need defending, and neither does Christianity. I get the urge to "correct the record" but I try to be careful about who i'm defending. After all, maybe it was the twitter pressure all that got him to open his doors. Maybe it was the goodness of his heart. Who knows, point is that they're open now. And pressuring him to do it (when all indications are that he wouldn't from everything we know about him) and asking the questions why they aren't open is fair. There's a certain level of "but the facts" that is necessary but i dont feel like this is one of those times.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by Socnorb11 »

That makes sense, Schlich.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by Freed Roger »

10k from Marp!

User avatar
Joe Shlabotnik
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 24296
Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
Contact:

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by Joe Shlabotnik »

Freed Roger wrote:10k from Marp!
and Waino and the Cardinals from what I understand.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by Freed Roger »

Trump reversed regulations to protect infrastructure against flooding just days before Hurricane Harvey

This would not have a direct effect on this disaster/recovery.

But then there is this
 
The Obama-era rules, which had not yet gone into effect, would have required the federal government to take into account the risk of flooding and sea-level rise as a result of climate change when constructing new infrastructure and rebuilding after disasters....

...in the coming days, Congress will be called upon to send billions of federal dollars to help with the state's recovery and rebuilding efforts.

But because of Trump's rollback of President Barack Obama's Federal Flood Risk Management Standard, experts across the political spectrum say much of the federal money sent to Texas is likely to be wasted on construction that will insufficiently protect against the next storm.

"We will rebuild things that should not be rebuilt and ... in ways that are less safe and secure than they should be," Eli Lehrer, president of the free-market think tank R Street Institute in Washington, told Business Insider.

Michael
GRB Founder
Posts: 35304
Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
Location: Chicago, IL
Contact:

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by Michael »

The stories on dogs getting rescued gets me in the feels every time.

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43343
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by heyzeus »

stlouie_lipp wrote:All this Osteen nonsense aside, anyone know of a good charity to donate where the majority of the donation goes to help directly? AD and Zeus you may have some insight living in TX. Nothing against the Red Cross, they do good things, but there is a lot of overhead there.

I have a lot of concerns about the Red Cross too after their handling of Haiti and Sandy relief efforts. The Houston Flood Relief Fund may be a good option (JJ Watt is an organizer). The Greater Houston Community Foundation has a Harvey relief fund set up by the mayor. My Houston friends are asking for donations to go there bc they are local groups and are moving quickly to use funds to provide aid on the ground.

User avatar
Farewell Friends
Snayke's Bottomline
Posts: 3888
Joined: August 3 16, 9:44 am

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by Farewell Friends »

Schlich wrote:You have a point, but who cares if some mean ppl made a snap judgement about him on the internet. He doesnt need defending, and neither does Christianity. I get the urge to "correct the record" but I try to be careful about who i'm defending. After all, maybe it was the twitter pressure all that got him to open his doors. Maybe it was the goodness of his heart. Who knows, point is that they're open now. And pressuring him to do it (when all indications are that he wouldn't from everything we know about him) and asking the questions why they aren't open is fair. There's a certain level of "but the facts" that is necessary but i dont feel like this is one of those times.
Very well said.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Hurricane Harvey

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Arthur Dent wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:It's not hard to model. My guess is the flow rates they use are not sufficient. The way the maps are made is pretty straightforward. FEMA has established flow rates. I don't know where these come from, but every time I've submitted map revisions, FEMA provides the flows and you don't even think about changing them. They also, most of the time, provide the downstream water elevations. So, say you want to change a stream channel. FEMA will provide the flow rates for the proposed location(s) and the water surface elevations at the downstream limits. All this information is put into their program called HEC RAS which is really a pretty good program for as basic as it is. Engineers can then change the cross sections of the stream where changes are being made. So, the program has the cross sections and builds a 3d model. It has the flow rates and it has the downstream water surface elevations. Then it just iterates the energy equation between cross sections and spits out the water surface elevations at the new cross sections.
Not being hard to model makes the the difficiencincies in these crucial maps fairly inexcusable.

Looking at the incorrectly predicted flooding locations in the link I provided, I'd specualate there are a few issues:
-Isolated flood damage (just one building where neighbors don't flood may be reported as flood damage but actually more like something directly from heavy rain and wind not rising water. Or there could be what amounts to a puddle situation around the property.
-Clusters of damage not adjacent to marked flood planes may be an issue with neighborhood drainage not discharging water quickly enough into the channels e.g. Local modelling issues.
-Clusers that expand the marked plains seem likely related to underestimated volumes, perhaps due to old or wrong data.

I would hope repeated prediction errors of this kind that leave property owners unprepared would force a new study to update the maps. You'd be badly screwed not having flood insurance because these maps made you think there was little to no risk.
I went back and sifted through 10 pages of people arguing about Joel Osteen to find the your link again and yes. There are two issues. The first is localized flooding which is, I think, what your first two points are. And, the second is incorrect flood elevations.

So, let's look at localized flooding and what causes it. There are two different things to worry about in design. The first is peak runoff intensity and the second is total volume. For individual sites, peak intensity is the main factor if you can assume that the adjacent properties are not flooded while overall volume is more about the streams, tributaries, channels, rivers, lakes, etc. Here's an example of localized flooding/peak intensity. if you're on a desolate state highway that has no flooding issues and you want to put a gas station on the property, you'd never look at total rainfall volume because it's irrelevant. The only design criteria is going to be preventing an increase in peak runoff (and there's the inherent design need to prevent flooding the site in particular the building). The easiest way to do this is to detain water with a pond and an outlet structure and design a drainage system to get the runoff to that pond. And, the easiest way to model that is with the rational method. Q (peak flow) = C (runoff coefficient) * i (rainfall intensity) * A (area). Calculate Q for the existing conditions using a likely runoff coefficient of about 0.3 or 0.4 for an open field. Then, put in a pond, recalculate Q for the proposed conditions with a higher runoff coefficient near 0.75 or so, run that flow through the pond with an outlet structure which would be something like a 5' wide weir wall 2' above the bottom of pond and a 12" hole cut into it at the bottom. Grade the pond to be just big enough to not overtop during certain storms. Boom, done. Find an owner that's cheap enough and an engineer that's shady enough, and those calculations can be butchered. But, that's not even the biggest problem.

Let's take that same site and say that the site slopes towards the state highway for quite some distance. Even if the site isn't in a floodplain, something is going to have to be done with the water that is coming from behind the property towards the gas station. You can grade a ditch on the property or pick up the flow and put it in a storm drain or some combination thereof. Now, take the same owner who doesn't want to spend money and try sizing a pipe or channel to carry the flow for a storm that has a 1% chance every year of occuring (the 100 year event) especially when that isn't what the ordinances of the municipality governing the development require. It's easy to end up with a situation where the pipe is designed for something smaller like a 10 year event and the analysis of the 100 year event consists of.... well, there's a 0.5' curb protecting the building from any storm runoff that gets to it. The pipe can handle 75% of the 100 year flow and the curb will handle the rest. There's no good model to analyze those scenarios. So, what happens is inevitably a hay bale gets caught in the pipe backing it up and runoff flows into the building.

Extrapolate that scenario to subdivisions, warehouses, strip malls, etc that are much larger in scale and the drainage systems are more complex. It's not hard to find a subdivision where the drainage system, even if working properly and protecting lots from the 100 year flows has a couple houses where the developer simply didn't pay attention and didn't build the house to a high enough elevation...especially in houston where it's flat as a pancake and bringing in fill costs money.

All of that is localized flooding and completely outside FEMA's control. Looking at the map of the tax day flood, there certainly seem to be a plethora of those.

Then, there's total rainfall which contributes to the flows FEMa produces. They use a variety of methods, but all of them account for the actual rainfall, not just the intensity. But, that's not to excuse FEMA. They publish the maps, but they rarely produce them instead relying on cities and developers to do that. And, it should be noted that most people will fight tooth and nail against being put IN a floodplain because then it requires flood insurance. So, it's not that government employees are lazy, but there's no real advantage to them for trying to increase the floodplain elevation even if it is the right thing to do. I think we talked about this a while ago when looking at all the money Austin is having to spend to buy property in the floodplain. It's much tougher for floodplain administrators in smaller, less wealthy cities to make the argument to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars to model their waterways accurately, place citizens who don't want it into the floodplain, and then possibly start buying those properties especially when there's not a clear use for the property. Sure, large developments that get put into a floodplain can be purchases and turned into a park, but what about the 35 half acre lots along a mile of river that aren't connected and don't have any real value? The right thing to do and the hard thing to do are usually the same. FEMA could certainly take a more active role in this and perhaps purchase any house along a floodplain but above the base flood elevation that floods due to the waterway rising more than predicted in the maps. This would encourage them to get their maps corrected. Further, it would prevent home owners from being in a [expletive] position where they can't get flood insurance but are likely to flood. Further, they could hire consultants, use their own consultants, or simply do the models themselves. And, of course, they could do a better job of keeping the floodrates accurate. Not to say they should be designing to storms like Harvey which are off the charts. But, I think they could certainly take a look at the flowrates they provide.

Post Reply