He's just trying to piss you off.heyzeus wrote:Wtf is he even trying to say?
For the record, as if it even needs saying, there are no anti-fascist activities during the worst natural disaster in state history.
Hurricane Harvey
- Joe Shlabotnik
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 24296
- Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
- Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
- Contact:
Re: Hurricane Harvey
- obucard
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 8182
- Joined: April 18 06, 11:04 pm
- Location: Central AR
Re: Hurricane Harvey
Some people are compelled to make everything political.heyzeus wrote:Wtf is he even trying to say?
For the record, as if it even needs saying, there are no anti-fascist activities during the worst natural disaster in state history.
- MrCrowesGarden
- 'Burb Boy
- Posts: 24841
- Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
- Location: Out of the Loop
Re: Hurricane Harvey
'Member when it was counterproductive to call him a garbage human being?
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: Hurricane Harvey
rise another 12 feet??? As in 10 plus 2 with an f, 2 e's, and a t??? Holy moly.heyzeus wrote:If you see images of the flooding downtown, consider that that water is expected to rise another 12 feet tonight.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Hurricane Harvey
Lives matter first, but can't help but think of all that stuff that will be under water - refineries, landfills. What an environmental mess.
Nothing like this, but the Meramec has a historic flood every other year now - and debris gets scattered everywhere. Barrels. One of my favorite trails had an RV dropped along it. A hot tub was on another from floods. If the flood is big enough though, it scours the typical shoreline clean.
Nothing like this, but the Meramec has a historic flood every other year now - and debris gets scattered everywhere. Barrels. One of my favorite trails had an RV dropped along it. A hot tub was on another from floods. If the flood is big enough though, it scours the typical shoreline clean.
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43343
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Hurricane Harvey
About to get worse. Major dam in west Houston has to start releasing or else fail. Water is going to rise 4-6" per hour downtown as a result.
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: Hurricane Harvey
This was a good thread explaining the risks of evacuating. Click the time stamp to see the whole thing. There was no easy choice and back when they would have had to decide, the forecast was less. Also: many freeways are designed to act as flood relief...i.e. they flood by design in this situation. Having thousands of cars on them was not a good idea.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Hurricane Harvey
Sure seems like the FEMA "100 year" floodplain maps are seriously deficient.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Insane is an understatement. Touching briefly on this from a design perspective, Harvey is so far outside typical storm parameters that it's impossible to say what will happen. Well, I take that back calculations can be ran and everything, but there's no historical data that will approximate what the downstream levels will be. And, without knowing that, it's going to tough to nail down what will happen upstream.
I'm not big into hydrology design, we usually sub the heavy lifting out if needed, but I'll do a lot of site design and runoff calculations. And, the way it's handled almost everywhere I've ever been is to detain the flows for the lower year storm events (the ones that are more likely and have less intensity) and provide a safe bypass for the major storm events (that are less likely and having more intensity).
But, just to give some quick numbers. The highest intensity anyone will ever use to analyze the bypass is 10 inches/hour. If site site/drainage system can handle runoff from a storm event that drops 10 inches in an hour, then it's going to be fine in an isolated event. But, this isn't an isolated event which is the problem. FEMA and hydrologists use empirical 24 hour rainfall events to calculate flows. And, FEMA uses those flow rates along with the topographic cross sections of streams to issue their flood maps. Harvey is going to do 3 things that are unique. The first, and least unique, is it's going to approach if not surpass the historical rainfall data for a 24 hour event. The second is it's going to create a surge that immediately increases the downstream water surface elevation of the rivers/lakes/ponds/bayous to which the watershed drains. And, 3rd, and most unique, it's going to approach if not surpass the historical rainfall data for the 24 hour event for multiple days in a row, if not a week.
In short, I'm not a hydrologist, but I know enough to know that this storm is going to create major flooding which I think everyone knows anyway. But, there's a little background on why it's going to be so bad.
I feel terrible for everyone that is affected by this as it's going to be a [expletive] show. My inlaws live in Houston and I told them to get out Friday when I saw the predictions, but they of course did not.
https://www.texastribune.org/2017/08/25 ... oded-past/
The maps of Hurricane Allison, and perhaps more tellingly from 2015 and 2016 flooding events, all show large scale flood damage well outside the 100 year contours. Perhaps that is related to a local rainfall stuff that's hard to model? Or just underestimation of the volumes? Is there some kind of trigger that forces a redo of data gathering to put together new maps?
Also enjoyed this local color:
Some local officials flat-out disagree with the scientific evidence that shows development has worsened the effects of big storms. Mike Talbott, the former longtime head of the local flood control agency, told The Texas Tribune and ProPublica last year that large-scale public works projects — like drainage basins — are reversing all the effects of Houston’s recent growth (His successor shares that view).
“You need to find some better experts,” Talbott said. When asked for names, he would only say, “starting here, with me.”
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Hurricane Harvey
It's not hard to model. My guess is the flow rates they use are not sufficient. The way the maps are made is pretty straightforward. FEMA has established flow rates. I don't know where these come from, but every time I've submitted map revisions, FEMA provides the flows and you don't even think about changing them. They also, most of the time, provide the downstream water elevations. So, say you want to change a stream channel. FEMA will provide the flow rates for the proposed location(s) and the water surface elevations at the downstream limits. All this information is put into their program called HEC RAS which is really a pretty good program for as basic as it is. Engineers can then change the cross sections of the stream where changes are being made. So, the program has the cross sections and builds a 3d model. It has the flow rates and it has the downstream water surface elevations. Then it just iterates the energy equation between cross sections and spits out the water surface elevations at the new cross sections.Arthur Dent wrote:Sure seems like the FEMA "100 year" floodplain maps are seriously deficient.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Insane is an understatement. Touching briefly on this from a design perspective, Harvey is so far outside typical storm parameters that it's impossible to say what will happen. Well, I take that back calculations can be ran and everything, but there's no historical data that will approximate what the downstream levels will be. And, without knowing that, it's going to tough to nail down what will happen upstream.
I'm not big into hydrology design, we usually sub the heavy lifting out if needed, but I'll do a lot of site design and runoff calculations. And, the way it's handled almost everywhere I've ever been is to detain the flows for the lower year storm events (the ones that are more likely and have less intensity) and provide a safe bypass for the major storm events (that are less likely and having more intensity).
But, just to give some quick numbers. The highest intensity anyone will ever use to analyze the bypass is 10 inches/hour. If site site/drainage system can handle runoff from a storm event that drops 10 inches in an hour, then it's going to be fine in an isolated event. But, this isn't an isolated event which is the problem. FEMA and hydrologists use empirical 24 hour rainfall events to calculate flows. And, FEMA uses those flow rates along with the topographic cross sections of streams to issue their flood maps. Harvey is going to do 3 things that are unique. The first, and least unique, is it's going to approach if not surpass the historical rainfall data for a 24 hour event. The second is it's going to create a surge that immediately increases the downstream water surface elevation of the rivers/lakes/ponds/bayous to which the watershed drains. And, 3rd, and most unique, it's going to approach if not surpass the historical rainfall data for the 24 hour event for multiple days in a row, if not a week.
In short, I'm not a hydrologist, but I know enough to know that this storm is going to create major flooding which I think everyone knows anyway. But, there's a little background on why it's going to be so bad.
I feel terrible for everyone that is affected by this as it's going to be a [expletive] show. My inlaws live in Houston and I told them to get out Friday when I saw the predictions, but they of course did not.
https://www.texastribune.org/2017/08/25 ... oded-past/
The maps of Hurricane Allison, and perhaps more tellingly from 2015 and 2016 flooding events, all show large scale flood damage well outside the 100 year contours. Perhaps that is related to a local rainfall stuff that's hard to model? Or just underestimation of the volumes? Is there some kind of trigger that forces a redo of data gathering to put together new maps?
Also enjoyed this local color:
Some local officials flat-out disagree with the scientific evidence that shows development has worsened the effects of big storms. Mike Talbott, the former longtime head of the local flood control agency, told The Texas Tribune and ProPublica last year that large-scale public works projects — like drainage basins — are reversing all the effects of Houston’s recent growth (His successor shares that view).
“You need to find some better experts,” Talbott said. When asked for names, he would only say, “starting here, with me.”
The flow rates being wrong is the most likely culprit for the modelling being wrong, but it should be noted if the downstream water surface elevations are too low then that will lower water surfaces all the way along the channel as well. HEC RAS is a pretty widely used and accepted program. And, it's easy to verify if anyone wanted to wasted a lot of time.
It also should be noted that if you're submitting to FEMA to change a map/improve a channel, the Corps of Engineers will almost assuredly claim the stream as a water of the US which severely prohibits what work can be done in the channel. It's a real regulatory nightmare to try to do even basic stuff. I'm working on a project now where a guy wants to create decorative water features in a stream that has about 6" of water flowing through an 8' wide channel during most low flow events. In the summer it will run dry periodically. But, for him to put in some boulders and channelize the flow to create little features would cost $200k for disturbing about 1,000 feet of the stream. If a municipality wants to concrete in 2 miles of channel to improve the drainage, good luck.
But, I don't know how they calc the flow rates so it is tough to criticize them.

