car advice
-
Diddy
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3583
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:45 pm
Re: car advice
Sometimes repairs are cheaper then a car payment. It may not make the most sense bto put more money into something then it's worth but there's no guarantee your not going to have repairs on whatever you buy either. I've had a couple older vehicles I've had to put more money then they were worth into knowing it was a sunk cost, but it kept me out of a payment and saved me money over the course of a pretty short time.
That sounds like a lot for the replacement engine. Does that include the swap? Most salvage yards I've felt with a negotiable. I don't know anything about that particular engine though.
That sounds like a lot for the replacement engine. Does that include the swap? Most salvage yards I've felt with a negotiable. I don't know anything about that particular engine though.
-
Diddy
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3583
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:45 pm
Re: car advice
Why did the engine go out at 150,000? Maintenance issue or something that could also be an issue on the replacement? You can send oil samples off for an analysis of the replacement issue pretty cheaply.
- Swirls
- gone fission
- Posts: 8299
- Joined: December 11 07, 4:15 pm
- Location: South Korea
Re: car advice
The obvious caveat to this is that if it's a diesel engine, it's just past being broken in at 100,000 miles... That's not the case here, though.cardinalkarp wrote:I would heavily suggest NOT buying a replacement motor w/ 108,000 miles on it. I'm sure service history for it is non-existent, and unless well taken care of 100k + engines could fail at any time and put you right back in the same situation. Not only that, at 140k miles other issues are going to arise w/ the suspension & steering components just do to normal wear.
It sucks that you've put $1,500 in the car the past year, but your best bet will be to either trade it in on a new vehicle (and they MIGHT give you $500-1,000 for it). If a salvage yard is only going to give you $100 for it, like you said, it might be best to just call Goodwill and see what kind of donation/tax write-off you can get for the car. Since it's not running they'll pick it up and tow it off for no charge.
- IMADreamer
- Has an anecdote about a townie he overheard.
- Posts: 12911
- Joined: December 6 10, 1:09 am
- Location: Illinois
Re: car advice
cardinalkarp wrote:I would heavily suggest NOT buying a replacement motor w/ 108,000 miles on it. I'm sure service history for it is non-existent, and unless well taken care of 100k + engines could fail at any time and put you right back in the same situation. Not only that, at 140k miles other issues are going to arise w/ the suspension & steering components just do to normal wear.
It sucks that you've put $1,500 in the car the past year, but your best bet will be to either trade it in on a new vehicle (and they MIGHT give you $500-1,000 for it). If a salvage yard is only going to give you $100 for it, like you said, it might be best to just call Goodwill and see what kind of donation/tax write-off you can get for the car. Since it's not running they'll pick it up and tow it off for no charge.
I agree with almost all of this. No way am I buying a used engine with 100k plus on the clock unless I'm completely going to rebuild that motor myself. There are just too many variables and while 100k is not a lot on a modern car it's not exactly a young motor either.
I'd figure out how to get something with cash or worst case scenario go get a loan for a new car and just be frugal with your purchase. If you shop smart you can get some pretty nice new or slightly used cars for a great deal. Plus it's winter time, the dealerships will be fighting for you to buy from them.
[expletive] goodwill though. Find someone else to donate it to or you know find someone to buy it because I guarantee there is someone who will pay more than 100 to it. Being charitable is great, but you can do that down the road.
- cardinalkarp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 18753
- Joined: May 4 06, 8:44 am
Re: car advice
Well, it was the salvage yard that was willing to give $100 for it....I haven't done any research to find out what kind of tax write-off a car donation would be.IMADreamer wrote:cardinalkarp wrote:I would heavily suggest NOT buying a replacement motor w/ 108,000 miles on it. I'm sure service history for it is non-existent, and unless well taken care of 100k + engines could fail at any time and put you right back in the same situation. Not only that, at 140k miles other issues are going to arise w/ the suspension & steering components just do to normal wear.
It sucks that you've put $1,500 in the car the past year, but your best bet will be to either trade it in on a new vehicle (and they MIGHT give you $500-1,000 for it). If a salvage yard is only going to give you $100 for it, like you said, it might be best to just call Goodwill and see what kind of donation/tax write-off you can get for the car. Since it's not running they'll pick it up and tow it off for no charge.
I agree with almost all of this. No way am I buying a used engine with 100k plus on the clock unless I'm completely going to rebuild that motor myself. There are just too many variables and while 100k is not a lot on a modern car it's not exactly a young motor either.
I'd figure out how to get something with cash or worst case scenario go get a loan for a new car and just be frugal with your purchase. If you shop smart you can get some pretty nice new or slightly used cars for a great deal. Plus it's winter time, the dealerships will be fighting for you to buy from them.
[expletive] goodwill though. Find someone else to donate it to or you know find someone to buy it because I guarantee there is someone who will pay more than 100 to it. Being charitable is great, but you can do that down the road.
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: car advice
No, I won't get the replacement engine. I knew all along that would be a stupid idea, but I couldn't quite stop considering it because of my recent sunk costs with tires and brakes.
Old engine died because it was suddenly out of oil. I was due for an oil change, but not grossly overdue. Don't think it was burning oil, and wasn't previously aware of a leak. So I don't know what happened. But the shop said it only had a 1/2 quart left and that the engine is toast.
Still not sure what I'm going to do - cheap-ish short term stop gap, or something more.
IMA made a good point about dealers wanting business now. We got a great deal on our van last January.
Old engine died because it was suddenly out of oil. I was due for an oil change, but not grossly overdue. Don't think it was burning oil, and wasn't previously aware of a leak. So I don't know what happened. But the shop said it only had a 1/2 quart left and that the engine is toast.
Still not sure what I'm going to do - cheap-ish short term stop gap, or something more.
IMA made a good point about dealers wanting business now. We got a great deal on our van last January.
- JoeMcKim
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 9248
- Joined: September 8 09, 10:56 pm
- Location: South County, St. Louis
Re: car advice
It's not a good idea to spend that much money on a car with that many miles and years on it. You don't want to accept the fact that you're not going to get that much money for trading it in, well just consider you had the car for a long time and got your moneys worth on the car already. To just spend that much money on an engine that costs more then the value of the car isn't a good idea. You'd be much better off spending that money on a down payment of a new car.
Last year I got a 2008 Mazda 6 for $7300 so if you still want that same brand of car you can still buy a relatively cheap newer version of the same car.
Try to not think of a car as an investment since they're not they're just giant money pits, you're paying for the right to have the freedom to get around wherever and whenever you want.
Last year I got a 2008 Mazda 6 for $7300 so if you still want that same brand of car you can still buy a relatively cheap newer version of the same car.
Try to not think of a car as an investment since they're not they're just giant money pits, you're paying for the right to have the freedom to get around wherever and whenever you want.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: car advice
My 04 Nissan Altima has a rusted out undercarriage. There is a foot sized hole in floorboard driverside and spreading (too many years of gravel road I guess) Professional and personal assessment -it is kaput
Looking to spend up to 16k - for a used midsized sedan . Preferably below 50k miles 2014 and later. Where does that leave me. Chevy Malibu? Cruze. Another Nissan?
Any thoughts on Carmax? Since in a pinch, no patience for used car sales people. Nominal trade in.
Thanks for any thoughts.
Looking to spend up to 16k - for a used midsized sedan . Preferably below 50k miles 2014 and later. Where does that leave me. Chevy Malibu? Cruze. Another Nissan?
Any thoughts on Carmax? Since in a pinch, no patience for used car sales people. Nominal trade in.
Thanks for any thoughts.
- cardinalkarp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 18753
- Joined: May 4 06, 8:44 am
Re: car advice
I love my Mazda 6. You might be able to find a 2014/15 Touring w/ under 50k for that price range. If you can find a 15 go w/ that as there were some upgrades after the first model year of the new body design (14).Freed Roger wrote:My 04 Nissan Altima has a rusted out undercarriage. There is a foot sized hole in floorboard driverside and spreading (too many years of gravel road I guess) Professional and personal assessment -it is kaput
Looking to spend up to 16k - for a used midsized sedan . Preferably below 50k miles 2014 and later. Where does that leave me. Chevy Malibu? Cruze. Another Nissan?
Any thoughts on Carmax? Since in a pinch, no patience for used car sales people. Nominal trade in.
Thanks for any thoughts.
-
Diddy
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3583
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:45 pm
Re: car advice
You might check VW for all of these used TDI cars that they are buying back if your fine with a diesel that gets great fuel mileage. They are being advertised and are a much better car then the Malibu IMOFreed Roger wrote:My 04 Nissan Altima has a rusted out undercarriage. There is a foot sized hole in floorboard driverside and spreading (too many years of gravel road I guess) Professional and personal assessment -it is kaput
Looking to spend up to 16k - for a used midsized sedan . Preferably below 50k miles 2014 and later. Where does that leave me. Chevy Malibu? Cruze. Another Nissan?
Any thoughts on Carmax? Since in a pinch, no patience for used car sales people. Nominal trade in.
Thanks for any thoughts.


