Yeah that seemed strange. Then again, it's the FBI so the entire thing could be made up.MrCrowesGarden wrote:There's nearly two thousand deaths caused by firearms where it doesn't state what kind of firearm it is.Tim wrote:For certain? I mean, according to the above figure.lukethedrifter wrote:Can you say that for certain?
Tim wrote:Hands + feet more deadly than "rifles" in 2014
Orlando shooting
- Tim
- Consider him admonished
- Posts: 8320
- Joined: March 25 15, 9:59 am
- Location: The South
Re: Orlando shooting
- Tim
- Consider him admonished
- Posts: 8320
- Joined: March 25 15, 9:59 am
- Location: The South
Re: Orlando shooting
http://reason.com/blog/2016/06/17/yes-i ... nds-and-fe
UPDATE: Commenters seem to want to assume that the "type not stated" category might be outrageously more overweighted toward rifles than are the known categories, and then weighted toward that subcategory of rifles that frightened people call "assault rifles."
In the known homicide data, rifles account for about 1/22 of the number of homicides as do handguns. I assumed lacking other evidence that the ratios would likely be roughly equal, meaning we could likely assume around 89 might be added to the "rifles" count, again a far larger category than the scary ones people want to ban.
One would have to assume that for some reason the "type not stated" is in fact mysteriously weighted toward rifles, and among that category "assault weapons," at a level four times that in the listed categories to get rifles—again, a larger category—to equal hands and fists as a murder tool.
UPDATE: Commenters seem to want to assume that the "type not stated" category might be outrageously more overweighted toward rifles than are the known categories, and then weighted toward that subcategory of rifles that frightened people call "assault rifles."
In the known homicide data, rifles account for about 1/22 of the number of homicides as do handguns. I assumed lacking other evidence that the ratios would likely be roughly equal, meaning we could likely assume around 89 might be added to the "rifles" count, again a far larger category than the scary ones people want to ban.
One would have to assume that for some reason the "type not stated" is in fact mysteriously weighted toward rifles, and among that category "assault weapons," at a level four times that in the listed categories to get rifles—again, a larger category—to equal hands and fists as a murder tool.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Orlando shooting
I did not realize libertarians were gun fetishists.
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: Orlando shooting
This was really interesting....
The Gun Control We Deserve
It's pretty long. It says we have a hodge podge of gun laws that vary widely from state to state. The basic gist of it is the "minimalist" states that restrict access do so by making it more expensive to own guns. So guns basically get restricted by class. The "maximalist" states make it as easy as possible, but this is still "controlled" by the state. This is somewhat of an oversimplification (since it doesn't address whether criminals, wife beaters, etc should be able to own guns)....but there is some truth to it too.
Then he lays out 3 scenarios that seem somewhat plausible, and they aren't mutally exclsuive. Parts of each could happen in some form or other.
Scenario 1 is the thing I've been hoping for - that we focus less on unpredictable mass shootings and more on suicides, gang violence, domestic violence, etc. He calls this the "it gets better" scenario.
Scenario 2 is "the neoliberal dystopia" where we only focus on the mass shootings and we basically find a way for gun makers, people teaching gun safety classes, "smart gun technologies", etc create new ways to profit from guns. This way it looks like we did something about guns but the main thing we did was make some people rich.
Scenario 3 is called the “atavistic, racist carceral security state comes home to roost” scenario. This is pretty chilling and will make me change even more how I approach this issue. Basically he says that it's not an accident that it is mainly suburban white folks calling for restrictions on guns, right at the same time that black activism is on the rise. There are 6 million Americans that own 10 or more guns, and almost all of them are white. They've got theirs and they either don't want or don't care if minorities ever get theirs. He also pointed out that when the assault weapons ban was put in place in 1994 it was part of a larger piece of legislation:
The Gun Control We Deserve
It's pretty long. It says we have a hodge podge of gun laws that vary widely from state to state. The basic gist of it is the "minimalist" states that restrict access do so by making it more expensive to own guns. So guns basically get restricted by class. The "maximalist" states make it as easy as possible, but this is still "controlled" by the state. This is somewhat of an oversimplification (since it doesn't address whether criminals, wife beaters, etc should be able to own guns)....but there is some truth to it too.
Then he lays out 3 scenarios that seem somewhat plausible, and they aren't mutally exclsuive. Parts of each could happen in some form or other.
Scenario 1 is the thing I've been hoping for - that we focus less on unpredictable mass shootings and more on suicides, gang violence, domestic violence, etc. He calls this the "it gets better" scenario.
Scenario 2 is "the neoliberal dystopia" where we only focus on the mass shootings and we basically find a way for gun makers, people teaching gun safety classes, "smart gun technologies", etc create new ways to profit from guns. This way it looks like we did something about guns but the main thing we did was make some people rich.
Scenario 3 is called the “atavistic, racist carceral security state comes home to roost” scenario. This is pretty chilling and will make me change even more how I approach this issue. Basically he says that it's not an accident that it is mainly suburban white folks calling for restrictions on guns, right at the same time that black activism is on the rise. There are 6 million Americans that own 10 or more guns, and almost all of them are white. They've got theirs and they either don't want or don't care if minorities ever get theirs. He also pointed out that when the assault weapons ban was put in place in 1994 it was part of a larger piece of legislation:
That legislation allocated $9.7 billion to new prison construction and gave money to states to pursue harsher sentencing guidelines while eliminating prison education programs—effectively writing a check for the New Jim Crow to leap into the 21st century. That crime bill was unprecedentedly sprawling, but bundled regulation of guns and targeting of minorities by those in power was hardly new. Recall the so-called Mississippi Plan of 1875, whereby white Southern Democrats sought to simultaneously disarm and disenfranchise freed blacks, and New York City’s Stop and Frisk program, which many liberals originally supported when it was presented to them as a way of getting guns off the street.
- Tim
- Consider him admonished
- Posts: 8320
- Joined: March 25 15, 9:59 am
- Location: The South
Re: Orlando shooting
Well that's painting with a broad brush, but yeah probably more so than GOPlukethedrifter wrote:I did not realize libertarians were gun fetishists.
- JoeMcKim
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 9248
- Joined: September 8 09, 10:56 pm
- Location: South County, St. Louis
Re: Orlando shooting
This joke might be wayyyyyyy too early but I'm going to say it anyways.
A muslim guy walks into a gay bar, bartender asks him what he'll have. Shots for everyone.
A muslim guy walks into a gay bar, bartender asks him what he'll have. Shots for everyone.
- Smith Corks One
- All-Star
- Posts: 1426
- Joined: April 27 10, 11:08 pm
Re: Orlando shooting
What the [expletive] is wrong with you?JoeMcKim wrote:This joke might be wayyyyyyy too early but I'm going to say it anyways.
A muslim guy walks into a gay bar, bartender asks him what he'll have. Shots for everyone.
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Orlando shooting
Oh get off your high horse
- Schlich
- Don't tone police me bro!
- Posts: 10841
- Joined: July 1 06, 7:24 pm
- Location: Lost in the Cloud
Re: Orlando shooting
The current fringe nature of the party makes it so that the gun fetishists are a bit more visible. If the LP ever becomes mainstream I can imagine them being reasonable on the subject. After all, one surefire way to take someone's liberty is to shoot them.Tim wrote:Well that's painting with a broad brush, but yeah probably more so than GOPlukethedrifter wrote:I did not realize libertarians were gun fetishists.
- Myles
- Everyday Player
- Posts: 407
- Joined: July 10 14, 1:41 pm
Re: Orlando shooting
I don't understand your point. You think him owning 4 guns and going to a gun range once a month defines "addicted"? Are you addicted to playing softball if you play once a month?dmarx114 wrote:but owning 4 guns and going to the range once a month strikes me as someone who is addicted to shooting their guns. You seem to be making the argument that you need your guns for protection, but I don't really believe that if you're shooting the guns as often as you say you are.TGantz wrote:I have two 9mm pistols, a Mosin Nagant 91/30 bolt action rifle, and an out-of-use Mauser from 1893.dmarx114 wrote:I think your middle ground stance is fine. I would sign up for that today.TGantz wrote:This is why nothing is ever done. One video of some red necks firing a what should be illegal gun in the woods, and we're lumping 40% of households in America into one, radical category. It's eerily similar to how Trump supporters are lumping all Muslims into being terrorists.
For anything to change, there has to be a middle ground. Reasonable gun owners that understand there are going to be regulations for buying guns, and reasonable people that dislike guns that understand they are a part of our culture and not leaving completely despite how sick they think it is.
I just don't need to hear about theis 2nd amendment stuff. If you truly, truly, truly need a gun to make you feel safe from car jackers, fine, go through the background check, 8 hour course, training, and pay licensing fees (all things you reasonably suggest).
But why don't people in Japan have this car jacking fear? Same question for Australia. Why is it that USA has all the criminals and you need to arm yourself to feel safe?
How many guns do you have? How often do you use it/them?
I shoot my pistols a little less than once a month at the range, the rifle less often because I have surplus ammo that is steel corded and will go through walls.
Japan and Australia weren't founded on the principle of citizens having guns. It's a different culture. The guns are already here, and they won't be leaving. Don't bring a knife to a gun fight.
To me it sounds like he owns a few guns and likes to keep his skills up. I assume he also enjoys it. I have a few guns and I wish I would carve the time out to go to the range once a month. I shoot my shotgun about once a month, but I do that in the back yard.





