Orlando shooting

Chat about non-baseball topics. No political discussions!
Post Reply
User avatar
MrCrowesGarden
'Burb Boy
Posts: 24841
Joined: July 9 06, 11:33 am
Location: Out of the Loop

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by MrCrowesGarden »

I'll say that I think we'd be safer without guns entirely, but I know that's not feasible. I'd gladly take some sort of meaningful compromise, but I run into the same BS arguments.

Michael
GRB Founder
Posts: 35304
Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
Location: Chicago, IL
Contact:

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by Michael »

TGantz wrote: I hate the muskets argument for the 2nd amendment. It's not just about British tyranny in the 1700's. The 2nd amendment is so staunchly defended because of what it represents. It's the only amendment that actually gives the people power over the government, whether it's in their imagination that they could defend themselves or not. The government can take away freedom of speech, and everyone would be like, "Whoa take it easy government." Then they take away the right to vote. At that point, we can defend ourselves from an overreaching government with a revolution. But if they start with the 2nd amendment, there's nothing we can do about the rest of the Constitution and the world turns into the Hunger Games. I'm not saying that it's as black and white as that, but that's the general thought of it from what I hear from extreme gun people.
I think this is reasonable and I'm sympathetic to this argument.
TGantz wrote:My reasoning for wanting to keep the 2nd amendment is for more of a daily use reason. The government can't enforce half of the laws they already have, how are they going to enforce taking guns away from criminals? They can't, which means Average Joe citizen that turns in his pistol is unprotected and car jackings continue to increase. The last several car jackings that have happened in this city have been in places that I frequent, either for home, work, or social life. Criminals are not just taking your wallet and car and leaving, they're killing people even when they comply. I've seen someone get pistol whipped in the face even after they gave up their purse.
For me this is more problematic. There's mounds of data that show guns leads to more death and violence.

If someone thinks all the added death and violence from our current gun laws is worthwhile to fight a possible tyrannical government I completely get it. It's kinda like free speech. Sometimes free speech can suck, but it's an overall huge net positive. However, the argument that we're somehow more safe with guns doesn't resonate with me at all. I wish gun advocates would just say added social cost is justified.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by thrill »

MrCrowesGarden wrote:I'll say that I think we'd be safer without guns entirely, but I know that's not feasible. I'd gladly take some sort of meaningful compromise, but I run into the same BS arguments.
Agree completely. In the absence of realistic gun confiscation strategy, totally cool with starting with background checks and a better standard than the terrorist watch list or the no-fly list. People love to trot out the stupidity of those but to me that just means we need a more efficacious methodology for those lists too. Start with checks and work from there. Let's not waste time pretending we're going to start or even end with confiscating private gun ownership for many, many reasons.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by Freed Roger »

Michael wrote: If someone thinks all the added death and violence from our current gun laws is worthwhile to fight a possible tyrannical government I completely get it. .
I don't get that at all. Probably the worst of all the terrible arguments put forth by NRA and 2d amendment extrapolators. And I've seen every Hunger Games movie.

Fighting back against your tyrannical govt would mean every person would need mega-weapons -mandatory (I think some extremists have proposed that btw). Even then, an armed citizenry-even all decked out with body armor, night vision goggles, pimped out assault rifles. could not compete against a govt that has mind-blowing advanced weaponry. Drones, robots, chemical stuff, nukes. - Govt could drop a bomb down a chimney, and with a mass monitoring of citizens, they could write algorithms to figure out which people to single out.

F-15 > AR-15
Last edited by Freed Roger on June 17 16, 10:31 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Schlich
Don't tone police me bro!
Posts: 10841
Joined: July 1 06, 7:24 pm
Location: Lost in the Cloud

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by Schlich »

Freed Roger wrote:
Michael wrote: If someone thinks all the added death and violence from our current gun laws is worthwhile to fight a possible tyrannical government I completely get it. .
I don't get that at all. Probably the worst of all the terrible arguments put forth by NRA and 2d amendment extrapolators. And I've seen every Hunger Games movie.

Fighting back against your tyrannical govt would mean every person would need mega-weapons -mandatory (I think some extremists have proposed that btw). Even then, an armed citizenry-even all decked out with body armor, night vision goggles, pimped out AR-15s could not compete against a govt that has mind-blowing advanced weaponry. Drones, robots, chemical stuff, nukes. - Govt could drop a bomb down a chimney, and with a mass monitoring of citizens, they could write algorithms to figure out which people to single out.
I think it's a little bit more complicated than that.

User avatar
Myles
Everyday Player
Posts: 407
Joined: July 10 14, 1:41 pm

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by Myles »

Freed Roger wrote:
Michael wrote: If someone thinks all the added death and violence from our current gun laws is worthwhile to fight a possible tyrannical government I completely get it. .
I don't get that at all. Probably the worst of all the terrible arguments put forth by NRA and 2d amendment extrapolators. And I've seen every Hunger Games movie.

Fighting back against your tyrannical govt would mean every person would need mega-weapons -mandatory (I think some extremists have proposed that btw). Even then, an armed citizenry-even all decked out with body armor, night vision goggles, pimped out AR-15s could not compete against a govt that has mind-blowing advanced weaponry. Drones, robots, chemical stuff, nukes. - Govt could drop a bomb down a chimney, and with a mass monitoring of citizens, they could write algorithms to figure out which people to single out.
I think it is more of having a "fighting chance". Mostly against local law enforcement. I think you are right that the chances of putting up a successful fight against a full military onslaught are nearly zero. I suspect the thought by these people is that if it is not a full blown attack, and very spread out (the USA is huge), that they may be able to do some damage. I would agree with that. Winning is another matter though.

User avatar
Myles
Everyday Player
Posts: 407
Joined: July 10 14, 1:41 pm

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by Myles »

Schlich wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:
Michael wrote: If someone thinks all the added death and violence from our current gun laws is worthwhile to fight a possible tyrannical government I completely get it. .
I don't get that at all. Probably the worst of all the terrible arguments put forth by NRA and 2d amendment extrapolators. And I've seen every Hunger Games movie.

Fighting back against your tyrannical govt would mean every person would need mega-weapons -mandatory (I think some extremists have proposed that btw). Even then, an armed citizenry-even all decked out with body armor, night vision goggles, pimped out AR-15s could not compete against a govt that has mind-blowing advanced weaponry. Drones, robots, chemical stuff, nukes. - Govt could drop a bomb down a chimney, and with a mass monitoring of citizens, they could write algorithms to figure out which people to single out.
I think it's a little bit more complicated than that.
I agree.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by Freed Roger »

Schlich wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:
Michael wrote: If someone thinks all the added death and violence from our current gun laws is worthwhile to fight a possible tyrannical government I completely get it. .
I don't get that at all. Probably the worst of all the terrible arguments put forth by NRA and 2d amendment extrapolators. And I've seen every Hunger Games movie.

Fighting back against your tyrannical govt would mean every person would need mega-weapons -mandatory (I think some extremists have proposed that btw). Even then, an armed citizenry-even all decked out with body armor, night vision goggles, pimped out AR-15s could not compete against a govt that has mind-blowing advanced weaponry. Drones, robots, chemical stuff, nukes. - Govt could drop a bomb down a chimney, and with a mass monitoring of citizens, they could write algorithms to figure out which people to single out.
I think it's a little bit more complicated than that.
Not sure what you mean Schlich. I'm giving far-fetched examples against a far-fetched argument. the most recent example -Cliven Ammon Bundy armed anti-govt approach doesn't work -even when the govt still has a due process/judicial thing going on.
--------
Somewhat related - I read a book recently - true story of 3 anti-govt guys in the 1990s that most likely were planning to blow up the Glen Canyon dam , got caught stealing a water-tank truck to make the bomb, and killed a cop, followed by manhunt etc etc.

they were home-grown anti US govt terrorists, like McVeigh. How this relates? - it struck me how these guys hated cops, because they are essentially agents of the govt that they hate. Likewise, similar militia-types murdered some cops at Vegas fast food restaurant (IIRC) a few years ago. Now, it seems these same types applaud the military style cops, to put down insurrections by the unrulies in the hoods. What's next for these guys , do they hate the Troops?!

I don't know my point. yeah it's complicated. the armed thyself against the govt argument seems to be the lowest and weakest reason for lax gun laws allowing AR-15 to be bought by the Orlando shooter.
Last edited by Freed Roger on June 17 16, 11:13 am, edited 1 time in total.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by Socnorb11 »

I don't think anyone really thinks they want to or are able to fight a government takeover. That's just lame reasoning from gun-obsessed people as a justification to own cool weapons that are built to kill en masse.

User avatar
Schlich
Don't tone police me bro!
Posts: 10841
Joined: July 1 06, 7:24 pm
Location: Lost in the Cloud

Re: Orlando shooting

Post by Schlich »

Freed Roger wrote:
Schlich wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:
Michael wrote: If someone thinks all the added death and violence from our current gun laws is worthwhile to fight a possible tyrannical government I completely get it. .
I don't get that at all. Probably the worst of all the terrible arguments put forth by NRA and 2d amendment extrapolators. And I've seen every Hunger Games movie.

Fighting back against your tyrannical govt would mean every person would need mega-weapons -mandatory (I think some extremists have proposed that btw). Even then, an armed citizenry-even all decked out with body armor, night vision goggles, pimped out AR-15s could not compete against a govt that has mind-blowing advanced weaponry. Drones, robots, chemical stuff, nukes. - Govt could drop a bomb down a chimney, and with a mass monitoring of citizens, they could write algorithms to figure out which people to single out.
I think it's a little bit more complicated than that.
Not sure what you mean Schlich. I'm giving far-fetched examples against a far-fetched argument. the most recent example -Cliven Ammon Bundy armed anti-govt approach doesn't work -even when the govt still has a due process/judicial thing going on.
--------
Somewhat related - I read a book recently - true story of 3 anti-govt guys in the 1990s that most likely were planning to blow up the Glen Canyon dam , got caught stealing a water-tank truck to make the bomb, and killed a cop, followed by manhunt etc etc.

home-grown American terrorists, like McVeigh. How this relates? - it struck me how these guys hated cops, because they are essentially agents of the govt that they hate. Likewise, similar militia-types murdered some cops at Vegas fast food restaurant (IIRC) a few years ago. Now, it seems these same types like military style cops, to put down insurrections by the unrulies in the hoods. What's next for these guys , do they hate the Troops?!

I don't know my point. yeah it's complicated. the armed thyself against the govt argument seems to be the lowest and weakest reason for lax gun laws allowing AR-15 to be bought by the Orlando shooter.
I think that the usefulness of arms in the hands of the populace during insurrection is proportional to the degree of tyranny involved. If people want to arm themselves in the event of some apocalyptic revolution, I think they're being a little paranoid, but the idea that arms would be useless because our government has nukes (or drones, or whatever) isn't entirely accurate. If the US government dropped a nuke on their home soil you can sure as hell bet that millions of people would be getting their hands on a gun and looking to take over control of those weapons. That's all I'm saying.

Post Reply