2015 NFL Thread

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
User avatar
JL21
NPR & THT Contributor
Posts: 36109
Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
Location: Chocolate City

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by JL21 »

jim wrote:I agree all of this was VERY very unlikely. It would have taken a miracle. I can't find that calculator you referenced.
Here you go:

http://wp.advancedfootballanalytics.com ... bcalc1.php
Let me just ask a question - would you say the game is completely over - 100% sure fired over - if the Cardinals had the ball down 19 on the Panthers 35 yard line with 5:00 left to play?

If your answer is yes, then we will agree to disagree. Because they would be one play way from having it an 12 point game with 4:45 or so to play. Still a big comeback, that's doable.

If your answer is no, that the Cardinals would have an unlikely but non zero probability of winning, then I would say the following:

1) NFL teams run kicks back for TD's on occasion, we would agree this is a possibility. So it's possible that Arizona could return the kick and cut the lead to 19.

2) NFL teams recover onside kicks on occasion. If 1) happened, and 2) happened, you just arrived at a situation where the Cardinals have the ball on the Panthers 40 or so. One play away from an 11 point game.

Again - miracle. I get it. The odds of one of those happening is remote, both in sequence really remote. But I don't see why you would take that chance is you are the Panthers. Just keep playing the game, do everything you can to increase your odds of winning.

2:00, up 25, other team out of times, ball on their 10, 1:30 left - not taking a knee would be a dick move, classless, and not in the spirit of the game. That I would have a problem with, not going for 2 when there was still 5 minutes left in the game.

That's my take on it.
I do think down 19, in Panthers territory/field goal range, is a very different situation from down 25 and taking a kickoff. Down 19 is three scores, one of which can be a field goal. Down 25 is four scores, and you need three TDs and three 2-point conversions. Though even in your 19 point scenario, you're talking about a 1% chance of winning. And as you acknowledge, it's an extremely remote scenario for any of that stuff to happen. And even if they manage to return the kick for a TD, and recover an onside kick, they STILL have to get two touchdowns, two extra points, and a field goal in appx. 4:30 of game clock. And to do that would also mean they'd have to recover at least one, if not two or three, onside kicks.

To recap, this is what we're talking about:

-Kickoff return for TD (19 point lead)
-Recover onside kick
-Score TD (13 point lead)
-Get 2 point conversion (11 point lead)
-Recover onside kick
-Score TD (5 point lead)
-Get 2 point conversion (3 point lead)
-Recover onside kick
- Score TD to win or field goal to tie

in 5 minutes.

User avatar
ndistops
All-Star
Posts: 1289
Joined: November 20 06, 9:00 pm
Location: West Michigan

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by ndistops »

No one on Arizona has said a word about any of this. I'm guessing if anyone had been annoyed by it they would have said so.

Also, Wart, if Carolina had been up 19 with 5 minutes to go, 4th and goal on the 1, the right play would be to go for it. There's little practical difference between being up 19 or 22 (with a FG) in that situation, and NFL teams can score TDs 3 times in 5 minutes. If they're up 25 in the same spot, then maybe it's a different thing.

User avatar
go birds
-go birds
Posts: 32057
Joined: February 5 10, 9:54 am

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by go birds »

#neverforget
Peyton Manning rallied the Colts from a 35-14 deficit with four minutes left in regulation, sending the game into overtime on Ricky Williams' 1-yard touchdown run with 35 seconds to play. Marvin Harrison, who had two touchdown catches, set up the tying score with a 52-yard reception to the Tampa Bay 5.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by jim »

JL21 wrote:
jim wrote:I agree all of this was VERY very unlikely. It would have taken a miracle. I can't find that calculator you referenced.
Here you go:

http://wp.advancedfootballanalytics.com ... bcalc1.php
Let me just ask a question - would you say the game is completely over - 100% sure fired over - if the Cardinals had the ball down 19 on the Panthers 35 yard line with 5:00 left to play?

If your answer is yes, then we will agree to disagree. Because they would be one play way from having it an 12 point game with 4:45 or so to play. Still a big comeback, that's doable.

If your answer is no, that the Cardinals would have an unlikely but non zero probability of winning, then I would say the following:

1) NFL teams run kicks back for TD's on occasion, we would agree this is a possibility. So it's possible that Arizona could return the kick and cut the lead to 19.

2) NFL teams recover onside kicks on occasion. If 1) happened, and 2) happened, you just arrived at a situation where the Cardinals have the ball on the Panthers 40 or so. One play away from an 11 point game.

Again - miracle. I get it. The odds of one of those happening is remote, both in sequence really remote. But I don't see why you would take that chance is you are the Panthers. Just keep playing the game, do everything you can to increase your odds of winning.

2:00, up 25, other team out of times, ball on their 10, 1:30 left - not taking a knee would be a dick move, classless, and not in the spirit of the game. That I would have a problem with, not going for 2 when there was still 5 minutes left in the game.

That's my take on it.
I do think down 19, in Panthers territory/field goal range, is a very different situation from down 25 and taking a kickoff. Down 19 is three scores, one of which can be a field goal. Down 25 is four scores, and you need three TDs and three 2-point conversions. Though even in your 19 point scenario, you're talking about a 1% chance of winning. And as you acknowledge, it's an extremely remote scenario for any of that stuff to happen. And even if they manage to return the kick for a TD, and recover an onside kick, they STILL have to get two touchdowns, two extra points, and a field goal in appx. 4:30 of game clock. And to do that would also mean they'd have to recover at least one, if not two or three, onside kicks.

To recap, this is what we're talking about:

-Kickoff return for TD (19 point lead)
-Recover onside kick
-Score TD (13 point lead)
-Get 2 point conversion (11 point lead)
-Recover onside kick
-Score TD (5 point lead)
-Get 2 point conversion (3 point lead)
-Recover onside kick
- Score TD to win or field goal to tie

in 5 minutes.
Basically. A few too many onside kicks, you could complete the above in about 2 minutes instead of 5, but more or less. Why take the chance?

User avatar
JL21
NPR & THT Contributor
Posts: 36109
Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
Location: Chocolate City

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by JL21 »

wart57 wrote:It is 1 extra point, not really running it up if it is 1 extra point. Hardly a dick move for 1 extra point. If they went for a T.D. on 4th and goal from the 1 up by 19 with 5 minutes left, that is a dick move.

What happens if the Panthers go for the extra point kick, the kick is blocked and AZ returns it for the 2 points. Now it is a 23 point lead - 3 td's with 2 - 2 point conversions and 1 extra point kick ties it, 3 td's with 3 - 2 point conversions win it for AZ.

Still far fetched, but the odds were better for victory if the Panthers go for 2.

All this "dick move" stuff is heavy on assumptions, sometimes, things are just down to the numbers.
Eh... for starters, I'm not going off on some tangent about "class" or "showing respect" or whatever else. That's a separate deal, one that I have nothing to do with. Nor am I worried about anyone's special magical feelings being tromped on. I'm not even really trying to have an argument. But I do like the discussion analytically with jim. And your "blocked extra point returned for 2 points" scenario is about as unlikely as the extra one point the Panthers got being the deciding factor.

The strongest and really only thing I've said is that it's a dick move. And yeah, it's only one point, but they had to go out of their way to get that extra point when they had the game in the bag as close to a lock as you can have. There was next to zero chance Arizona was going to come back. They basically had a free extra point and they said, "Nope, I want two points".

User avatar
JL21
NPR & THT Contributor
Posts: 36109
Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
Location: Chocolate City

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by JL21 »

go birds wrote:#neverforget
Peyton Manning rallied the Colts from a 35-14 deficit with four minutes left in regulation, sending the game into overtime on Ricky Williams' 1-yard touchdown run with 35 seconds to play. Marvin Harrison, who had two touchdown catches, set up the tying score with a 52-yard reception to the Tampa Bay 5.
Worth noting that the Bucs were on their way to 7-9, compared to Cardinals trying to come back on the 15-1 Panthers. Even in that case, the Colts needed 3 scores and no two point conversions (compared to the 4 scores and 3 two-point conversions the Cardinals needed).

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by wart57 »

jim wrote:Where are these thousands at?

I also hope going for two pisses off Peyton Manning so much that he throws a tizzy fit and trips and falls and tears his ACL.
Peyton doesn't need an ACL, Nationwide is on his side.

I hope the Bronco's win, because if they lose, Manning will be back next year wearing an L.A. Rams uniform, if the Bronco's win, he will most likely retire - he needs to hang them up.

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by wart57 »

JL21 wrote:
wart57 wrote:It is 1 extra point, not really running it up if it is 1 extra point. Hardly a dick move for 1 extra point. If they went for a T.D. on 4th and goal from the 1 up by 19 with 5 minutes left, that is a dick move.

What happens if the Panthers go for the extra point kick, the kick is blocked and AZ returns it for the 2 points. Now it is a 23 point lead - 3 td's with 2 - 2 point conversions and 1 extra point kick ties it, 3 td's with 3 - 2 point conversions win it for AZ.

Still far fetched, but the odds were better for victory if the Panthers go for 2.

All this "dick move" stuff is heavy on assumptions, sometimes, things are just down to the numbers.
Eh... for starters, I'm not going off on some tangent about "class" or "showing respect" or whatever else. That's a separate deal, one that I have nothing to do with. Nor am I worried about anyone's special magical feelings being tromped on. I'm not even really trying to have an argument. But I do like the discussion analytically with jim. And your "blocked extra point returned for 2 points" scenario is about as unlikely as the extra one point the Panthers got being the deciding factor.

The strongest and really only thing I've said is that it's a dick move. And yeah, it's only one point, but they had to go out of their way to get that extra point when they had the game in the bag as close to a lock as you can have. There was next to zero chance Arizona was going to come back. They basically had a free extra point and they said, "Nope, I want two points".
An extra point kick was blocked and returned by the Saints against Carolina in December....

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap300000 ... int-return

User avatar
go birds
-go birds
Posts: 32057
Joined: February 5 10, 9:54 am

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by go birds »

JL21 wrote:
go birds wrote:#neverforget
Peyton Manning rallied the Colts from a 35-14 deficit with four minutes left in regulation, sending the game into overtime on Ricky Williams' 1-yard touchdown run with 35 seconds to play. Marvin Harrison, who had two touchdown catches, set up the tying score with a 52-yard reception to the Tampa Bay 5.
Worth noting that the Bucs were on their way to 7-9, compared to Cardinals trying to come back on the 15-1 Panthers. Even in that case, the Colts needed 3 scores and no two point conversions (compared to the 4 scores and 3 two-point conversions the Cardinals needed).
yea i mean, the deficit is larger (not by much) but it's not completely unrealistic.

the cardinals had the best offense in the league, if im not mistaken.

User avatar
JL21
NPR & THT Contributor
Posts: 36109
Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
Location: Chocolate City

Re: 2015 NFL Thread

Post by JL21 »

wart57 wrote:
An extra point kick was blocked and returned by the Saints against Carolina in December....

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap300000 ... int-return
Yes. The first time in NFL history.

Post Reply