avery is much smarter than he lets on. 70 IQ my ass. His nephew, Brendan definetely. At one point, Steve Avery mentions he is always being recorded from jailhouse. And he seems to be playing to an audience in most the recordings. My god the 90 percent of the judicial system people seem like loathesome asshats
I agree. How the heck do you first keep a girlfriend while you are in jail for a number of years. Then after that one falls apart, how do you meet and make a new girlfriend??? I was blown away he was able to maintain these kind of relationships while in jail. He might not be book smart but he has a lot of social smarts.
the new girlfriend in episode 10 made me more uneasy about Avery too. Seems like predators have this unusual ability to charm. This isn't the silver bullet or anything, just adds a part to my overall sense about Avery.
I've mulled this series over for a few days - my gut says Avery is guilty, but not without doubt. My utter disgust for the justice system corruption and failures in this process, can't shake this sense that he did it. I am fairly sure the Manitowoc police helped the case along with evidence planting (the keys, blood in car, the bullet maybe) - and the murder narrative put forth doesn't make sense as a result.
However, I can't fathom the police were able to plant a car, and her bones on the property of the last guy to see her. That would require too much intimate knowledge of the murder.
It seemed like the "just" result of the trial would have been a hung jury/mistrial - and then do it over the right way (new venue, proscutors, and without the key, the blood allowed as evidence-and any remnants of Brendan's story). I'm not sure how juries work though - I don't think you get to vote hung, it is either guilty or not.
the case against Brendan (at least as presented in the series) was incredibly weak. No physical evidence. No witnesses, effectively. A public defender Kachinsky that plotted against him. I feel Kachinsky and his investigator are more of a danger to society than Brendan.
Kratz should be in jail as well.
He may not be the brightest bulb on the tree, but to park the car of the person you just killed in you salvage yard when you have access to a crusher is something a 10 year old could figure out. All of it was planted....the car, the person who FOUND the car somehow locates the car in 10 minutes (as its parked right no the perimeter on a lot that contains 40 acres of vehicles, the blood in the car, the key in the house, all of this crap alone is enough to find that he's not guilty.
I am not sure about the car. yeah, the crushers are there. Doesn't seem logical, but murder isn't either. Steven seems exceedingly smart about some things, not others. Maybe he thought, the crushers would be first place they'd look for traces and if they traced the car to a crusher, he would have to know he's done. Or perhaps crusher use would require his Dad or brother know about it's use.
the brother situation, I wish they explored that a bit more. Seems like he disappears in later episodes, after he resigned to be pissed that this notoriety hurt business.
to plant the car and bones there, would mean police hauled it in from elsewhere, and knew someone else murdered her, or possibly they murdered her. They'd have to know the real murderer wasn't going to show up somewhere down the line.
Anyway, I can't really argue the case for the prosecution because they are all so damn [expletive] up and corrupt, but still get the vibe from Steven.
for those that have finished (this was lifted from the comments on the avclub--i did not do this leg work):
"There is supposedly evidence against him that was not shown in the documentary..."
Yes, I'm always curious about what gets left out of these presentations. Even a 10-part documentary as painstakingly (and excellently) assembled as this one can't hope to show us everything. And a certain amount of bias or slant will enter any presentation. (For instance, the filmmakers clearly developed a tight relationship with the Averys, while noting in the media that the Halbach family declined to participate in filmed private interviews.)
Here are a few allegations (culled from the press and available legal docs) that aren't included in MaM, and may be less flattering to an Avery (and/or Dassey) innocence view:
- FALSE NAME / SPECIAL REQUEST
"Steven Avery called Auto Trader magazine to schedule an appointment with a photographer. 'Send the girl who was out here before,' he told the magazine, using his sister’s first initial and last name – 'B. Janda.'"
SOURCE: http://www.milwaukeemag.com/20...
Additionally, I've read that the affidavit to support the state's request on bail mentions that Halbach had been to the Avery property numerous times in 2005 to take pictures for Auto Trader Magazine, for which she worked as a freelance photographer. Halbach allegedly complained to her manager, Angela M. Schuster, that on previous trips to Avery's property he answered the door wearing only a towel, the affidavit says. (Regrettably I do not have a source link to the affidavit.)
- BLEACHED JEANS?
Within the criminal complaint against Brendan Dassey, it's alleged that Brendan's Mom asked him about stains on his jeans the night of Teresa Halbach's disappearance, and that Brendan supposedly said the stains had resulted from helping Steve Avery bleach the floor of his garage. These jeans were supposedly taken into evidence:
"On February 27, 2006, your complainant [Investigator Fassbender] spoke with [Brendan's mother] Barb Janda. Barb Janda stated on October 31, 2005, when Brendan Dassey returned from Steven Avery's residence, Dassey had bleach stains on his jeans. Barb Janda asked Dassey what happened to his jeans, he told her that his jeans were bleached while he was helping Steven Avery clean his garage floor with bleach. On March 1, 2006, Investigator Wiegert recovered the jeans worn by Dassey on October 31, 2005. Investigator Wiegert noted that the jeans contained bleach spots and other stains."
SOURCE: http://convolutedbrian.com.s3....
According to one case page's trial notes, Avery's girlfriend Jodi (who you'll remember was in jail for DUI but called Avery by phone on the afternoon/evening in
question) "testified that in one of two phone calls to Avery on the night of 31 October, 2005, Steve said Brendan was helping clean the garage."
SOURCE: http://www.convolutedbrian.com...
- HANDCUFFS AND LEG IRONS
"Police found... a pair of handcuffs and leg irons in [Avery's] house."
"And the handcuffs and leg irons? 'I bought them,' Avery said. 'I wanted to try out something different with [my girlfriend] Jodi.'"
SOURCE: http://www.milwaukeemag.com/20...
"Complainant is informed that during a search of the residence of Steven A. Avery,
law enforcement located items of restraints within Avery's residence, including handcuffs and leg irons..."
SOURCE: http://convolutedbrian.com.s3....
- KAYLA AVERY, the cousin of Brendan's who testified in tears
In MaM she apologetically testifies that she had fabricated conversations with Brendan, in which he allegedly talked about the crime and his own/his uncle's involvement. But was she lying then, or now? The press noted:
"Prosecutors followed [Kayla's] testimony with that of Susan Brandt, who worked an internship as a counselor at Mishicot middle and high schools in early 2006... Brandt said Kayla Avery told her and a Mishicot counselor in January 2006 that 'she was scared because her uncle Steven Avery had asked one of her cousins to help move a body.' The girl didn't specify which of her cousins allegedly helped Avery, Brandt said, and she was scared but not confused."
SOURCE: http://archive.postcrescent.co...
In conclusion, I'm not saying that the above items are proof of guilt, by any means -- just that there are more things in hell and earth than displayed in our documentaries, no matter how extensive or well-presented.
i think he did it. i think brendan was involved in a very minor way--coerced by avery because hes a very low iq kid who can be manipulated.
i think the sheriff's department and everyone involved against the avery's did plant evidence and coerce confessions. reason being, because they wanted to make sure they got their conviction because they had it out for this guy. in doing so they almost [expletive] everything up by being so bad at it.
not really sure how avery managed to do it, how he managed to cover everything up and then play the part of wrongfully accused, but i also don't think hes as dumb as everyone makes him out to be.
On the AV club discussion link, someone pointed out that the Colburn (sp) officer, was in several later episodes escorting Brendan around to fro courthouse. I had thought I had saw him, but dismissed it-thought it had to be some other cop. The crooked ones look alike
I was going to list out the most loathesome characters in this saga. Obviously whoever committed the crimes, but that goes w/o saying... The sketch artist deputy....Kachinsky, Lenz, investigator OKelley. The balding [expletive] that Wierchert(sp), who interrogated Brendan, ...Kratz...yeah him. That other guy next to Kratz. ...
Agreed. I've actually stayed away from the spoilers in this thread since I only started watching it last Friday. I don't know if he did it or not, but I certainly lean to him not doing it. I certainly don't think the prosecution showed that he did, and I thought his defense did a tremendous job. From the "forced" confession of a mentally disabled teen, to the key, to the lack of DNA of Teresa (there would have been blood all over that garage) to how it was Manitowoc police that basically found everything...I just don't get it.
I don't think he did it either. Steven Avery is a strange bird, but I don't think he's a murderer. It did seem a little too convenient for Manitowoc to find everything. And Colborn asking to run a plate on a vehicle he had supposedly not seen sticks out like a sore thumb.
Tadych did it. Steven's brother in law and Brendan's stepdad. As others mentioned, Tadych was only alibi'd by Bobby Dassey, who got an alibi from Tadych. Bobby I think was complicit in what happened, but he didn't know his brother would get involved in the case. Tadych knew Manitowoc had a hard-on for busting Avery and would seek out any chance to bring him down. You might recall after the Avery verdict, Tadych says something like "he got what was coming to him."
Also, on a non-spoiler note, the reporter with glasses is hot.
I don't think he did it either. Steven Avery is a strange bird, but I don't think he's a murderer. It did seem a little too convenient for Manitowoc to find everything. And Colborn asking to run a plate on a vehicle he had supposedly not seen sticks out like a sore thumb.
Tadych did it. Steven's brother in law and Brendan's stepdad. As others mentioned, Tadych was only alibi'd by Bobby Dassey, who got an alibi from Tadych. Bobby I think was complicit in what happened, but he didn't know his brother would get involved in the case. Tadych knew Manitowoc had a hard-on for busting Avery and would seek out any chance to bring him down. You might recall after the Avery verdict, Tadych says something like "he got what was coming to him."
Also, on a non-spoiler note, the reporter with glasses is hot.
I don't think he did it either. Steven Avery is a strange bird, but I don't think he's a murderer. It did seem a little too convenient for Manitowoc to find everything. And Colborn asking to run a plate on a vehicle he had supposedly not seen sticks out like a sore thumb.
Tadych did it. Steven's brother in law and Brendan's stepdad. As others mentioned, Tadych was only alibi'd by Bobby Dassey, who got an alibi from Tadych. Bobby I think was complicit in what happened, but he didn't know his brother would get involved in the case. Tadych knew Manitowoc had a hard-on for busting Avery and would seek out any chance to bring him down. You might recall after the Avery verdict, Tadych says something like "he got what was coming to him."
Also, on a non-spoiler note, the reporter with glasses is hot.
Angenette Levy
2 hrs ·
Hi Everyone - I have received many messages over the last week from people who have watched the Netflix documentary "Making A Murderer". I covered the case from the beginning. Many people have asked about my thoughts on the Avery and Dassey cases. I have thoughts, of course. I always have a lot of questions - it's just my nature. And I asked a lot of questions of both the State and the defense teams in these cases. Once I finish watching the documentary I will post something. But I am not finished yet. I work every day and have other obligations so binging hasn't been an option. No one "won" in this case. The Halbach family lost Teresa in an awful, awful way and the Averys watched two family members go to prison. I have posted links to stories from the filmmakers, the special prosecutor and one of Avery's defense attorneys below.
LikeCommentShare
Top Comments
43 people like this.
Comments
Tom Tomaszewski
Tom Tomaszewski I have seen all 10 installments of the infotainment video Angenette and I found it to be a biased , reprehensible and irresponsible waste of ten years by two amateurs. And that is the best I can say about it.
Like · Reply · 1 hr
Angenette Levy
Angenette Levy Tom - I remember seeing you at the courthouse but I can't remember: were you there for the Avery trial in Calumet Co?
Like · Reply · 1 hr
Tom Tomaszewski
Tom Tomaszewski I covered Avery from back in Green Bay monitoring the trial while the reporter from WTMJ was on the scene. We reversed that for Dassey. So I sat through it all, just remotely grabbing sound from the feed to do updates. Went to Chilton for a number of the News Conferences.
Like · Reply · 1 hr
Steven Lee
Steven Lee Angenette, you agree that MAM is biased, reprehensible and irresponsible waste of ten years? Why is Tom answering for you?
Like · Reply · 31 mins · Edited
Tom Tomaszewski
Tom Tomaszewski Steven- To be fair - I am out of the business and free to say what I want to say. If I were still reporting I would not be as free with my own opinions in case I had to report once again on that story.
Like · Reply · 1 · 32 mins
Agreed. I've actually stayed away from the spoilers in this thread since I only started watching it last Friday. I don't know if he did it or not, but I certainly lean to him not doing it. I certainly don't think the prosecution showed that he did, and I thought his defense did a tremendous job. From the "forced" confession of a mentally disabled teen, to the key, to the lack of DNA of Teresa (there would have been blood all over that garage) to how it was Manitowoc police that basically found everything...I just don't get it.
Don't know if this needs to be spoilered or not but:
I don't believe that Avery is necessarily "innocent". I just think there is no way they proved his guilt beyond a shadow of a doubt. So, he's more "not guilty" in my mind than "innocent".