Making A Murderer

Chat about non-baseball topics. No political discussions!
Post Reply
Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by Freed Roger »

Another documentary could be made on the highly politicized nature of WI. Everything is is tainted by it.

In this saga, Kachinsky mentions his failed campaign to be judge. Kratz certainly mentions his elected position. In rural areas, getting elected DA or sheriff is like a Kingship. Elections to become judges are highly contentious.

With this political backdrop, an elected official in judicial process has extended incentive to put people behind bars. The reprecussions to an elected official with desires for higher office. of a guilty man walking (or even an innocent man that looks guilty to sound bite public) is dooming. states or areas where we do not have contested elections for such roles, it is hard to relate.

User avatar
pioneer98
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22007
Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
Location: High A Minors

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by pioneer98 »

Freed Roger wrote:When I finish this thing, will be jonesing to talk about it.
Such as
[SHOW]
avery is much smarter than he lets on. 70 IQ my ass. His nephew, Brendan definetely. At one point, Steve Avery mentions he is always being recorded from jailhouse. And he seems to be playing to an audience in most the recordings. My god the 90 percent of the judicial system people seem like loathesome asshats
[SHOW]
I agree. How the heck do you first keep a girlfriend while you are in jail for a number of years. Then after that one falls apart, how do you meet and make a new girlfriend??? I was blown away he was able to maintain these kind of relationships while in jail. He might not be book smart but he has a lot of social smarts.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by Freed Roger »

[SHOW]
the conviction of the nephew causes me to wonder if something in his case was left out by the filmmakers. From what I saw, he was a good witness for himself on the stand, as was his cousin. They did not crack, if they were an act. No physical evidence and two coerced minors. How he was found guilty based on the trial shown on film is beyond me.
Last edited by Freed Roger on December 27 15, 5:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.

MrSaigon

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by MrSaigon »

I gave up disgusted in episode 3 and just read the spoilers on the AV Club. I can't believe that's how anyone goes about their business, the way they grilled that poor kid.

The problem with so many documentaries is that they leave me wanting to see the counterpoint, and this one (from what I saw) is definitely guilty.
[SHOW]
As most here have said, I just don't see the Sheriff having a lady killed. Maybe she was killed by someone and they put it together? But they'd have to be so meticulous. I think perhaps Avery, or at least someone in his family, was involved, but I don't know how he could be run up on what he was--let alone his nephew. You watch that video of the people searching his house and consider that the key wasn't found until the fourth or fifth sweep and man it's easy to form some really strong doubts. But again, I'd like to see a counterpoint. The AV Club blog said there is talk that Avery called the girl several times that day, and requested her specifically from Auto Trader. Anyway, it was a really interesting show, but I have a long queue of stuff to watch and I don't regret my decision.

User avatar
pioneer98
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22007
Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
Location: High A Minors

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by pioneer98 »

MrSaigon wrote:I gave up disgusted in episode 3 and just read the spoilers on the AV Club. I can't believe that's how anyone goes about their business, the way they grilled that poor kid.

The problem with so many documentaries is that they leave me wanting to see the counterpoint, and this one (from what I saw) is definitely guilty.
[SHOW]
As most here have said, I just don't see the Sheriff having a lady killed. Maybe she was killed by someone and they put it together? But they'd have to be so meticulous. I think perhaps Avery, or at least someone in his family, was involved, but I don't know how he could be run up on what he was--let alone his nephew. You watch that video of the people searching his house and consider that the key wasn't found until the fourth or fifth sweep and man it's easy to form some really strong doubts. But again, I'd like to see a counterpoint. The AV Club blog said there is talk that Avery called the girl several times that day, and requested her specifically from Auto Trader. Anyway, it was a really interesting show, but I have a long queue of stuff to watch and I don't regret my decision.
[SHOW]
The two guys that were going hunting that day who alibi'd each other and no one else were clearly lying. Don't know if you got far enough to see that.

User avatar
JL21
NPR & THT Contributor
Posts: 36109
Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
Location: Chocolate City

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by JL21 »

The Third Man wrote:I have to admit, I burst out laughing during the first episode where the one lawyer mentions that the victim identified the perpetrator as wearing white underwear "whereas Steven Avery didn't even own underwear."
I just finished #1 as well and also laughed at that.

planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by planet planet »

Is it a common thing for teenagers and not too bright people to confess to something they didn't do? After watching MoaM, I watched The Central Park Five and can't believe those kids were convicted either.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by Freed Roger »

pioneer98 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:When I finish this thing, will be jonesing to talk about it.
Such as
[SHOW]
avery is much smarter than he lets on. 70 IQ my ass. His nephew, Brendan definetely. At one point, Steve Avery mentions he is always being recorded from jailhouse. And he seems to be playing to an audience in most the recordings. My god the 90 percent of the judicial system people seem like loathesome asshats
[SHOW]
I agree. How the heck do you first keep a girlfriend while you are in jail for a number of years. Then after that one falls apart, how do you meet and make a new girlfriend??? I was blown away he was able to maintain these kind of relationships while in jail. He might not be book smart but he has a lot of social smarts.
[SHOW]
the new girlfriend in episode 10 made me more uneasy about Avery too. Seems like predators have this unusual ability to charm. This isn't the silver bullet or anything, just adds a part to my overall sense about Avery.

I've mulled this series over for a few days - my gut says Avery is guilty, but not without doubt. My utter disgust for the justice system corruption and failures in this process, can't shake this sense that he did it. I am fairly sure the Manitowoc police helped the case along with evidence planting (the keys, blood in car, the bullet maybe) - and the murder narrative put forth doesn't make sense as a result.

However, I can't fathom the police were able to plant a car, and her bones on the property of the last guy to see her. That would require too much intimate knowledge of the murder.

It seemed like the "just" result of the trial would have been a hung jury/mistrial - and then do it over the right way (new venue, proscutors, and without the key, the blood allowed as evidence-and any remnants of Brendan's story). I'm not sure how juries work though - I don't think you get to vote hung, it is either guilty or not.

the case against Brendan (at least as presented in the series) was incredibly weak. No physical evidence. No witnesses, effectively. A public defender Kachinsky that plotted against him. I feel Kachinsky and his investigator are more of a danger to society than Brendan.
Kratz should be in jail as well.

User avatar
cardinalkarp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 18752
Joined: May 4 06, 8:44 am

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by cardinalkarp »

Freed Roger wrote:
pioneer98 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:When I finish this thing, will be jonesing to talk about it.
Such as
[SHOW]
avery is much smarter than he lets on. 70 IQ my ass. His nephew, Brendan definetely. At one point, Steve Avery mentions he is always being recorded from jailhouse. And he seems to be playing to an audience in most the recordings. My god the 90 percent of the judicial system people seem like loathesome asshats
[SHOW]
I agree. How the heck do you first keep a girlfriend while you are in jail for a number of years. Then after that one falls apart, how do you meet and make a new girlfriend??? I was blown away he was able to maintain these kind of relationships while in jail. He might not be book smart but he has a lot of social smarts.
[SHOW]
the new girlfriend in episode 10 made me more uneasy about Avery too. Seems like predators have this unusual ability to charm. This isn't the silver bullet or anything, just adds a part to my overall sense about Avery.

I've mulled this series over for a few days - my gut says Avery is guilty, but not without doubt. My utter disgust for the justice system corruption and failures in this process, can't shake this sense that he did it. I am fairly sure the Manitowoc police helped the case along with evidence planting (the keys, blood in car, the bullet maybe) - and the murder narrative put forth doesn't make sense as a result.

However, I can't fathom the police were able to plant a car, and her bones on the property of the last guy to see her. That would require too much intimate knowledge of the murder.

It seemed like the "just" result of the trial would have been a hung jury/mistrial - and then do it over the right way (new venue, proscutors, and without the key, the blood allowed as evidence-and any remnants of Brendan's story). I'm not sure how juries work though - I don't think you get to vote hung, it is either guilty or not.

the case against Brendan (at least as presented in the series) was incredibly weak. No physical evidence. No witnesses, effectively. A public defender Kachinsky that plotted against him. I feel Kachinsky and his investigator are more of a danger to society than Brendan.
Kratz should be in jail as well.
[SHOW]
He may not be the brightest bulb on the tree, but to park the car of the person you just killed in you salvage yard when you have access to a crusher is something a 10 year old could figure out. All of it was planted....the car, the person who FOUND the car somehow locates the car in 10 minutes (as its parked right no the perimeter on a lot that contains 40 acres of vehicles, the blood in the car, the key in the house, all of this crap alone is enough to find that he's not guilty.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Making A Murderer

Post by Freed Roger »

cardinalkarp wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:
pioneer98 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:When I finish this thing, will be jonesing to talk about it.
Such as
[SHOW]
avery is much smarter than he lets on. 70 IQ my ass. His nephew, Brendan definetely. At one point, Steve Avery mentions he is always being recorded from jailhouse. And he seems to be playing to an audience in most the recordings. My god the 90 percent of the judicial system people seem like loathesome asshats
[SHOW]
I agree. How the heck do you first keep a girlfriend while you are in jail for a number of years. Then after that one falls apart, how do you meet and make a new girlfriend??? I was blown away he was able to maintain these kind of relationships while in jail. He might not be book smart but he has a lot of social smarts.
[SHOW]
the new girlfriend in episode 10 made me more uneasy about Avery too. Seems like predators have this unusual ability to charm. This isn't the silver bullet or anything, just adds a part to my overall sense about Avery.

I've mulled this series over for a few days - my gut says Avery is guilty, but not without doubt. My utter disgust for the justice system corruption and failures in this process, can't shake this sense that he did it. I am fairly sure the Manitowoc police helped the case along with evidence planting (the keys, blood in car, the bullet maybe) - and the murder narrative put forth doesn't make sense as a result.

However, I can't fathom the police were able to plant a car, and her bones on the property of the last guy to see her. That would require too much intimate knowledge of the murder.

It seemed like the "just" result of the trial would have been a hung jury/mistrial - and then do it over the right way (new venue, proscutors, and without the key, the blood allowed as evidence-and any remnants of Brendan's story). I'm not sure how juries work though - I don't think you get to vote hung, it is either guilty or not.

the case against Brendan (at least as presented in the series) was incredibly weak. No physical evidence. No witnesses, effectively. A public defender Kachinsky that plotted against him. I feel Kachinsky and his investigator are more of a danger to society than Brendan.
Kratz should be in jail as well.
[SHOW]
He may not be the brightest bulb on the tree, but to park the car of the person you just killed in you salvage yard when you have access to a crusher is something a 10 year old could figure out. All of it was planted....the car, the person who FOUND the car somehow locates the car in 10 minutes (as its parked right no the perimeter on a lot that contains 40 acres of vehicles, the blood in the car, the key in the house, all of this crap alone is enough to find that he's not guilty.
[SHOW]
I am not sure about the car. yeah, the crushers are there. Doesn't seem logical, but murder isn't either. Steven seems exceedingly smart about some things, not others. Maybe he thought, the crushers would be first place they'd look for traces and if they traced the car to a crusher, he would have to know he's done. Or perhaps crusher use would require his Dad or brother know about it's use.
the brother situation, I wish they explored that a bit more. Seems like he disappears in later episodes, after he resigned to be pissed that this notoriety hurt business.

to plant the car and bones there, would mean police hauled it in from elsewhere, and knew someone else murdered her, or possibly they murdered her. They'd have to know the real murderer wasn't going to show up somewhere down the line.

Anyway, I can't really argue the case for the prosecution because they are all so damn [expletive] up and corrupt, but still get the vibe from Steven.

Post Reply