Vidor wrote:2. "Citizen Kane" is really the only other entry in the "best debut" contest.
Pather Panchali, 12 Angry Men, Eraserhead, The 400 Blows, Breathless, Night of the Living Dead.
Pather Panchali and that whole trilogy is amazing.
Famous Mortimer wrote:Haha, I think you're all forgetting the greatest debut of all time, one so amazing that the director never needed to do another one, "Manos: The Hands Of Fate".
I've never seen it but I'm dying to. For all the wrong reasons, of course.
Vidor wrote:1. Malick's best film, because it has an actual story.
I have no idea what this means.
I don't think my post was that inscrutable. "Badlands" has a story, a plot with a beginning, middle, and an end, which becomes less true with Malick's later films, like "To the Wonder".
Anyway, in other news, Kirk Cameron's "Saving Christmas" debuts in theaters and promptly earns the title of "worst movie ever" at the IMDb.
Listed by what I think are the best films that happen to be debuts, without regard for the director's later work but with a little extra emphasis on "wow, it's impressive that that was a first film."
1. Kane (there's no other option here)
2. Breathless
3. Pather Panchali
4. Shadows
5. Killer of Sheep
6. This Is Spinal Tap
7. Donnie Darko
8. Hard Eight
9. Pi
10. Badlands
Special mention: Eraserhead, Slacker, El Mariachi, Shawshank, Virginia Woolf, Night of the Hunter, Bottle Rocket, Hard Eight, Real Life, Blood Simple--a lot of these are because they are indicative of the director's talent to follow. You can see the rambling conversational genius of Linklater's "Before" series in Slacker. You can see the attention to detail in Anderson's later stuff forming in Bottle Rocket. You can see PTA's virtuosic use of camera and actor in Hard Eight.
Note: I don't respond well to Truffaut. I find him a tick sentimental for my liking with a few exceptions like Shoot The Piano Player. Good not great to my taste. I wasn't sure if I could put l'Atalante in here after Zero de Conduite, but I'd put it in my ten and up there with Night of the Hunter as Best Only Feature Film.
Why not just put Zero de Conduite in there instead, which I think is a better film anyway? I've kind of always wondered why L'Atalante was held in higher esteem. Zero de Conduite had a bigger influence and served as a much better link between French Impressionism and Poetic Realism.
Since we're talking debuts, I wouldn't exactly put Scorsese's "Who's That Knocking at my Door?" on a best list, but it is very good and very much showcases what he would become. It's Scorsese's charms processed down into a hyper-condensed sap.
For a serious answer, and one that's not been mentioned yet, I'd go for "Repo Man". Amazing film, and if I didn't adore "Straight To Hell" beyond all reason, I'd say it was Cox's best film too.
Donnie Darko or Hard Eight above Badlands is madness.
I think, contextually, Pather Panchali, Eraserhead and Killer of Sheep destroy all comers. Two were student films and the other was by somebody who'd never before picked up a camera before the first day of shooting.