trill wrote:At first, I think hipster Scorcese was a fair comparison but at this point, he's surpassed any other director for dedication to mise en scene.
I certainly wouldn't argue this. I wonder though if it comes at a cost. Or maybe just that sense of place and feeling is what WA is so great at creating but he's otherwise an average filmmaker.
Another thought- warning I'm no film studies major, is this dedication to mise en scene the antithesis of that Von Trier dogma business of a few years back?
lukethedrifter wrote:is this dedication to mise en scene the antithesis of that Von Trier dogma business of a few years back?
Not at all. Big budget Hollywood blockbusters, special effects-driven stories and the like are the antithesis of Dogme 95. The rules of Dogme 95:
Shooting must be done on location. Props and sets must not be brought in (if a particular prop is necessary for the story, a location must be chosen where this prop is to be found).
The sound must never be produced apart from the images or vice versa. (Music must not be used unless it occurs where the scene is being shot.)
The camera must be hand-held. Any movement or immobility attainable in the hand is permitted.
The film must be in colour. Special lighting is not acceptable. (If there is too little light for exposure the scene must be cut or a single lamp be attached to the camera).
Optical work and filters are forbidden.
The film must not contain superficial action. (Murders, weapons, etc. must not occur.)
Temporal and geographical alienation are forbidden. (That is to say that the film takes place here and now).
Genre movies are not acceptable.
The film format must be Academy 35 mm.
The director must not be credited.
lukethedrifter wrote:Or maybe just that sense of place and feeling is what WA is so great at creating but he's otherwise an average filmmaker.
Just to clarify, this is kind of like saying, "Sure, Tony Gwynn was great at making contact and hitting for high averages, but he wasn't much of a power hitter."
Technically, that's true... but don't discount his skill.
And I guess it really depends on how you define 'great filmmaker' anyway. Just because he's not making movies about weightier topics doesn't mean he's not a skilled filmmaker. He's really impressive at painting his world, and that's one of the first/easiest rules of filmmaking- make what you know. His style is extremely well-versed in film history (evocative of everything from Satyajit Ray to Lubitsch to Jean Vigo to Truffaut and then some), and his films are downright enjoyable to most.
trill wrote:At first, I think hipster Scorcese was a fair comparison but at this point, he's surpassed any other director for dedication to mise en scene.
I certainly wouldn't argue this. I wonder though if it comes at a cost. Or maybe just that sense of place and feeling is what WA is so great at creating but he's otherwise an average filmmaker.
I like JL's Tony Gwynn analogy. He has a limited skill set, but it's so elite, it brings up his value.
His movies have gotten less and less human, but they're still beautiful to look at and if you're a visual person, you can enjoy it for what it is a great deal without worrying about how twee and inhuman it feels.
To clarify, luke, a lot of what you're saying is a relatively common knock on him. I certainly don't mean to squelch the discussion because I think it's a good one. It comes up with every new Wes Anderson release now.
And if I'm being honest, it's also why I tend to think of him a little lower than guys like PT Anderson, Steve McQueen, Darren Aronofsky, and obviously the Coens and Scorsese (since we're talking about people still making movies today).
I don't pretend to be adding some cutting edge new perspective to the general discussion. I just had never really put much thought into it. And clearly, since I'm just now seeing Rushmore, wasn't familiar with all of his work so just now starting to see the patterns every one else saw many films ago.
lukethedrifter wrote:I'm not discounting his skill. I think you guys have it right. I enjoy getting into his worlds but at some point certain things start gnawing at me.
lukethedrifter wrote:I don't pretend to be adding some cutting edge new perspective to the general discussion. I just had never really put much thought into it. And clearly, since I'm just now seeing Rushmore, wasn't familiar with all of his work so just now starting to see the patterns every one else saw many films ago.
I only brought that up to validate your opinion- that lots and lots of critics and viewers feel the same way.