The Coens' have their share of critics when it comes to their overall place in the upper echelon. The big charge on them is that they're often making fun of their characters, which I've never understood. They're far and away my personal favorite director(s), but they also have a few legit stinkers.Vidor wrote:I seem to have touched a nerve by suggesting a Coen Brothers film isn't the greatest thing out there. Third rail of movie criticism? Better not talk about how "The Big Lebowski" is a series of weird ideas in search of a plot.
I'd say the plot is next to irrelevant in Lebowski. It's a riff on The Big Sleep (which I'm sure the title is a nod to) and noir in general. You can count up the noir tropes - loner hero (who smokes pot instead of drinks), kidnapped woman, rich "client", hero gets knocked out constantly, etc... So yeah, it's a playground for a bunch of weird ideas and it totally works.
I'd be surprised if Llewyn Davis is any more about 60's folk singers than A Serious Man is about 60's midwestern Jews.


