Arthur Dent wrote:AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Donnie Ebert wrote:How much would delivery be by drone?
With zero scientific evidence or statistical data, I'm guessing that (minus the startup costs, including permitting and R&D), drones would be exponentially cheaper than delivery by land (only because all the infrastructure is publicly funded and the R&D for the most part is already complete). The only thing trucks have in their favor would be ability to load heavier/more packages. But....that gets erased quickly with a couple fill ups, oil changes, tire changes, not to mention the general cost to the public to maintain the roadways.
I don't actually know anything either, but I would assume the opposite. These drones are helicopters, and helicopters are expensive to operate because they have to put lot of energy into not falling. Also, you'd probably need several hundred drone trips to transport what you'd normally put in a single UPS truck, and that's assuming that everything can be split into < 5 pound packages. Could you operate a a large fleet of drones flying a bunch of inefficient out and back routes for the same cost as driving a single truck? Seems unlikely.
If using drones meant you could dramatically scale back spending on local roads, maybe it'd be a more favorable comparison, but that doesn't seem too likely. What fraction of road traffic is short distance transport of < 5 pound parcels?
True dat.
But, how much does a helicopter weigh? 5 tons? With one engine? Carrying up to 4 people. Further, what instruments does it have? Etc etc etc. There's a lot of energy spent in inefficient, obsolete places. I get the feelings these drones are light like < 10 lbs with a small, but powerful, processor and small, but powerful and efficient, motors - in Amazon's case, 8 of them.
In today's prices, I don't think a fleet of drones capable of doing what a UPS truck does in a single day would be cost effective. No. I mean, it might even cost more to build a single drone than a UPS truck. I don't know. But, I'd guess in 10 years, once the design is approved and they're in mass production, again I'd guess you could get 20 drones for the price of what one costs today or thereabouts. Engines for the things will be much cheaper. Maintenance would be minimal comparatively. And, quicker. Gas and oil for trucks will likely go up while technology to run drones will go down. Imo, all of that will eventually lead to it being cheaper to operate drones than trucks or a single truck. Maybe I'm under estimating the complexity of what they will be, however, and the price will never be advantageous.
Edited to add: it could also prevent to and from trips for consumers to go pick up a box of tampons as well. But, iirc, delivery vehicles and personal vehicles are pretty negligible when doing ESAL calcs. So, it may not reduce maintenance costs for municipalities either way.