IMADreamer wrote:trill wrote:IMADreamer wrote:
Me too, death is no punishment, it is just the end. Let this guy live a long miserable life in some hell hole getting ass raped.
So they guy who thinks it's inappropriate for Bostonians to cheer at his capture is now championing a sexually brutal revenge fantasy. Interesting dichotomy.
Well the guy still has to go to trial, be convicted, etc. Then he can be punished like all the other prisoners in this country. Which is federal pound me in the ass prison. I'm not fantasizing about it, but if he is convicted of this, which he will be, he should be punished severely.
Rather than addressing the justice of what has happened or will happen, I was speaking more to the cognitive dissonance of someone being so emotionally measured and criticizing a city finally feeling safe to go outside cheering and celebrating in relief then giving his blessing for the sexual torture for the person who was captured. That's not very emotionally measured or objective. Just doesn't line up.
IMADreamer wrote:
The whole thing about cheering I just don't get.
You post a lot about how society sometimes baffles you with how non-empathetic and cold it is, whether we're discussing civil equality for gays and lesbians, the current system for medical care in America or gun control, for example. Clearly empathy is a big deal to you and how you form your opinions. Yet you can't empathize with the relief that the people of Boston we're feeling after living under conditions of stress and fear that is almost unheard of in this country? Mmmkay. Doesn't make sense that you wouldn't "get" the cheering.
IMADreamer wrote:Not to mention when we see Islamists cheering when American's die or get captured we are disgusted by that and then we pretend we are better then that.
We are better than that. So are Muslims. The vast majority of Bostonians were cheering because they felt safe and their lives could get back to normal for the first time in 5 days. I'm sure some we're thrilled at the idea of this guy receiving punishment, just like the vast majority of Muslims do not cheer the death of westerners but a small minority do cheer at the idea of what they view as deserved punishment towards a culture or government they feel oppressed by.
There's a huge difference between the scenes in Boston and the scenes of militant muslims celebrating the death of their enemy. Only a mind incapable of even the slightest grasp of subtlety wouldn't understand that. I think you are capable of seeing the difference, you've just chosen to take a weird, moral grandstanding position and are now trying to rationalize it.
IMADreamer wrote:
I just think everyone should breathe a sigh of relief that it appears the authorities got the right guy, he'll hopefully go to trial like he should, be found guilty, and this will all be over.
That's what the cheering was for. The collective "sigh of relief."
IMADreamer wrote:I just don't see any of this as a happy moment. I see it as an end to a sad chapter in our history.
Of course it's a happy moment. A terrorist who murdered people and planned to murder more is off the streets. If you're somber about that, that's fine. Not everyone has to be like you.
IMADreamer wrote:
I see it as an end to a sad chapter in our history.
Well that's just dumb. It's not the end of this particular incident's story and non-state enemy combatants are here indefinitely.