Stock Market Talk
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Stock Market Talk
Just a few quick rebuttals and I'll leave it alone. As you mention, yes, there are many people trying to make money in the stock market including pretty much everyone with a retirement account. That doesn't mean people outside of funds and on their own can't make money. And it doesn't mean swing trading in any of its forms is a get rich quick scheme. If I gave the impression that it was foolproof, impossible to lose money, or simply required a quick search for news and only to see if the price crossed a line on a chart to make money, then I was not clear in my original post that it is still gambling. That said, so many people are doing it close to the way I described and think it works that Scottrade has a pre-programmed chart (showing the bands, average and hourly candlesticks) set up on its platform for users at just the click of a button.
And, people can do better than a fund with all the tools, capabilities and brains because it's a different game, pure and simple. Swing traders likely couldn't manage a fund as well as some of the good fund managers. Likewise, a good fund manager isn't going to swing trade with the fund. One's a long term investment (eg, energy and shipping), the other a short term trade (eg, any stock that has dipped a couple percent for no reason). Completely different and almost unrelated. Which brings me back to risk:
Yes, you are taking risk any time you get in the market. You'll never change that. You're also taking a risk not getting in the market and burying money in your back yard. Is it more risky to push all your money into a trade that you'll monitor for a few days and then be back in a cash position or is it more risky to dump 10% of your paycheck into god knows what stocks being managed by god knows who and letting it get dinged through every recession - Growth Fund of America lost half it's value in 2008, think about that, and is just now getting back to what it was - and market dip (all the while paying fees to do that and making that money inaccessible to you)? Or is it more risky to park your money in a suitcase in a vault and hope that the dollar appreciates? For me the answer is simple. I want control of my money and I want to limit the risk by rarely being in positions except when the conditions are favorable, extremely favorable.
Further getting into leveraged risk would involve talking about options, where you risk money that may well be lost forever in order to gain a lot more higher % (eg, risk $300 to gain hopefully at least that much if not more). I'm not fluent in that yet, though I'm working on it.
And, as I've made clear time and again, I have no clue how to pick stocks. I'm not good at it; finding this one was just rubbing elbows with the right guy at the right time. So, I needed a way to make money in the market. And, trading was a way more repeatable approach than finding stock XYZ about to bust out of its britches.... again, imo.
Regarding the stock I mentioned, yeah. It's far better trading a volatile stock if you only want to be in it for a couple days than one that takes a week or more to rebound and recover because that limits your risk to a market crash or something crazy happening. Imo. That doesn't mean it's any more risky than putting the money in a fund that may or may not outperform inflation over the next 28 years all while I can't touch it.
Edited to say: I'd take qualms with the fact that XTXI is a low quality stock. But it doesn't matter. It makes money the same as AMZN, AAPL, GOOG or whatever it takes to be a high quality stock.
And, people can do better than a fund with all the tools, capabilities and brains because it's a different game, pure and simple. Swing traders likely couldn't manage a fund as well as some of the good fund managers. Likewise, a good fund manager isn't going to swing trade with the fund. One's a long term investment (eg, energy and shipping), the other a short term trade (eg, any stock that has dipped a couple percent for no reason). Completely different and almost unrelated. Which brings me back to risk:
Yes, you are taking risk any time you get in the market. You'll never change that. You're also taking a risk not getting in the market and burying money in your back yard. Is it more risky to push all your money into a trade that you'll monitor for a few days and then be back in a cash position or is it more risky to dump 10% of your paycheck into god knows what stocks being managed by god knows who and letting it get dinged through every recession - Growth Fund of America lost half it's value in 2008, think about that, and is just now getting back to what it was - and market dip (all the while paying fees to do that and making that money inaccessible to you)? Or is it more risky to park your money in a suitcase in a vault and hope that the dollar appreciates? For me the answer is simple. I want control of my money and I want to limit the risk by rarely being in positions except when the conditions are favorable, extremely favorable.
Further getting into leveraged risk would involve talking about options, where you risk money that may well be lost forever in order to gain a lot more higher % (eg, risk $300 to gain hopefully at least that much if not more). I'm not fluent in that yet, though I'm working on it.
And, as I've made clear time and again, I have no clue how to pick stocks. I'm not good at it; finding this one was just rubbing elbows with the right guy at the right time. So, I needed a way to make money in the market. And, trading was a way more repeatable approach than finding stock XYZ about to bust out of its britches.... again, imo.
Regarding the stock I mentioned, yeah. It's far better trading a volatile stock if you only want to be in it for a couple days than one that takes a week or more to rebound and recover because that limits your risk to a market crash or something crazy happening. Imo. That doesn't mean it's any more risky than putting the money in a fund that may or may not outperform inflation over the next 28 years all while I can't touch it.
Edited to say: I'd take qualms with the fact that XTXI is a low quality stock. But it doesn't matter. It makes money the same as AMZN, AAPL, GOOG or whatever it takes to be a high quality stock.
Last edited by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 on February 26 13, 11:05 am, edited 5 times in total.
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Stock Market Talk
Here are my guesses for long stocks: SUTR and RWC
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: Stock Market Talk
SUTR is interesting. Added to my watchlist.
Disclaimer: when I said it's time to buy DDD, understand I'm just a random guy with very little money in the game. They are one I've had for a while now. Their stock dropped yesterday from nearly $57/share to the $35/share range. It had been overpriced, but I think it's long-term prospects are still good. Their revenue had been growing at over 50% per year, and it's stock had been priced accordingly. Their most recent annual report showed they only grew at 24% for existing business in the past year (37% if you include mergers).
Disclaimer: when I said it's time to buy DDD, understand I'm just a random guy with very little money in the game. They are one I've had for a while now. Their stock dropped yesterday from nearly $57/share to the $35/share range. It had been overpriced, but I think it's long-term prospects are still good. Their revenue had been growing at over 50% per year, and it's stock had been priced accordingly. Their most recent annual report showed they only grew at 24% for existing business in the past year (37% if you include mergers).
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Stock Market Talk
Yeah, I don't have any money in either of the stocks I threw out there. Just popped up on a screener so I put them on a watchlist....they did pretty ok today, but nothing fantastic. I put DDD on my watchlist. It took that drop yesterday but bounced back. Not back to the original price, but still a pretty decent rebound.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Stock Market Talk
Obviously, I don't know what you've done exactly, but based on what you've said, it sounds like the gains you attribute to technical analysis and the ability to project short term price movements are actually the result of trading in a stock that has done very well lately - a choice that you say isn't repeatable and involving a skill you don't think you have. All the trading has actually reduced your returns and cost you lots of money in fees (perhaps the reason Scottrade makes it easy to do?) and taxes. Has it reduced your risk (relative to what)? Hard to say, but it has certainly added costs much larger than the high fee Growth Fund of America.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Yes, you are taking risk any time you get in the market. You'll never change that. You're also taking a risk not getting in the market and burying money in your back yard. Is it more risky to push all your money into a trade that you'll monitor for a few days and then be back in a cash position or is it more risky to dump 10% of your paycheck into god knows what stocks being managed by god knows who and letting it get dinged through every recession - Growth Fund of America lost half it's value in 2008, think about that, and is just now getting back to what it was - and market dip (all the while paying fees to do that and making that money inaccessible to you)? Or is it more risky to park your money in a suitcase in a vault and hope that the dollar appreciates? For me the answer is simple. I want control of my money and I want to limit the risk by rarely being in positions except when the conditions are favorable, extremely favorable.
Also, I think you are mixing several things together here. Yes, 401k plans are often lousy. My company also, per default, routes employee retirement savings into a high fee actively managed plan, which is rotten. The alternative to that isn't either day trading or burying the money in the backyard. You can typically, for example, move the money to a broad index fund with quite low fees, or, if you are concerned about the inaccessibility of 401k funds, invest the money outside of a retirement account. That can be done with or without putting money in mutual funds.
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Stock Market Talk
And you sucked me back in, just when I was done!Arthur Dent wrote: Obviously, I don't know what you've done exactly, but based on what you've said, it sounds like the gains you attribute to technical analysis and the ability to project short term price movements are actually the result of trading in a stock that has done very well lately - a choice that you say isn't repeatable and involving a skill you don't think you have. All the trading has actually reduced your returns and cost you lots of money in fees (perhaps the reason Scottrade makes it easy to do?) and taxes. Has it reduced your risk (relative to what)? Hard to say, but it has certainly added costs much larger than the high fee Growth Fund of America.
Also, I think you are mixing several things together here. Yes, 401k plans are often lousy. My company also, per default, routes employee retirement savings into a high fee actively managed plan, which is rotten. The alternative to that isn't either day trading or burying the money in the backyard. You can typically, for example, move the money to a broad index fund with quite low fees, or, if you are concerned about the inaccessibility of 401k funds, invest the money outside of a retirement account. That can be done with or without putting money in mutual funds.
Regarding the trading results being a result of a bull stock, I don't think that's entirely true. It helps in a trade to know the stock is likely to tick higher at some point if all doesn't go according to plan, but that's not the goal and not the methods I've been using (which really would be a buy and hold as opposed to trading). For instance, twice in the past couple weeks I've shown trades on here of buying XTXI pennies shy of $17 and how they've both been winners. Yet the stock as of right now is $16.87. Those gains are definitely not a result of a bull stock. Further, here's the chart of the stock the past year. It's only been trending upwards the past 3 months and there were winning trades in brief downturns. Likewise money can still be made now as it is trending downward. And, because I took money out of the stock earlier in the year and have it in cash, I'm not hurt when the stock drops $1.25 over two days.

Though, looking back on it, yes, I should have just bought and held from December going forward. Lesson learned.
Yes, online brokers want active traders, no doubt about it. But, I don't think they're trying to force people to be active, rather just giving them a convenient platform to do whatever they want. Here's a screenshot of what preset charts you can pick.

The point of saying that they had the preloaded chart was more to show it's a pretty accepted method of short term trading as opposed to a get rich quick scheme. Millions of people likely use it, not just some hack on a Cardinals message board.
And, while the costs of trading are greater than the fees of the Growth Fund of America, so too are the gains, by a wide margin. All in all, I find it extremely beneficial to do it this way. I 1. feel like I'm learning a skill and 2. making more money than any other way outside picking a hot investment fund or stock. Maybe it's all a house of cards and will come crashing down. I hope not and feel comfortable enough to keep doing it.
Investing outside of a retirement account requires knowledge of what to buy, rather it is an index fund just trying to mirror the market, a fund trying to outperform it, or a stock. If you have suggestions of ones that are going to perform well (preferably better than the market), I'd love to hear about them. Coke (KO), Hewlett-Packard (HPQ), Krispy Kreme (KKD), McDonalds (MCD), Walgreens (WAG), and multiple others as well as New Insights Fund, Vanguard Funds, Fidelity funds have all been suggested. At some point, I need to figure out how to sift through those and separate which if any are good buys. Funny how all the recommended stocks all just had great runs of varying sizes.
Anyway, my point wasn't to say this is the best thing ever or that everyone should go open up a trading account. Just to give a different perspective to what was in the thread and hopefully show that technical analysis isn't completely useless...
-
Michael
- GRB Founder
- Posts: 35304
- Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
Re: Stock Market Talk
I haven't read this whole thread and I don't know the exact details being discussed, but old-school charting technical analysis like this, at least in the futures industry, is pretty well debunked. The studies that were presented in my derivatives class were pretty clear on this. Looking in the past you can always find a chart to confirm behavior, the rub is picking the right one for the future.
edit -
edit -
Stocks in general have had a great run lately. In the go-go 90's there were a lot of investors who thought they knew what they were doing, but they were basically gambling. I don't know your exact strategies, but as always be careful.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote: Coke (KO), Hewlett-Packard (HPQ), Krispy Kreme (KKD), McDonalds (MCD), Walgreens (WAG), and multiple others as well as New Insights Fund, Vanguard Funds, Fidelity funds have all been suggested. At some point, I need to figure out how to sift through those and separate which if any are good buys. Funny how all the recommended stocks all just had great runs of varying sizes.
- Radbird
- There's someone in my head but it's not me
- Posts: 62390
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
- Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II
Re: Stock Market Talk
So what happens to stocks Friday and next week if the bozos in DC don't get their act together?
-
Michael
- GRB Founder
- Posts: 35304
- Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
Re: Stock Market Talk
Buy low, sell high?Radbird wrote:So what happens to stocks Friday and next week if the bozos in DC don't get their act together?
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Stock Market Talk
Ha. Exactly, so, what's the lesson to be learned there? Maybe that you shouldn't look at the known past and expect the behavior to continue into the unknown future? I am not quite sure your point, though. Is it that you can't look at the past and predict the future (ie, charts) or that you can (ie, 90s investors didn't know what they were doing so today's traders don't either) because you kind of make both points.Michael wrote:I haven't read this whole thread and I don't know the exact details being discussed, but old-school charting technical analysis like this, at least in the futures industry, is pretty well debunked. The studies that were presented in my derivatives class were pretty clear on this. Looking in the past you can always find a chart to confirm behavior, the rub is picking the right one for the future.
edit -
Stocks in general have had a great run lately. In the go-go 90's there were a lot of investors who thought they knew doing, but they were basically gambling.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote: Coke (KO), Hewlett-Packard (HPQ), Krispy Kreme (KKD), McDonalds (MCD), Walgreens (WAG), and multiple others as well as New Insights Fund, Vanguard Funds, Fidelity funds have all been suggested. At some point, I need to figure out how to sift through those and separate which if any are good buys. Funny how all the recommended stocks all just had great runs of varying sizes.
Anyway, looking at your investopedia page, if that's what you meant by technical analysis, isn't the same thing I was talking about earlier. I was talking about statistical analysis or probabilities not the old school chart patterns that are open to interpretation (head and shoulders, wedges, double bottoms and tops). Basically once a stock moves outside of an envelope it spend almost 90% of its time, what happens next? Either the envelopes move or the stock does. Regardless, of what happens next, it's a good flag that something is happening and look deeper. If a stock starts rebounding, hopefully you can make money off the move. If not, no harm.
I'm not quite sure why there's such an aversion to applying simple statistical analysis to the stock market from a board that seemingly understands and is on board with using the benefits of using advanced statistics for baseball predictions...
