Arthur Dent wrote:Have you computed your net return (less trading costs edit: and taxes) and compared that to what you would have if you just purchased a broad market index fund (e.g VTI) and collected the dividends?
Here's the long version. Just read the bold if you want the number.
What got all this going....a little over a year ago, I looked at my 401K portfolio and painstakingly went through and calculated all my contributions over the past however many years (7 at the time). At that point, I noticed I had gained less than a percent overall. I might not have calced it correctly but basically took assets/money contributed and that number was less than 1.01. Wha wha. I don't have crazy funds either....Growth Fund of America. New perspective maybe. Tbh, I forget. I asked the retirement guys what the [expletive] was going on. They of course blamed the recession. Bull [expletive]. This was 2012. Almost half of my money had gone in post stock market bust. So...bull [expletive]. Then they blamed the fees associated with the individual funds. So, I moved it all to a Vanguard target date....which is still not doing great. Whatever.
At taht point, I got kind of pissed. Really, what the hell do fund managers do? Well, come to find out, not very much. My dad, who dabbles in the market, complete forecast the crash back in 2007. Most of the guys I work with forecast it before that. That's not to say they made money off it, but doing a ton of residential development, we were familiar with the industry. At the end of 2006 a report came out from the Walton Business School at U ofA that the area had too much housing. Too many lots and too many new houses. Banks tightened up lending. The whole dept we had at work (about 15 guys) within the year was down to 5. All that to say, the crash was easily foreseeable by anyone with a pulse on the market. None of my fund managers saw it, that's for sure. So, again, wtf are they being paid to do. Nothing. Fund managers are dip [expletive] and worthless, imo.
Okay, so that's why I cut back my contributions to only take advantage of the maximum free money the company gives and started investing the rest myself.
There was a huge learning curve. At first, like half my gains were being eaten by the commission. I wasn't making back trades, I just didn't have enough capital. So about a month into it, I sold off a chunk of stock so the commission wouldn't be that high of a % and I could trade with more.
That, in hindsight was not the best of decisions financially. I sold the stock at ~$13.50 and it's at ~$18 now....or a 33% gain. I've got a spreadsheet of my trades that shows the individual gains percentage wise minus the costs.
Overall, the average, including some losses and the beginning, is about 2% per trade after commissions. The $now/$then is about 1.29. (I know that isn't the precise answer you wanted, but it's close). Yeah, should have stuck with the stock and spent zero time trading. But, at least I've learned a new skill....something I wouldn't have been able to say had I just sat back and watched 1 stock climb for the past year.
At some point that stocks run is going to end and I'll have to either find another ugy who knows a guy who knows someone's dad's friend who knows the brass of a company whose stock is an order of magnitude undervalued.....or actually know what I'm doing. I'm still learning, so next up it would be nice to find a way to find winning stocks.
Anyway, I'm better than a [expletive] ass fund manager, imho of course, and have no problem paying the fees. Of course, I'dl ike to minimize the both amount I have to trade (work) and fees while maximizing profit.
It's pointless to think about trades that should have been made or ones that haven't. But, there's still a sickness when I look back at sending all this money to a 401K to do nothing and be untouchable for another 28 years or however long when if I added that to my scottrade account now, I could probably retire and do nothing but trade/invest. As is, I'll be working for a paycheck for at least another 5-10 years before that happens. Oh well....just time I guess. Blah.
*All of this ignores taxes. I know. It sucks being taxed twice on income and then again on capital gains which doesn't happen with a lot of funds/retirement accounts. Still, even taking 25% of my trading gains, its still better than what a fund is doing....
Also, I'm not ignoring the rest of your post AD. Thanks for posting that. I understand completely what they're saying. That's assuming, however, that you can pick stocks and hole them and make money. As I've mentioned, I don't know how to pick winning stocks. I've just spent my time learning to trade them when they get out of whack.