Stock Market Talk
- AdmiralKird
- MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
- Posts: 10178
- Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
- Location: Tycho Crater, Luna
Re: Stock Market Talk
You should put all your life savings in a short term APPL derivative.
If you don't know what you're doing just get a market ETF or find someone who will manage your money for a reasonable fee.
If you want to actually make money analyzing and buying stocks well... That takes a lot of learning and experience. I will give you a brief rundown:
Technical Analysis: Buying on trends and charts and crap and more crap layered with [expletive] is not going to do you any good. Don't waste your time. The books are written by those who have won at the lottery, and are trying to tell you how they won the lottery. Well, you pulled a lever and got lucky, that's basically it, and they pass it off as gospel because they're knowledgeable about the rest of the market and can make money. People listen to them like those who have a 'strategy' for when they gamble. Stock's move short term on human trends, but these are sporadic, not time-able except through guessing, and long-term do not correlate to the actual earnings of a company.
Fundamental Analysis: Almost all information is priced into a stock, so you're not going to do extremely well unless you take risk. The best way is to analyze the company and a whole, not just their numbers and see if they have the ability to produce abnormal gains above what is being priced into the stock. Take a company like Apple, trades at something like 4 times its assets (not sure off the top of my head), well that stock has some great growth, but its also pricing all of that in so it really doesn't make sense to buy Apple.
Stay away from popular companies. They are more prone to being fully analyzed and priced than a less publicized one.
The key is not unlike baseball, where you try and find a good player thats being incorrectly priced, which based on everything you know, should do better than forecast. Take for example, Lance Lynn. Guy had great stats last year, and did almost everything perfect. He was little known, and is now the top starter in the national league (small sample size too be sure) but his projected worth back after the playoffs was a borderline setupman, and now he would be at least be valued by most teams as a dependable 4th-5th starter. Give him another few months at his current pace and he would be worth #3 trade value, #2 trade value after a few months next year. But if you watched him and analyzed the Sabr's you would know he was worth more than people projected. Yes, there was a lot of uncertainty there, but you can narrow some of that out by looking at intangibles and less-known stats.
The point is, you can analyze companies but its difficult and you still have to expose yourself to additional risk. But unless you're willing to spend hours and hours reading and running numbers through excel and knowing what you're doing then you should probably just stick to ETFs. It's likely any alphaeic (returns that exceed the expected amount of risk taken) returns a broker could generate would be taken out in his fees anyway.
If you don't know what you're doing just get a market ETF or find someone who will manage your money for a reasonable fee.
If you want to actually make money analyzing and buying stocks well... That takes a lot of learning and experience. I will give you a brief rundown:
Technical Analysis: Buying on trends and charts and crap and more crap layered with [expletive] is not going to do you any good. Don't waste your time. The books are written by those who have won at the lottery, and are trying to tell you how they won the lottery. Well, you pulled a lever and got lucky, that's basically it, and they pass it off as gospel because they're knowledgeable about the rest of the market and can make money. People listen to them like those who have a 'strategy' for when they gamble. Stock's move short term on human trends, but these are sporadic, not time-able except through guessing, and long-term do not correlate to the actual earnings of a company.
Fundamental Analysis: Almost all information is priced into a stock, so you're not going to do extremely well unless you take risk. The best way is to analyze the company and a whole, not just their numbers and see if they have the ability to produce abnormal gains above what is being priced into the stock. Take a company like Apple, trades at something like 4 times its assets (not sure off the top of my head), well that stock has some great growth, but its also pricing all of that in so it really doesn't make sense to buy Apple.
Stay away from popular companies. They are more prone to being fully analyzed and priced than a less publicized one.
The key is not unlike baseball, where you try and find a good player thats being incorrectly priced, which based on everything you know, should do better than forecast. Take for example, Lance Lynn. Guy had great stats last year, and did almost everything perfect. He was little known, and is now the top starter in the national league (small sample size too be sure) but his projected worth back after the playoffs was a borderline setupman, and now he would be at least be valued by most teams as a dependable 4th-5th starter. Give him another few months at his current pace and he would be worth #3 trade value, #2 trade value after a few months next year. But if you watched him and analyzed the Sabr's you would know he was worth more than people projected. Yes, there was a lot of uncertainty there, but you can narrow some of that out by looking at intangibles and less-known stats.
The point is, you can analyze companies but its difficult and you still have to expose yourself to additional risk. But unless you're willing to spend hours and hours reading and running numbers through excel and knowing what you're doing then you should probably just stick to ETFs. It's likely any alphaeic (returns that exceed the expected amount of risk taken) returns a broker could generate would be taken out in his fees anyway.
- Joe Shlabotnik
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 24291
- Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
- Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
- Contact:
Re: Stock Market Talk
This is not investment advice, but it has worked for me. I do the mutual funds and index funds in a 401K and then I have a self directed IRA that I invest in individual stocks. MY IRA beats the crap out of my 401(k).
If you are in it for the long haul, I don't think its rocket science or even that hard.
1. Save your investable funds in cash.
2. Wait for a day where there is panic in the financial headlines. It helps if you hear people around the water cooler are talking about selling everything or wishing they had.
3. At that point run to the phone or internet and put in market buy orders on the likes of PG, XOM, LLY, ED, SO, GE, T etc. Big companies with long track records of success and good dividends.
4. Rinse and repeat.
You'll get a buying opportunity ever 6-18 months. And if you are dollar cost averaging, don't wait, just invest at regular intervals.
If you are in it for the long haul, I don't think its rocket science or even that hard.
1. Save your investable funds in cash.
2. Wait for a day where there is panic in the financial headlines. It helps if you hear people around the water cooler are talking about selling everything or wishing they had.
3. At that point run to the phone or internet and put in market buy orders on the likes of PG, XOM, LLY, ED, SO, GE, T etc. Big companies with long track records of success and good dividends.
4. Rinse and repeat.
You'll get a buying opportunity ever 6-18 months. And if you are dollar cost averaging, don't wait, just invest at regular intervals.
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: Stock Market Talk
Are we the same people?Joe Shlabotnik wrote:This is not investment advice, but it has worked for me. I do the mutual funds and index funds in a 401K and then I have a self directed IRA that I invest in individual stocks. MY IRA beats the crap out of my 401(k).
If you are in it for the long haul, I don't think its rocket science or even that hard.
1. Save your investable funds in cash.
2. Wait for a day where there is panic in the financial headlines. It helps if you hear people around the water cooler are talking about selling everything or wishing they had.
3. At that point run to the phone or internet and put in market buy orders on the likes of PG, XOM, LLY, ED, SO, GE, T etc. Big companies with long track records of success and good dividends.
4. Rinse and repeat.
You'll get a buying opportunity ever 6-18 months. And if you are dollar cost averaging, don't wait, just invest at regular intervals.
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: Stock Market Talk
I've been using a newsletter (Morningstar Stock Investor) and I think it's worth the money. I'm getting good returns while I learn about how to properly research stocks and build/balance a portfolio. I tried a Motley Fool newsletter for a while, but I like Morningstar better.
- go birds
- -go birds
- Posts: 32057
- Joined: February 5 10, 9:54 am
Re: Stock Market Talk
Haven't had the chance to read everything yet, but thanks for the input.
Quick question, how much is good to start investing with?
My dad said that no less than a grand....I'm looking to dump anywhere between 1k - 2k into scottrade....
Quick question, how much is good to start investing with?
My dad said that no less than a grand....I'm looking to dump anywhere between 1k - 2k into scottrade....
-
Gashouse
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5010
- Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: Stock Market Talk
As you're figuring things out, only invest directly in stocks with money you can afford to lose. Put the rest in an index fund until you feel like you have a clue.
rules of thumb I've read say that commissions on stock trades shouldn't exceed 1% of the trade value because that's money you're never getting back. Therefore the stock has to go up about 2% just for you to break even (buying cost and selling cost). If you're only starting with $1-2K, you'll need stick to just a couple of stocks. You'll have a hard time finding commissions much less than $5, so each trade should be at least $500 worth. How much does Scottrade charge per trade?
rules of thumb I've read say that commissions on stock trades shouldn't exceed 1% of the trade value because that's money you're never getting back. Therefore the stock has to go up about 2% just for you to break even (buying cost and selling cost). If you're only starting with $1-2K, you'll need stick to just a couple of stocks. You'll have a hard time finding commissions much less than $5, so each trade should be at least $500 worth. How much does Scottrade charge per trade?
- vinsanity
- Chili dog truther
- Posts: 8836
- Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
- Location: Indianapolis
Re: Stock Market Talk
Are you Warren Buffet?TimeForGuinness wrote:Are we the same people?Joe Shlabotnik wrote:This is not investment advice, but it has worked for me. I do the mutual funds and index funds in a 401K and then I have a self directed IRA that I invest in individual stocks. MY IRA beats the crap out of my 401(k).
If you are in it for the long haul, I don't think its rocket science or even that hard.
1. Save your investable funds in cash.
2. Wait for a day where there is panic in the financial headlines. It helps if you hear people around the water cooler are talking about selling everything or wishing they had.
3. At that point run to the phone or internet and put in market buy orders on the likes of PG, XOM, LLY, ED, SO, GE, T etc. Big companies with long track records of success and good dividends.
4. Rinse and repeat.
You'll get a buying opportunity ever 6-18 months. And if you are dollar cost averaging, don't wait, just invest at regular intervals.
I always lamented not having enough cash in 08 as the market was falling from the sky.
- AdmiralKird
- MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
- Posts: 10178
- Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
- Location: Tycho Crater, Luna
Re: Stock Market Talk
I use Morningstar as well. They have good analysis but you still have to back it up with other sources. There's a 14 day trial but it costs $200 a year.Gashouse wrote:I've been using a newsletter (Morningstar Stock Investor) and I think it's worth the money. I'm getting good returns while I learn about how to properly research stocks and build/balance a portfolio. I tried a Motley Fool newsletter for a while, but I like Morningstar better.
Now if someone wanted to share their mlbtv subscription...
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Stock Market Talk
Like TT said, don't invest this money in stocks if it is your retirement acct. Just get into mutual funds or something like that.
If you want to start buying and selling stocks like a day trader....good luck.
Billy Walters has something to say about Wall Street.
[/youtube]
If you want to start buying and selling stocks like a day trader....good luck.
Billy Walters has something to say about Wall Street.
[/youtube]
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis


