Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who died

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Locked
User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by vinsanity »

Fat Strat wrote:God chooses to bind himself by his own character. Holiness is one defining aspect of his character -- perfection. Christians believe we were created in perfection (perfect holiness).
Why would a perfect being bind his own power? The "rock so big he can't lift it" isn't an argument as much a paradox. If something is omnipotent it has unlimited power. The paradox means unlimited power to create and move, but what happens if each is unbound? It goes back to Epicurus. If he has bound his own power, he's not omnipotent. If he chooses to not fully exercise that power, that's another matter.

So the paradox is less about God specifically and more about omnipotence as an abstract idea. More like what happens if an immovable object meets an unstoppable force? Either one of those descriptions is false or we have a paradox on our hands.

The have to/chose to thing is a bit more complicated, but borders on more argumentative than I feel comfortable venturing in to. The crux of my question was, why did he have to send a son to suffer to forgive us from a sin he imposed due to an ancestors choice? Why couldn't he just wave his hand and say 'You are forgiven, say 4 Our Fathers, volunteer at the soup kitchen and be nice to your brother'?

If your kid breaks a window, you don't have to pick up the shard of glass and slice your hand to say, "My son, you are forgiven. Don't you see the pain I go through to forgive you?" You could choose to do so. Or you could put your hands on your hips and frown with that disappointing voice, "I'm not mad. Just disappointed," and let the guilt remind him of his mistake.

Why couldn't/didn't God have done the latter? If it's unconditional love, why take something perfect (our original form), convert it to something imperfect, make it suffer a few decades (if you're lucky) so that you can convert it back to being perfect? If he can do it for imperfect beings, and we are all imperfect, why do you need church and scripture or to live like Jesus to be accepted for eternity couldn't he just make us all perfect when we die?

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Socnorb11 »

vinsanity wrote:
Fat Strat wrote:God chooses to bind himself by his own character. Holiness is one defining aspect of his character -- perfection. Christians believe we were created in perfection (perfect holiness).
Why would a perfect being bind his own power? The "rock so big he can't lift it" isn't an argument as much a paradox. If something is omnipotent it has unlimited power. The paradox means unlimited power to create and move, but what happens if each is unbound? It goes back to Epicurus. If he has bound his own power, he's not omnipotent. If he chooses to not fully exercise that power, that's another matter.

So the paradox is less about God specifically and more about omnipotence as an abstract idea. More like what happens if an immovable object meets an unstoppable force? Either one of those descriptions is false or we have a paradox on our hands.

The have to/chose to thing is a bit more complicated, but borders on more argumentative than I feel comfortable venturing in to. The crux of my question was, why did he have to send a son to suffer to forgive us from a sin he imposed due to an ancestors choice? Why couldn't he just wave his hand and say 'You are forgiven, say 4 Our Fathers, volunteer at the soup kitchen and be nice to your brother'?

If your kid breaks a window, you don't have to pick up the shard of glass and slice your hand to say, "My son, you are forgiven. Don't you see the pain I go through to forgive you?" You could choose to do so. Or you could put your hands on your hips and frown with that disappointing voice, "I'm not mad. Just disappointed," and let the guilt remind him of his mistake.

Why couldn't/didn't God have done the latter? If it's unconditional love, why take something perfect (our original form), convert it to something imperfect, make it suffer a few decades (if you're lucky) so that you can convert it back to being perfect? If he can do it for imperfect beings, and we are all imperfect, why do you need church and scripture or to live like Jesus to be accepted for eternity couldn't he just make us all perfect when we die?

He could have done all of the things that you mentioned above..

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Socnorb11 »

With all due respect, Vin - it's a little obnoxious of you to continue to bait Fat into explaining and justifying his faith repeatedly. I'm not sure why he's bothering, at this point. If you want the answers, why not Google it, or better yet........ talk to your local pastor? I mean, what is your objective here? You really think you're going to break Fat down? Honestly?

User avatar
TAZ
Veteran Player
Posts: 714
Joined: November 8 06, 6:35 pm
Location: O'Fallon, Missouri

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TAZ »

Thanks Jim!
And thanks for your thoughtful reply Fat. I'm way more of a drive-by poster anyway, but I can't help it either, this stuff fascinates me.
Fat Strat wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
Fat Strat wrote:What do you mean that "God still has to do X in order to do Y"?
I'll take a stab because I think it's a good question either way. He's saying that statement and this one:
You're also correct to say that God is "unbound".
Is contradictory. If God were unbound, he wouldn't have to do anything. If God were unbound he wouldn't have to send himself to a virgin to suffer for our sins against him so he could forgive us. If he were unbound, he could just forgive us.
God chooses to bind himself by his own character. Holiness is one defining aspect of his character -- perfection. Christians believe we were created in perfection (perfect holiness). That's our live pre-sin in the Garden of Eden. But sin entered. By defintion, it is imperfection -- it creates a void of separation between us and God. We have chosen an imperfect path rather than God's perfection. The stain of that is complete... Any imperfection is enough to make something (in this case us) less than perfect.
Pretty much right on the head Vin. I think what I'm trying to get at is the description of God's nature is... what's the right word?... not contradictory, more... incoherent. I'm asking a similar question to the ole' heavy rock question. Could God create a rule that even God could not break? Replace the God concept with any other idea and most people would give the o_O face and say it doesn't make sense. "Could a circle that could be anything be a squared circle?" The premise is faulty to begin with.

The problem of evil shouldn't exist if what men say about God is true, that God's omnipotent and omnibenevolent. Evil does exist in the world, look at Jr Seau's mom and tell me it doesn't. So either God can stop evil from happening and doesn't, so God's not benevolent. Or God wants to stop evil but can't, God's not omnipotent. Or God doesn't stop evil and doesn't want to, God's neither. If you say God wants to stop evil and does, I'd say evil still happens to some people so God's not consistent, which you'd think would also be a defining characteristic of someone "perfect".
Fat Strat wrote:And that also speaks to your question of evidence. I started by making a decision very early in life (early elementary age) - that God is real. Look around? How can he not be real? That's what I thought. Creation was all the evidence I needed....
Fat Strat wrote:So, you ask about evidence? That's my evidence....
I'm glad that you've taken this approach, mostly at least... There's nothing that is more shocking to me than believers that try to convince me that there is actually, unbiased, testable, measurable, falsifiable scientific evidence. There isn't.

But you are committing the fallacy of appealing to ignorance. http://www.fallacyfiles.org/ignorant.html

In fact, there are very solid, predictable, testable, falsifiable scientific theories that DO account for large-and-small scale creation of cosmic bodies and space/time. There is the fact that life evolves and the process by which that occurs is described in the theory of evolution. It isn't a theory yet, but there's a good hypothesis of the start of life (that's different than evolution) in abiogenesis. We're a little further away about what happened the instant of the big bang, but there's some good ideas.

But saying "We don't know how this happens ergo God" gets you further away from an explanation, because even *if* that is correct, you've only explained the WHO and not the HOW. *If* God did start it all then there's a new "how" that needs to explain "how" God got the ability to, you know, create a universe from nothing (or from its "brain" and why it has a brain in the first place).

One last thing that's been circling in my head, would love to hear your thoughts...

Why does the Bible not have any information in it that wasn't known to people, at least the literates, at the time it was written? It shows people coming first, a clear metaphor for evolution would've had all "lesser" lifeforms come first and god then perfects his creation with humanity, but this is not what we get in either of the 2 differing Genesis creation stories. It gets light first before the sun's created. It says multiple times that the Earth is on pillars and does not move. The writers come up with pi=3.0 (something about a circled place, measured in cubits, can't recall the exact book and verse). It tells us that we are God's special creation and everything was made for us, when the Earth is 70% inhabitable, the vacuum of space will kill us instantly, and the simple size of the cosmos is so inconceivable that it's impossible to think our little spot is the reason for it all (I guess this last statement of mine is my appeal to ignorance as well).
Check this out. One purplish pixel is the galaxy CLUSTER that our Milky Way is a part of. Seriously. It is mind-boggling.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-09-29/m ... ad/3050580

edit - Dangit! I made a huge posts again...

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat Strat »

I actually think that I've addressed most of your questions in this thread already. At this point you're addressing your arguments rather than my statements concerning your questions...
The have to/chose to thing is a bit more complicated, but borders on more argumentative than I feel comfortable venturing in to.


The "chose to" part is foundational to the identity and incarnation of Christ, the creation of man, salvation/redemption, and the very character, nature, and activity of God. I think I've explained it as adequately as I can.

User avatar
TAZ
Veteran Player
Posts: 714
Joined: November 8 06, 6:35 pm
Location: O'Fallon, Missouri

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TAZ »

Socnorb11 wrote:With all due respect, Vin - it's a little obnoxious of you to continue to bait Fat into explaining and justifying his faith repeatedly. I'm not sure why he's bothering, at this point. If you want the answers, why not Google it, or better yet........ talk to your local pastor? I mean, what is your objective here? You really think you're going to break Fat down? Honestly?
I only speak for myself, but, I get into these because they're fun. It's mental exercise. It's honing our arguments (on both sides).
I don't expect to "break down" anyone. Just like to see where people come from and their thought process.

I'll tell you this - if you talk to a local pastor, you will not get consistent answers to most of these questions. Faith is unevidenced and subjective. There's no consistent mechanism for determining what is metaphor and is literal truth (talk to a fundamentalist and a liberal theologian about Noah's flood and about the crucifixion, it's interesting to see one imbrace both as absolute truth and the other say "well the flood shows us X but the rising of Christ is for reals"). People fall into a wide spectrum, so it's interesting to me to figure out where they are on the faith spectrum and how they think about certain issues with faith.

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat Strat »

TAZ wrote:I only speak for myself, but, I get into these because they're fun. It's mental exercise. It's honing our arguments (on both sides).
I agree. It's fun. We're never going to come to agreement, but nothing wrong with some hearty discussion so long as it doesn't end in a shouting match. I could definitely address your most recent post, but I think the mods are about to lock us out. Discussion probably has run its course and these conversations on here have a tendency to break down to shouting matches eventually...

User avatar
TAZ
Veteran Player
Posts: 714
Joined: November 8 06, 6:35 pm
Location: O'Fallon, Missouri

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by TAZ »

Fat Strat wrote:
TAZ wrote:I only speak for myself, but, I get into these because they're fun. It's mental exercise. It's honing our arguments (on both sides).
I agree. It's fun. We're never going to come to agreement, but nothing wrong with some hearty discussion so long as it doesn't end in a shouting match. I could definitely address your most recent post, but I think the mods are about to lock us out. Discussion probably has run its course and these conversations on here have a tendency to break down to shouting matches eventually...
Oh yeah, for sure. I agree. It was good stuff.

But anywho... in a different direction... fb posters are silly.

http://www.lamebook.com/

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Hungary Jack »

Faith is unevidenced and subjective.
The world would be a more chilled place if everyone understood this.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by jim »

Hungary Jack wrote:
Faith is unevidenced and subjective.
The world would be a more chilled place if everyone understood this.
I don't even think it's a word though.

Locked