The Trayvon Martin shooting

Chat about non-baseball topics. No political discussions!
Post Reply
User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by vinsanity »

Cole Burns wrote:Let's see...same state that let Casey Anthony go free? There's no way that could happen twice.

This is an easy prophecy: Buildings will burn.
Zimmerman charged with second degree murder and manslaughter.

I'm not sure this case is the same as the Casey Anthony trial at all. The prosecution went for first degree and manslaughter there as well, but their case was much more unsure. They had to prove she intended to kill her child for the murder charge or that it was gross negligence that led to her death. Is it not reasonable to believe the child died in a tragic, unpreventable circumstance?

Here you have a guy who has admitted he shot the victim. You have a guy who called 911 thinking someone was suspicious. An operator repeatedly asking the man to not confront the victim and confronted him anyway. You have a man who has an alleged history of violence. When you instigate a confrontation, with a loaded weapon no less, I think you have a hard time justifying that deadly force was necessary. Both men would have their lives if Zimmerman had stayed away, as the operator asked him to do.

But, we don't have all the evidence either. We shall see.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by cards2468 »

vinsanity wrote:
Cole Burns wrote:Let's see...same state that let Casey Anthony go free? There's no way that could happen twice.

This is an easy prophecy: Buildings will burn.
Zimmerman charged with second degree murder and manslaughter.

I'm not sure this case is the same as the Casey Anthony trial at all. The prosecution went for first degree and manslaughter there as well, but their case was much more unsure. They had to prove she intended to kill her child for the murder charge or that it was gross negligence that led to her death. Is it not reasonable to believe the child died in a tragic, unpreventable circumstance?

Here you have a guy who has admitted he shot the victim. You have a guy who called 911 thinking someone was suspicious. An operator repeatedly asking the man to not confront the victim and confronted him anyway. You have a man who has an alleged history of violence. When you instigate a confrontation, with a loaded weapon no less, I think you have a hard time justifying that deadly force was necessary. Both men would have their lives if Zimmerman had stayed away, as the operator asked him to do.

But, we don't have all the evidence either. We shall see.
Since Zimmerman was legally allowed to confront Martin, it will all come down to figuring out if or if not Zimmerman was acting in self defense. That's the part that might be hard to prove and could lead to Zimmerman being acquitted, which would then lead to a pretty strong outcry from the public.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by vinsanity »

cards2468 wrote:Since Zimmerman was legally allowed to confront Martin, it will all come down to figuring out if or if not Zimmerman was acting in self defense. That's the part that might be hard to prove and could lead to Zimmerman being acquitted, which would then lead to a pretty strong outcry from the public.
I guess he was 'legally' allowed to confront Martin, but given stand your ground it again seems reasonable to think Martin was standing his ground, since a guy who had been stalking him on a vehicle was approaching him.

With the affirmative defense, Zimmerman has to prove he was attacked, unprovoked. Given that he was on the offensive, he had a weapon with which to protect himself and the testimony of Martin's friend on the phone that Martin felt threatened before Zimmerman approached him, there would have to be some pretty convincing evidence that Zimmerman walked up and was attacked unprovoked. The state doesn't have to prove Zimmerman wasn't attacked.

I'd also be curious to hear the statement about how/when the gun was pulled. If Martin was slamming his head against concrete, it seems like it would be hard to brandish a weapon and shoot someone.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

I am pretty curious as to what will happen....

If he's found guilty, then good. All is well.
If not, then that's troublesome. Not just because Zimmerman will not be held accountable for what appears to be at least manslaughter, but because it is a blueprint for legally executing someone:

Step 1. Find someone you don't like, 'person a', and wait for 'person a' to be alone on public property
Step 2. Conceal your gun
Step 3. Push 'person a'
Step 4. Get beat up
Step 5. Shoot 'person a'

Nothing to see here, move along. Just protecting myself.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by Hungary Jack »

vinsanity wrote:
cards2468 wrote:Since Zimmerman was legally allowed to confront Martin, it will all come down to figuring out if or if not Zimmerman was acting in self defense. That's the part that might be hard to prove and could lead to Zimmerman being acquitted, which would then lead to a pretty strong outcry from the public.
I guess he was 'legally' allowed to confront Martin, but given stand your ground it again seems reasonable to think Martin was standing his ground, since a guy who had been stalking him on a vehicle was approaching him.

With the affirmative defense, Zimmerman has to prove he was attacked, unprovoked. Given that he was on the offensive, he had a weapon with which to protect himself and the testimony of Martin's friend on the phone that Martin felt threatened before Zimmerman approached him, there would have to be some pretty convincing evidence that Zimmerman walked up and was attacked unprovoked. The state doesn't have to prove Zimmerman wasn't attacked.

I'd also be curious to hear the statement about how/when the gun was pulled. If Martin was slamming his head against concrete, it seems like it would be hard to brandish a weapon and shoot someone.
This sums it up nicely. It will all boil down to the credibility of the defendant and his story, because Martin unfortunately is unable to testify.

I don't know enough about the specific charge to gauge the probability of an acquittal, but if it's an overreach and Zim walks, justice will not be served. There has to be some accountability for the fact that he pursued an individual, and then ended up killing a man who was unarmed.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by Socnorb11 »

vinsanity wrote:
cards2468 wrote:Since Zimmerman was legally allowed to confront Martin, it will all come down to figuring out if or if not Zimmerman was acting in self defense. That's the part that might be hard to prove and could lead to Zimmerman being acquitted, which would then lead to a pretty strong outcry from the public.
I guess he was 'legally' allowed to confront Martin, but given stand your ground it again seems reasonable to think Martin was standing his ground, since a guy who had been stalking him on a vehicle was approaching him.

With the affirmative defense, Zimmerman has to prove he was attacked, unprovoked. Given that he was on the offensive, he had a weapon with which to protect himself and the testimony of Martin's friend on the phone that Martin felt threatened before Zimmerman approached him, there would have to be some pretty convincing evidence that Zimmerman walked up and was attacked unprovoked. The state doesn't have to prove Zimmerman wasn't attacked.

I'd also be curious to hear the statement about how/when the gun was pulled. If Martin was slamming his head against concrete, it seems like it would be hard to brandish a weapon and shoot someone.
Martin could pretty clearly use the "stand your ground" rule, but it doesn't really matter since he's dead.

I agree with your last statement, and would just add that it seems odd that if Martin was on top of Zimmerman when he was shot, then why didn't any blood trickle onto Zimmerman? His clothes looked spotless in the police station video.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by vinsanity »

Hungary Jack wrote:I don't know enough about the specific charge to gauge the probability of an acquittal, but if it's an overreach and Zim walks, justice will not be served. There has to be some accountability for the fact that he pursued an individual, and then ended up killing a man who was unarmed.
I think that's why he won't walk on the manslaughter charge, but I think this is a case where the trial is the proper justice and not so much the outcome. I'd rather see 100 guilty men walk free, than 1 innocent one in jail. I also agree with some who suspect a plea may be the more likely scenario where he will spend time in prison but not face a jury.
Socnorb11 wrote:Martin could pretty clearly use the "stand your ground" rule, but it doesn't really matter since he's dead.
What I meant was the prosecution can use that as reasonable doubt against Zimmerman's claim of "stand your ground". Stand your ground doesn't mean you can push someone, get punched then shoot them cause you were afraid for your life. Zimmerman left the safety of his truck, armed, to follow someone he thought was suspicious enough to call the police. That's not something you do when you're fearing for your life and need to use deadly force.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by Socnorb11 »

vinsanity wrote:
Hungary Jack wrote:I don't know enough about the specific charge to gauge the probability of an acquittal, but if it's an overreach and Zim walks, justice will not be served. There has to be some accountability for the fact that he pursued an individual, and then ended up killing a man who was unarmed.
I think that's why he won't walk on the manslaughter charge, but I think this is a case where the trial is the proper justice and not so much the outcome. I'd rather see 100 guilty men walk free, than 1 innocent one in jail. I also agree with some who suspect a plea may be the more likely scenario where he will spend time in prison but not face a jury.
Socnorb11 wrote:Martin could pretty clearly use the "stand your ground" rule, but it doesn't really matter since he's dead.
What I meant was the prosecution can use that as reasonable doubt against Zimmerman's claim of "stand your ground". Stand your ground doesn't mean you can push someone, get punched then shoot them cause you were afraid for your life. Zimmerman left the safety of his truck, armed, to follow someone he thought was suspicious enough to call the police. That's not something you do when you're fearing for your life and need to use deadly force.

OK. I get where you're coming from now. Completely agree.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by cards2468 »

What I'm mostly interested in with this case is that if the feds had to get involved in order to arrest Zimmerman, what's going to be done about the police force/judges/nepotism/racism that appears to have been an issue?

Had attacker and victim been of the same race, would this just have been swept under the rug? It really seems like the possibility of justice being served is only happening because of public outcry.

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43331
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: The Trayvon Martin shooting

Post by heyzeus »

This will likely be the OJ trial for the 2010s. And In Florida! Bring on the RaHoWa!

Post Reply