Hungary Jack wrote:I cannot speak for anyone but me and perhaps a few close friends, but I have little sympathy for teachers unions whose interests put job security above performance. There is just too much at stake to let these things continue without significant change and experimentation in public education, which teachers unions in general oppose.
I would never assert that public school teachers are well paid, but they are certainly not poorly paid, and the benefits of job security and defined benefit pensions are things you typically do not find in the private sector.
The bolded statement, in my anecdotal experience, is overwhelming false.
To use an analogy. Say you work for HR Block doing taxes for people. They agree to pay you $25k/year after requiring 4 years of schooling specializing in accounting and passing the CPA exam. They say you'll have to do 10 returns a week and will get graded on your performance. So you do 10 and you do well enough. But the next year they bring you 20 returns a week and no new employees to help and then say you'll get paid the same $25k, but they're going to take all missed deductions out of your paycheck. Then the following year they fire your assistant, refuse to fix your computer and ask you to do 30 returns a week and cut your pay to $20k.
I'm suggesting I feel sorry for teachers unions but when people want to keep whittling away at teachers salaries, overfill classrooms and take away learning resources then start firing teachers based on performance when we are short teachers - I understand why the union is putting job security as number 1. The state is trying to cut costs - ok I get that - but they are trying to cut teachers pays and eliminate resources that help teachers do their jobs, now you want to fire them on performance?
Then there's the question of how you grade 'performance'. If I Mr. Pryzbylewski and half the class is more concerned with the street than probability theory and their teachers are all but absent, does that make him a bad teacher? Should he be held to the same standards as kids going school in Chesterfield with overbearing parents, less concern where their next meal is coming from and more resources?
How are you going to grade? Standardized tests? Taking time out of class to test based on performance? A very rough estimate of how smart students are? So now 'bad' teachers are going to teach the test and/or cheat to keep from getting fired and students aren't learning. Or if you had 5 5th grade teachers with classes of 30 and one gets fired you could end up 4 5th grade teachers and have classes of 35-40 kids making it that much harder to learn.
All this completely ignores the fact that blaming teachers for bad students is shirking responsibility and independent freedoms that you seem to champion so much. As a parent, is there really anything your kid will learn before college you can't help them with? Why are blaming teachers for lazy kids and absent parents?
We both had professional fathers and came from families of 3 siblings.
You realize that is privileged right? There's nothing wrong with it, but you grew up in what would probably considered the top 10-20% of incomes. How did you pay for college? It's not something anyone should be ashamed of or embarrassed of or judged for. Just as long as you do recognize it and realize that a lot of these problems like education, unemployment, food stamps etc affect a lot hard working people. American people that maybe you haven't interacted with daily. 27% of people have a college degree. You and I and others were born with certain advantages. I'm not suggesting that we be punished for it. I'm not suggesting that everyone should be equal. I just think sometimes we don't fully understand the extent of privilege we have or the extent of the problems outside it.