Use of the word Socialist

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by vinsanity »

Hungary Jack wrote:Sorry about your head.
Explains a lot doesn't it?
Hungary Jack wrote:Starting a business is certainly not everybody, but the opportunities are there for those who really want it. Most people start businesses using other people's money. Bank loans for startups are rare, but businesses that rely on capital equipment can get loans with the equipment as collateral. I see this with restaurants pretty often.
But they have the same, if not then similar, opportunities in China. I think it was Stossel or someone on dateline years ago that went to china for a report on it. They got a permit to start a business at the mall. They had to apply for the permit, find an industry and location that wasn't saturated. You didn't have free reign to pick your location or any business you wanted, but they were preventing two mexican restaurants from opening up side by side. Something like that.

I guess the point is, none of that, starting a business or getting a bank to lend you money or finding investment capital doesn't have to change because of a NHS or better health care. Might there be a few more restrictions and a few more regulations that could dampen a little growth - probably. But I dunno about you, I'd take half the roaring 20's, 90's, early 2000's if it meant no great depression, no dot com bubble and no housing bubble.
Agreed that schools need more money, but increased teacher salaries (which I support) need to be accompanied by rules that eliminate tenure as job security and emphasize greater accountability. Crappy teachers are a big part of the problem, and in principle I trust school supers to figure out which teachers are good performers and which aren't.
I'm in total agreement. There needs to be give and take on each side. Parents need to stop treating teachers as babysitters who will teach their kid everything and they have no responsibility, and Teacher's Unions need to get rid of [expletive] teachers for good reasons. Not because they did porn 20 years ago. Not because they gave the governors son a B. But because they said 2+2=5 or that the National Guard and state police are the same thing (my sophomore history teacher; true story).

But 30 kids to a teacher who gets paid [expletive] doesn't help. Grading them on standardized tests isn't great either since their should be some fluctuation from state-state, city-to-city and even neighborhood to neighborhood.
We (or I) basically get the 70/30 option with my crappy HMO from United Healthcare (I miss my BCBS policy).
I wish I had it that good. I have 70/30 from my employer. Pay $50 copay to see the specialists for some hip problems. Get a bill for $250 for two xrays. Da [expletive]? realize no imaging was covered. Whatever now I know. Go to PT the doc prescribed. No PT is covered till I hit my $3k deductible and then it's only 70%. Ask them how much PT is. Don't know. Why? "Well the hospital has different deals with different insurance companies on what they pay. Plus we don't know your specific plan." "I have to pay for all of it. How much will you bill them?" "well different insurers make us use different codes for different things. the therapists has to record and log everything they did and those get billed at different rates to different companies. Then some offer discounted rates for somethings. Billing will have that info in a few days and you could ask them then." "So there's no way to know how much 1 hour of physical therapy will cost me, till I get the bill?" "Correct".

This doesn't happen if you have one insurance company.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Freed Roger »

Hungary Jack wrote: Education and healthcare need major improvements, but I still think democracy begins and ends with economic choice. I don't think socializing either one (one size fits all) is the way to go.
Interesting paradoxes going on with these two and their respective reform efforts.

I apologize for oversimplify/generalizing here. -People all up in arms about any govt meddling in the high cost inefficient health care system - yet welcoming to legislatures meddling in public ed. Health Care and Public Ed are both necessities, and they seem bent on keeping the inefficiencies of the health care system (crazy CEO pay, middlemen out the arse).Hands off Govt, let the industry experts figure it out

But same entourage has taken up an obsession with legislating Public ED all the way down to curriculm, teacher pay, tenure performance. Hands in Govt. Yikes. Without a doubt, the union busting/vendetta against Dems plays a big role in this.

I realize the public ed budget falls under the state and local budgets, so taxpayers pay for it, and the politicians have oversight responsibilty. Yet Health Care - we all pay for that too, some of it direct with tax dollars even. Seems like the two industries share a lot in common, yet opposite ideologies are being applied.

I realize some say privatize all public schools, (charters/vouchers), and that may work in places, but But generally what is gained there? School superintendent of big school district may make $300-400K. CEO of a hospital system may make 3 to 4 million.

Anyway, its [expletive] up and getting worse.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Hungary Jack »

Perhaps one of the issues in public education is the role of the teachers unions, and public distrust in terms of accountability and teachers' unions acting more in the interest of job security than significant reform. I don't know what research suggests about the public's opinions of teachers unions, but here in Chicago the anecdotal evidences suggests that they are not very popular with Joe Taxpayer (the Plumber's brother). Thus the demand for local pols to get heavily involved in regulating schools, curriculum, etc. They cannot do much to change the workforce practices, but they can tinker with everything else.

I think school privatization and charter schools are about trying new models that are free of union restrictions and constraints in the areas of compensation, performance evaluation, etc. I applaud these efforts, but it's far too early to say whether or not they are a solution.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Freed Roger »

Hungary Jack wrote:Perhaps one of the issues in public education is the role of the teachers unions, and public distrust in terms of accountability and teachers' unions acting more in the interest of job security than significant reform. I don't know what research suggests about the public's opinions of teachers unions, but here in Chicago the anecdotal evidences suggests that they are not very popular with Joe Taxpayer (the Plumber's brother). Thus the demand for local pols to get heavily involved in regulating schools, curriculum, etc. They cannot do much to change the workforce practices, but they can tinker with everything else.

I think school privatization and charter schools are about trying new models that are free of union restrictions and constraints in the areas of compensation, performance evaluation, etc. I applaud these efforts, but it's far too early to say whether or not they are a solution.
Go ahead. Just call them union goons and thugs. You know you want to.
:wink:

Too bad that the tea party/GOP is using the obvious problems in places like IL as a trojan horse for vendetta/power grab against democrats in places that do not have too bad of problems (MO, WI). Not that reforms aren't needed, but the ones pushing the reforms are untrustworthy. ...hell Walker was caught cheating in college had his dad fix it, and eventually dropped out.

I agree, the unions aren't popular with joe taxpayers, but how much of it is because of the divisive/race to the bottom disinformation campaign. "they got pensions and you don't, they don't work summers, they don't pay for health care, AND you do people!-grab your pitchforks and torches!"

....well let me tell you something Joe Taxpayer. Walmart Greeters are entitled to a 10% employee discount, and you aren't. So lets grab a motorized shopping cart and Storm the Gates!

...ahh this is fun.


charters, vouchers, -we'll see. Mixed results so far. I'd rather them generally try to fix broken schools and if people want private ed, they pay out of their own pocket -like I used to for kid #1.

Small sample size comparison, but Kid #2 is flourishing in an excellent public school. The teachers and the school are way better than what we paid for in private. What helps is that it is a small public school with a good local tax base, and has the aspects that you normally associate with private schools - nice parental involvement and community spirit.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by vinsanity »

Hungary Jack wrote:Perhaps one of the issues in public education is the role of the teachers unions, and public distrust in terms of accountability and teachers' unions acting more in the interest of job security than significant reform.
I'd say this is far. However, there's a cause/effect question here. Are unions more focused on security than reform and accountability because states wanna slash funding then lower wages because of falling scores?

I guess what I mean is, if we gave the teachers we have better opportunities with class sizes, resources and pay and made it a more reasonable choice of profession maybe unions could do a better trim of holding them accountable. But when we have 30 kids to a teacher and a shortage of teachers as it is, it's tough to just let someone go.

And again, with private and charter schools it's still a nice option...for those that can get there. I'm not saying that unions are blameless or politics are totally to blame. I just don't think we're giving the teachers we have a good opportunity to succeed as it is.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Hungary Jack »

I cannot speak for anyone but me and perhaps a few close friends, but I have little sympathy for teachers unions whose interests put job security above performance. There is just too much at stake to let these things continue without significant change and experimentation in public education, which teachers unions in general oppose.

I would never assert that public school teachers are well paid, but they are certainly not poorly paid, and the benefits of job security and defined benefit pensions are things you typically do not find in the private sector.

What is happening in WI is mean-spirited, IMO. Collective bargaining should be the right of every employee. But it is the responsibility of elected officials to advocate on the behalf of taxpayers, which means asserting taxpayer interests that may contradict public employee interests (in terms of compensation). Walker has taken this to a new level, and I am not sure I agree with it, but public employee unions have had a holy alliance with democratic officials for a long time that has left states like Illinois facing huge public pension shortfalls. Taxpayers like me who pay attention to this are pretty concerned, and should be.

User avatar
IMADreamer
Has an anecdote about a townie he overheard.
Posts: 12909
Joined: December 6 10, 1:09 am
Location: Illinois

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by IMADreamer »

Hungary Jack wrote:"Most of the people in this country let alone the world, will never have the money or opportunity to start their own business."

Starting a business is certainly not everybody, but the opportunities are there for those who really want it. Most people start businesses using other people's money. Bank loans for startups are rare, but businesses that rely on capital equipment can get loans with the equipment as collateral. I see this with restaurants pretty often.

Agreed that schools need more money, but increased teacher salaries (which I support) need to be accompanied by rules that eliminate tenure as job security and emphasize greater accountability. Crappy teachers are a big part of the problem, and in principle I trust school supers to figure out which teachers are good performers and which aren't.

We (or I) basically get the 70/30 option with my crappy HMO from United Healthcare (I miss my BCBS policy).

Sorry about your head.
You know I can't keep up with you guys on this forum, I'm not smart enough I know it, but I can speak from experience which I feel like at 30 I've lived two life times because of growing up on a farm and all the hard times I saw in doing so, then going out on my own living in a city and coming back to my small town.

I think one thing I do have the experience to speak on is starting, or atleast buying a small business, and also the availability of the American dream. Most of my life I spent my life running away from farming and probably what I really am. When I was finally grown up enough to realize that I love farming and the farm lifestyle it was really too late to get into it. Yes my family has a nice sized operation but the problem is "buying in" to that operation is financially impossible for me. We are talking millions to do so. This has become fact in farm communities. It is virtually impossible to get in now because of the financial and economical situation of the country, banks, and the ag industry. No bank, will go out and loan a start up the money to farm. Cases like mine are becoming more common where ideally you would inherit the farm and take over, but that too in impractical because the previous generation (my father, and uncles) have put everything they have back into the farm. So when they decide to call it quits they will get their retirement fund by selling out. It's what my grandfather did, and his father before that. So back to the idea of starting up, well a start up won't get the huge discounts on a seeds a large operator will. The same goes for chemicals, fertilizer, etc. It's all stacked against you.

So maybe another business is possible. Well that's what I did, but I'm not going to sugar coat it, the only reason I was able to buy an existing business was because, first I knew the owner that was selling which gave me an in to the industry. Second I had worked for years several jobs to have my own start up money, and third due to my families great standing and long term relationship with a local bank some strings were pulled, favors, were asked, and I was able to get a loan that I wouldn't have gotten other wise.

I guess my point is that I feel extremely lucky, I caught some great breaks that because of my family situation and other things that I don't think most would get. A good friend of mine is trying to start up a business in NJ, he works as hard as I do, has great credit, etc but can't get a loan from anyone and he needs half of what I needed. So I ask what is the difference in our situations? Well I knew a guy who could pull some strings, he doesn't.

That's where I feel we are at in America, if you know someone you are golden, if not you are [expletive] and have no chance. So while it seems hypocritical of me to say things like this, I feel the American dreams is very much dead, or atleast on it's death bed. I often wonder how the next generation will do it, or even if there will be any small businesses in 25 years.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Hungary Jack »

If you think that in America entrepreneurship is the province only of insiders and people in the know, then you would find it to be an iron-walled castle surrounded by a moat full of alligators, piranhas, and e coli in Europe and China.

It doesn't really matter how you were able to get your business. You found an opportunity and took the risk and hopefully are reaping the rewards. Your friend who needs the funding needs to get creative about finding it, because there is a lot of money out there looking for a good home. If his plan is viable and sound and the terms are right, investors will participate.

So yes networking is incredibly important. That's why people pay $100k for an MBA. Not so much the edumacation, but the network.

But it isn't most of life's opportunities about networking and expanding your horizons through social connections? This forum is an example right? We hobnob here, meet new personalities, and exchange all sorts of insults and ideas, which enriches our lives.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Freed Roger »

Hungary Jack wrote:I cannot speak for anyone but me and perhaps a few close friends, but I have little sympathy for teachers unions whose interests put job security above performance. There is just too much at stake to let these things continue without significant change and experimentation in public education, which teachers unions in general oppose.

I would never assert that public school teachers are well paid, but they are certainly not poorly paid, and the benefits of job security and defined benefit pensions are things you typically do not find in the private sector.

What is happening in WI is mean-spirited, IMO. Collective bargaining should be the right of every employee. But it is the responsibility of elected officials to advocate on the behalf of taxpayers, which means asserting taxpayer interests that may contradict public employee interests (in terms of compensation). Walker has taken this to a new level, and I am not sure I agree with it, but public employee unions have had a holy alliance with democratic officials for a long time that has left states like Illinois facing huge public pension shortfalls. Taxpayers like me who pay attention to this are pretty concerned, and should be.
I'm betting, living in corrupt, democratic union Chicago IL has skewed your views. WI is not IL. And any cheesehead worth their bratwurst would fight you over a comparison to ILL.

What Walker is doing in WI has nothing to do with balancing the budget, and everything to do with partisan politics. He is running an authoritarian government and is taking all of his advice on education reform from business leaders and donors, and none of it from education leaders.

Balancing the budget is just a numbers game, it is not short or long term results. I could balance a budget -BAM lets eliminate the Dept of Trans. Bam lets raise taxes. He played the entire # on public workers. You would think the investor class, who played a role in the economic meltdown would share some of the sacrifice.

Needless to say, my family is pissed, they never were part of any political or a democratic machine, and had their beefs with the union, even though they know unions are a net positive for teachers and school districts.

One brother liked to call himself a libertarian back before it was popular - and decade before it was bastardized by the GOP and tea party. My brother's kids have elementary school class size of +30 now, taken a $4000 paycut (with more to come), and been scapegoated and raked over the coals. They can only hope one of these dumbass GOP president candidates selecst Walker as a VP running mate. Sarah Palin in drag.

Taxpayers pay attention to what happens around them. In your case you have Chicago and IL. Others pay attention to the pro-business media.

Anyway, recently Spectrum Brands announced they will get a $4 million dollar taxpayer incentive to keep their HQ in WI. I'm not an absolutist, sometimes incentives to business are necessary. (Look at Obama bragging about GM already. ) But Spectrum illustrates how crony this crap is. Pay us or we'll move. They went through bankruptcy in 2009, so probably got a lot of welfare relief there and stiffed many a supplier. The CEO had $13,700,000 in compensation, yet they need a taxpayer handout.

Aaahh the new capitalism.

User avatar
IMADreamer
Has an anecdote about a townie he overheard.
Posts: 12909
Joined: December 6 10, 1:09 am
Location: Illinois

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by IMADreamer »

Yeah but that CEO works so hard, some Saturdays even.

Post Reply