Use of the word Socialist

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
Adrian Wapcaplet
All-Star
Posts: 1483
Joined: April 19 06, 8:00 am
Location: The Des Moines Metro Area
Contact:

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Adrian Wapcaplet »

Well said, Mr Sanity.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Freed Roger »

Agreed. Good thoughts there Vin.

US is having a hard time maturing, aren't a growing nation anymore. With limited exceptions, it's not wide open- as a China is now. Like it or not, we are getting more akin to UK and Europe - nations that have been around- with empire building done, borders set, natural resources quantified and limited.... don't get me wrong, with some technologies/industries the US will and needs to grow- but for most part, it is time to start figuring out how to live sustainably with what we have.

This is next to impossible to do with an ultra-lopsided control and wealth. And a moronic level of politic, put forth in order to maintain this control.

And is it possible that different balancing acts of the "isms" work better based on cultures/norms and other conditions?
FWIW-Forbes does "happiest" countries lists
US is #10, but some of those socialist places seem to be working out ok. Point is, there is no one true way - and American Exceptionalism is bogus Sh*t.

User avatar
slide_into_first
is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
Posts: 14433
Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by slide_into_first »

Obama supports robbing the poor to support the rich viz a viz if you're not part of the solution, you're part of the problem.

User avatar
slide_into_first
is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
Posts: 14433
Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by slide_into_first »

I think what IMADreamer is saying is Obama still could be a Muslim and an illegal alien.

User avatar
IMADreamer
Has an anecdote about a townie he overheard.
Posts: 12909
Joined: December 6 10, 1:09 am
Location: Illinois

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by IMADreamer »

slide_into_first wrote:I think what IMADreamer is saying is Obama still could be a Muslim and an illegal alien.

Obviously.


Vin you are spot on. I don't think most of this country realizes how good it is in other countries of the world. I've never met someone who lived in Europe that didn't love it and didn't say how much better it was there because you don't have the constant worry of education and health care on your mind.

User avatar
slide_into_first
is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
Posts: 14433
Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by slide_into_first »

You know I'm just messin' with you. I bought March corn after the bearish supply demand report at 592 and it's up to 643. Thanks.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by vinsanity »

IMADreamer wrote:Vin you are spot on. I don't think most of this country realizes how good it is in other countries of the world. I've never met someone who lived in Europe that didn't love it and didn't say how much better it was there because you don't have the constant worry of education and health care on your mind.
It's beyond that. Things like the Red Scare and Cold War have turned communism/socialism in to something back. It seems like people think all 'isms' are bad.

It's not even about how much better other places are. It's the weird connection where if you ask someone if they want "Socialized health care" it gets overwhelming opposed. But if you ask the same people if they supported something like Medicare for everyone, where the government uses your medicare/medicaid taxes to pay for your health insurance then the same people support that plan.

It's Glen Beck telling people to go to the library and read a book on why socialism is bad. No [expletive] joke. It's the Tea Party telling the middle class to take the government back from wall street and stop the cronyism but decrying communism as evil. People don't understand that Social Security they collect, libraries, highway systems, government subsidies, co-ops are all forms of socialism and communism.

Not to get too off the deep end with 'conspiracies' but it comes down to education. What benefit do the capitalists and politicians have in educating people that Communism isn't a totalitarian/fascist regime. It's not about one person being a 'Czar' or Dictator. It doesn't even have to be about lack of competition. Socialism and Communism are about a large group of people doing what's best for the whole of the group. It's so much easier to keep power and money centralized if you can get the uneducated to fear everything you dislike by labeling it capitalism. It's a bit...out there, but it's a quote from Carlin as part of a bit I've always loved.
They say we need more money for education, we need more books, more teachers, more classrooms, more schools, we need more testing for the kids. You say to one of them: well, you know, we’ve tried all of that and the kids still can’t pass the tests. Ah don’t you worry about that, we’re going to lower the passing grades. And that’s what they do in a lot of these schools, they lower the passing grades, so more kids can pass. More kids pass, the school looks good, everybody is happy, the IQ of the country slips another two or three points and pretty soon all you need to get into college is a [expletive] pencil. Got a pencil, get the [expletive] in there, it’s physics. Then everyone wonders why 17 other countries graduate more scientists than we do. Education! Politicians know that word. They use it on you. Politicians have traditionally hidden behind three things: the Flag, the Bible and Children. No child left behind! No child left behind! Oh really? It wasn’t long ago that you were talking about giving kids a head start. Head start? Left behind? Someone’s losing [expletive] ground here.

They don’t care about you at all. At all. At all. And nobody seems to notice. Nobody seems to care. That’s what the owners count on. The fact that Americans will probably remain willfully ignorant of the big red, white and blue dick that’s being jammed up their [expletive] every day, because the owners of this country know the truth. It’s called the American Dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Hungary Jack »

Do they per capita income figures reflect real (cost of living adjusted) or nominal incomes? I am not trying to refute the point, just ensuring a proper comparison.

Two anecdotal pieces of evidence regarding the relative desirability of the US as a place to live/work: 1) A lot of the students I have encountered in recent years still view the States as the best place to start a business, especially the European ones. But India and China are definitely considered great opportunities, for good reason. 2) My father, the heart surgeon, has operated on many wealthy Europeans who could not bear to wait for socialize medicine (and he has worked almost exclusively in academic hospitals, ie not private practice).

If real issue issue is income inequality (and largely I suspect it is), then reforming the tax code is a big step in addressing this. Raise the capital gains tax to 20% (as I said earlier); lower the statutory corporate rate to 25% (promotes investment here) while eliminating the loopholes to get the effective rate very near 25%, and keep marginal rates on income progressive but not obscene at the upper levels.

Education and healthcare need major improvements, but I still think democracy begins and ends with economic choice. I don't think socializing either one (one size fits all) is the way to go.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by vinsanity »

Hungary Jack wrote:Do they per capita income figures reflect real (cost of living adjusted) or nominal incomes? I am not trying to refute the point, just ensuring a proper comparison.
I actual don't know.
Two anecdotal pieces of evidence regarding the relative desirability of the US as a place to live/work: 1) A lot of the students I have encountered in recent years still view the States as the best place to start a business, especially the European ones. But India and China are definitely considered great opportunities, for good reason. 2) My father, the heart surgeon, has operated on many wealthy Europeans who could not bear to wait for socialize medicine (and he has worked almost exclusively in academic hospitals, ie not private practice).
The only problem is, starting a business or not being able to wait for a heart surgeon and having the ability to pay for it are things that affect, forgive me, the top 1%. Most of the people in this country let alone the world, will never have the money or opportunity to start their own business. That's fine. We need workers. But no one, anywhere, should make $1.50/hour to assemble an iPhone so an Apple Shareholder can afford a new lambo.
If real issue issue is income inequality (and largely I suspect it is), then reforming the tax code is a big step in addressing this. Raise the capital gains tax to 20% (as I said earlier); lower the statutory corporate rate to 25% (promotes investment here) while eliminating the loopholes to get the effective rate very near 25%, and keep marginal rates on income progressive but not obscene at the upper levels.
It's not the inequality specifically as how much inequality. The amount of wealth being concentrated at the top has grown the last 40 years.
Image
Nothing in communism or socialism says that there's something inherently wrong with a CEO making more than a factory worker. Nothing says you can't have a richer class. No one is advocating that every person in the country is exactly equal (See: Harrison Bergeron espousing these ideas from a staunch liberal/socialist). The problem is that congress is on the take. That corporations and wealthy people can afford more influence and are doing it at the expense of most Americans.
Education and healthcare need major improvements, but I still think democracy begins and ends with economic choice. I don't think socializing either one (one size fits all) is the way to go.
Again. This is a misrepresentation of what socialism is. It's not a one size fits all approach. Education is already socialized but it still offers economic choice. You don't like the public school you're kid will go to and have the means to offer them a better education? You do it! Our educational system is woeful, and it's creating idiot parents who aren't helping kids help themselves. It's a sad, terrible trend that can change if we'd pay our teachers a decent wage and stop letting Texas decide what goes in every text book. The schools need more money. I don't care if it's from gambling taxes, pot taxes, lottery taxes or income taxes. Democracy and economic choice have nothing to do with one another. It's like saying basketball begins with a good quarterback. Democracy is electing officials. Period. Economic choice is part of a financial structure of how money flows between governments, business and consumers. You can socialism, democracy and economic choice.

Same with Healthcare. Socialized healthcare doesn't have mean there's no choice. Every one hears these things and gets scared and vilifies something they may or may not understand.

I believe Canada's health care plan is like 70/30 mix. The government negotiates and pays for 70% of all costs and you can buy insurance for the other 30% that'll cover more of the elective type things or over-runs in costs. There's no reason the government couldn't set up a system that said "Hey Doc's. We'll pay you $150 for every x-ray. We'll give you $6k for every joint replacement and $10k for every child birth." Then they negotiate like a union would and say "Well materials and radiologsts are $150, so how about $175. And we need $7k for joints, and we can natural child birth for $8k, but $10k for the C-Section". So if I want an x-ray for my every other yera knee check up I can wait the 6 weeks for an appointment (bout how long it takes for me now anyway) and get it done/read by a random doc.

But if I think Paletta can do a better a job, I could go to him and he could bill me $10k. The government covers $7k and I have to cover the extra $3k to get a better doc and it done quicker.

Socialized health care and the free market are not mutually exclusive. It doesn't have to be one or the other. Every European I've talked to (a handful) have said the long wait tiems you hear about are for tatoo removes that NHS will pay for. It's for elective and non immediate surgeries. My mom got a broken bone take care of in the Canadian ER. Free. She started to complain about it taking 3 hours to get seen, but it was a Friday night or something and a broken finger - not exactly life threatening. We recalled that once I sat in a wheel chair bleeding from my head (a 4x6 peice of pine feel on it, I was 10) for 3 hours in an ER waiting room while the took a girl with a sprained ankle in for an xray. Get that?

A 10 year old, pale from blood loss from his head, with a possible concussion was passed over for a girl with a sprained ankle. Even at the ankle sprains protest! And you're afraid of rationing care and choice? What about when a private insurance company refuses to pay $15k on a tumor resection that saves a 12 year old's leg cause it only costs $5k to amputate it? Or how about refusing to pay $100/week for anti-nausea meds for a chemo patient because it's not 'necessary'? How about dropping an entire small-business from the insurance because there were too many claims per person since two families were stricken with cancer?

That's economic choice? If that's choice, I don't want it. I'll gladly wait 6 weeks to see my doc about my heart burn if I don't have to pay for it and some 15 year old kid's parents don't have to choose between their retirement accounts and his leg.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: Use of the word Socialist

Post by Hungary Jack »

"Most of the people in this country let alone the world, will never have the money or opportunity to start their own business."

Starting a business is certainly not everybody, but the opportunities are there for those who really want it. Most people start businesses using other people's money. Bank loans for startups are rare, but businesses that rely on capital equipment can get loans with the equipment as collateral. I see this with restaurants pretty often.

Agreed that schools need more money, but increased teacher salaries (which I support) need to be accompanied by rules that eliminate tenure as job security and emphasize greater accountability. Crappy teachers are a big part of the problem, and in principle I trust school supers to figure out which teachers are good performers and which aren't.

We (or I) basically get the 70/30 option with my crappy HMO from United Healthcare (I miss my BCBS policy).

Sorry about your head.

Post Reply