160 pounds?! Nathan Gerbe, the smallest player in the NHL, is 5'5" and 180 pounds. The average NHL forward is 6' and between 195-210 pounds, pop that up to 6'1 1/2" 210-220 for defensemen. You're right though, that I have the linebacker weight wrong. They average 230-250 pounds. I should have said cornerback.Popeye_Card wrote:True, and I don't think hockey helmets are as padded as an NFL helmet.JackofDiamonds wrote:Football's concussions may not be as bad, remember, it's "Mass x Velocity^2." These guys fly around the rink at 30mph and aren't much smaller than your average linebacker.
But most collisions in hockey don't occur at full speed. Perron was travelling at maybe 15-20 mph, with Thornton going at maybe 10-15 when that collision happened--not much different than a running speed. While it was helmet to helmet, it wasn't nearly as viscious as you see on a weekly basis in the NFL.
And on the subject of mass, Joe Thornton is one of the largest forwards in the NHL, listed at 6-4, 230. Weight-wise, that's a pretty average linebacker. Most NHL players are more in the 160-200 pound range, a good deal below most non-kicker NFL players.
And most collisions in football don't happen at full speed either. Someone is slowing down to time a catch, someone is coming off a block, etc. etc.
Add in the difference between turf and ice, sidelines and boards, and hockey concussions make more sense to me.



