I'd imagine it would be the same as alcohol. You might get a misdemeanor, you might just have to destroy it on the spot and be let off with a warning. So yea, I guess it wouldn't have been much different if it weren't legalized, but at least it wouldn't carry the stigma that he committed a crime that isn't age dependent. The schools would probably go easier too. Kids get busted all the time for alcohol possession, and at my school it usually resulted in an afternoon of picking up trash in the parking lot, so no threat of not being able to finish school that year.Freed Roger wrote:It does make sense to have some rules and parameters on drug use with schools- be it alcohol or a dime bag. Someone explain how legalizing and taxing pot for HS kids is going to work out? At that age, most kids don't have much sense with limits, and sometimes the weight of the law and consequences is not always or often an effective constraint, but it is still necessary.cards2468 wrote:It's a little more free-market than illegalizing it and arresting kids for carrying a dime bag.Freed Roger wrote:That's rather anti-free markets of you.Hungary Jack wrote: Seriously, the government should decriminalize possession of small amounts and regulate (and tax) its sale.
My 20year old stepdaughter recently was flagged for minor in possession of bud light at a concert. Her boyfriend, who is 22 was ticketed for providing. Both misdemeanors. It sort of seems silly - only a few months from being legal and all, and she is not a boozer. But hey, that is life. There needs to be some sort of rules to the game, and she knew them, took the risk and was caught. The consequences aren't too bad and are not life altering.
It sounds like the whole thing is working out ok for Radbirds nephew.
My Nephew's Predicament
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
- JCShutout
- MacGyver of Underwear
- Posts: 13369
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
- Location: South City
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
First its pot, then its heroin, then its human sex trafficking, then its pig sex trafficking, then its ethnic genocide. I don't think you all are taking into account the dangerous path this young man is traveling down.
Good luck to the kid Rad. Busting kids on crap like this is stupid. Legalize and tax this stuff.
Good luck to the kid Rad. Busting kids on crap like this is stupid. Legalize and tax this stuff.
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
How many innocent people in Mexico were killed by drug cartels just to get that dime bag in to the US?
Dad gum pot heads! Making exploiting Mexico for it's cheap resorts dangerous for us law abiding citizens!!!
Dad gum pot heads! Making exploiting Mexico for it's cheap resorts dangerous for us law abiding citizens!!!
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
My nephew 15 ( a very sweet kid with some above-the-norm mental hurdles) got pretty screwed up with pot, alcohol, prescription meds. An incident at his school is what brought the matter to a head. He spent last Christmas in the hospital. It really rocked their family, they knew of problems, but not the extent -and it all came spilling out since he couldn't sleep for two days because of amphetamines.
Anyway, he has gone through an A A type program and is getting back on track. Everybody is different with how they can handle excesses or use stuff to self-medicate. I'm guessing Radbirds nephew can handle it, and by no means do I feel he should lose college opportunities etc assuming he otherwise qualifies. But there are many many who can't handle the stuff.
I don't think the point of the school or law is to punish, but there needs to be some restrictions . I'm sure some authorities can make the focus of the laws as punishment rather than deterrent and intervention. But authorities have to have something to work with. It doesn't sound too heavy handed to give misdemeanors to minors.
I don't know..., it seems this legalize/tax drugs is a pollyannish solution to drug/alchohol/prescription med abuse. Have to draw the line somewhere.
Anyway, he has gone through an A A type program and is getting back on track. Everybody is different with how they can handle excesses or use stuff to self-medicate. I'm guessing Radbirds nephew can handle it, and by no means do I feel he should lose college opportunities etc assuming he otherwise qualifies. But there are many many who can't handle the stuff.
I don't think the point of the school or law is to punish, but there needs to be some restrictions . I'm sure some authorities can make the focus of the laws as punishment rather than deterrent and intervention. But authorities have to have something to work with. It doesn't sound too heavy handed to give misdemeanors to minors.
I don't know..., it seems this legalize/tax drugs is a pollyannish solution to drug/alchohol/prescription med abuse. Have to draw the line somewhere.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
It's not intended to be a solution to the problem of drug abuse, which is, of course, real and serious. The argument is that the consequences of the drug war are far worse than the original problem. There is extensive research on this showing that treatment is cheaper and more effective than law enforcement, that drug interdictions drive up prices increasing profitability and related crime, etc.Freed Roger wrote:I don't know..., it seems this legalize/tax drugs is a pollyannish solution to drug/alchohol/prescription med abuse. Have to draw the line somewhere.
As to drugs and kids, I think we would do well to have a more honest approach that doesn't paint everything in black and white terms. It does absolutely no good and plenty of real harm to teach kids (as I was taught in the D.A.R.E. program) that all illegal drugs are more or less equally evil, but to say nothing about the massive problem of alcohol abuse. To the extent that the gateway drug theory is true (which is to say not much), lies like this feed it. When kids realize they are being lied to, they may disregard warnings about other drugs.
Anyway, I have no real problem with various authority figures intervening to try and prevent kids from getting too much into drugs, but it's a problem if the goal of that is to punish rather than to help. If you're preventing someone from finishing high school over $15 in pot, the cure is clearly worse than the disease.
- Fat_Bulldog
- likes to grate his own cheese
- Posts: 12883
- Joined: May 9 06, 12:41 pm
- Location: Drunk
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
Arthur Dent wrote:It's not intended to be a solution to the problem of drug abuse, which is, of course, real and serious. The argument is that the consequences of the drug war are far worse than the original problem. There is extensive research on this showing that treatment is cheaper and more effective than law enforcement, that drug interdictions drive up prices increasing profitability and related crime, etc.Freed Roger wrote:I don't know..., it seems this legalize/tax drugs is a pollyannish solution to drug/alchohol/prescription med abuse. Have to draw the line somewhere.
As to drugs and kids, I think we would do well to have a more honest approach that doesn't paint everything in black and white terms. It does absolutely no good and plenty of real harm to teach kids (as I was taught in the D.A.R.E. program) that all illegal drugs are more or less equally evil, but to say nothing about the massive problem of alcohol abuse. To the extent that the gateway drug theory is true (which is to say not much), lies like this feed it. When kids realize they are being lied to, they may disregard warnings about other drugs.
Anyway, I have no real problem with various authority figures intervening to try and prevent kids from getting too much into drugs, but it's a problem if the goal of that is to punish rather than to help. If you're preventing someone from finishing high school over $15 in pot, the cure is clearly worse than the disease.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
It is my understanding that that drugs alcohol can do way more irreparable harm to young developing brains (up to age 25) than to a grown persons - from a purely scientific standpoint.Arthur Dent wrote:It's not intended to be a solution to the problem of drug abuse, which is, of course, real and serious. The argument is that the consequences of the drug war are far worse than the original problem. There is extensive research on this showing that treatment is cheaper and more effective than law enforcement, that drug interdictions drive up prices increasing profitability and related crime, etc.Freed Roger wrote:I don't know..., it seems this legalize/tax drugs is a pollyannish solution to drug/alchohol/prescription med abuse. Have to draw the line somewhere.
Anyway, I have no real problem with various authority figures intervening to try and prevent kids from getting too much into drugs, but it's a problem if the goal of that is to punish rather than to help. If you're preventing someone from finishing high school over $15 in pot, the cure is clearly worse than the disease.
Sure, some authoritiy figures can be counterproductive with punishment use. But they need something to work with. Kicking a kid out of school for minor drug possession may not be the best option, but somewhere in the policy it has to be a threat/option. A lot of times the punishment code or whatever you call it, is needed more to wake up kid's parents than anything.
Then you also have parents that would advocate for no punishment ever for their kids. Take it even further, my friend, a counselor in north suburb STL HS -basically the parents/guardians use their kids to be dealers - because of their access to sales, and slap on the wrist they'd get for being caught. My nephew came across some of this, with the section 8 kids dumped into Chicago suburbs that were "friends" of his -their guardians/parents ranged from non-existent, to benefactors of their HS kid's drug dealing etc.
And yeah, I'm not intending to start the legalization of drugs thread derail. I have mixed feelings and some skepticism there. Too much to write.
And I don't know much about DARE program other than my daughter went through it without much lasting animosity or kickback (and believe me, she would have animosity -she still holds grudges against teachers from 10 years ago.)
- Fat_Bulldog
- likes to grate his own cheese
- Posts: 12883
- Joined: May 9 06, 12:41 pm
- Location: Drunk
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
I went through the DARE program.
Dared me to do a ton of drugs.
I'm okay.
Dared me to do a ton of drugs.
I'm okay.
- docellis
- America's Most Beloved Twitter Joke Thief
- Posts: 24741
- Joined: April 18 06, 6:54 pm
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
It doesn't really matter --- but I really could have sworn the federal aid applications did not specify felony. I remember that because I knew someone in your nephew's situation and I just couldn't believe that they would bother checking to see if people lied about a non-felony.
I could be wrong.
I could be wrong.
- Fat_Bulldog
- likes to grate his own cheese
- Posts: 12883
- Joined: May 9 06, 12:41 pm
- Location: Drunk
Re: My Nephew's Predicament
I stand corrected. Researched it and it states that a conviction of state or federal drug possession will result in a 1 year loss of financial aid eligibility. It also states something about when the conviction occured - if it occured while receiving aid. So, not sure there.docellis wrote:It doesn't really matter --- but I really could have sworn the federal aid applications did not specify felony. I remember that because I knew someone in your nephew's situation and I just couldn't believe that they would bother checking to see if people lied about a non-felony.
I could be wrong.



