Joe Shlabotnik wrote:That's it right there. Discipline. Get out of debt. Stay out of debt.
Stop listening to people calling you a 'consumer' and wanting to get their hands in your wallet. Do what is best for you.
Not all debt is bad. I want to say the 'average' millionaire still carries a mortgage, but has his car paid off. The wealthy get wealthy cause they can use their debt to leverage their money. Can you pay $40k in cash for the new car you want/need? Sure, I have the assets to cover it. But I can get 0 down and a 4% auto loan then invest my $40k in say a rental property or something that'll make me more money than the car loan ends up costing me.
Sure - you have 40K. How do you get that 40K to begin with? Get out of debt. Stay out of debt. Then when you have the resources like 6 months of living expenses saved, meeting your cash flow every month, then you have the freedom to do as you suggest.
Transmogrified Tiger wrote:I'm aware of what the historical returns are. I'm skeptical that they will continue that way for the immediate term, especially depending on what the terms of the loan are. If his loan is like yours and has a 3% rate, then yes, odds are really likely that banking/investing that money is a better bet. This is why I originally said that student loans are one of the few debts it makes sense to just pay the minimum. But if he's got a 6% interest rate and roughly 10 years to go, then the picture is less clear(especially considering the rest of a person's financial picture and preferences).
Yeah, my interest rates are definitely not 3%. I believe the rate on my Federal loans is 6.8%, and the one I got through the state of North Dakota is 6.02%. I'm not positive on that, I can't look it up -- the Bank of North Dakota's website has been down the last couple days.
This isn't directed to anyone in particular, but I have to say I think it's irresponsible to give out authoritative sounding/specific investment advice to people without fully knowing all the relevant factors of their situation. Even if you do have that information there's a good chance you're not qualified to interrupt their situation anyway.
Sorry to be a debbie downer, but this is serious stuff we're discussing.
Michael wrote:This isn't directed to anyone in particular, but I have to say I think it's irresponsible to give out authoritative sounding/specific investment advice to people without fully knowing all the relevant factors of their situation. Even if you do have that information there's a good chance you're not qualified to interrupt their situation anyway.
Sorry to be a debbie downer, but this is serious stuff we're discussing.
This is why I refrain from posting advice in these threads completely. There is not a universal solution in finance.
Michael wrote:This isn't directed to anyone in particular, but I have to say I think it's irresponsible to give out authoritative sounding/specific investment advice to people without fully knowing all the relevant factors of their situation. Even if you do have that information there's a good chance you're not qualified to interrupt their situation anyway.
Sorry to be a debbie downer, but this is serious stuff we're discussing.
This is why I refrain from posting advice in these threads completely. There is not a universal solution in finance.
Michael wrote:This isn't directed to anyone in particular, but I have to say I think it's irresponsible to give out authoritative sounding/specific investment advice to people without fully knowing all the relevant factors of their situation. Even if you do have that information there's a good chance you're not qualified to interrupt their situation anyway.
Sorry to be a debbie downer, but this is serious stuff we're discussing.
This is why I refrain from posting advice in these threads completely. There is not a universal solution in finance.
Michael wrote:This isn't directed to anyone in particular, but I have to say I think it's irresponsible to give out authoritative sounding/specific investment advice to people without fully knowing all the relevant factors of their situation. Even if you do have that information there's a good chance you're not qualified to interrupt their situation anyway.
Sorry to be a debbie downer, but this is serious stuff we're discussing.
This is why I refrain from posting advice in these threads completely. There is not a universal solution in finance.
+
++
----
OK, I just cancelled those dudes out. Fire away willy-nilly, you wannabe Suze Orman types.
Michael wrote:This isn't directed to anyone in particular, but I have to say I think it's irresponsible to give out authoritative sounding/specific investment advice to people without fully knowing all the relevant factors of their situation. Even if you do have that information there's a good chance you're not qualified to interrupt their situation anyway.
Sorry to be a debbie downer, but this is serious stuff we're discussing.
This is why I refrain from posting advice in these threads completely. There is not a universal solution in finance.
+
++
----
OK, I just cancelled those dudes out. Fire away willy-nilly, you wannabe Suze Orman types.