UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
Transmogrified Tiger
Puppy Murderer
Posts: 9323
Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
Location: Across the River

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Transmogrified Tiger »

So the implication is that interesting threads are started, but people don't respond to them because of who started them? And that favored posters get repeated discussion on topics that are not as worthwhile because of their place in the "pecking order"? I can't even read that without feeling ridiculous, never mind actually do something like that.

User avatar
themiddle54
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4524
Joined: August 24 10, 2:49 pm

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by themiddle54 »

haltz wrote:Saying that looking at pictures of beautiful women is objectifying is hyper-PC nonsense.
(sighs)

As per norm, haltz, you've missed my point and cherry-picked one thing to hyperbolically pick at. You must have me confused with some pro-womyn mid-90s campus type. Sorry to say I'm not that guy.

Saying that looking at pics of beautiful women, and posting pics on these pages and saying "I'd [expletive] her, wouldn't you? Doesn't she have great [expletive]?" are the same thing is not something I agree with. The latter veers into the territory of objectifying women and misogyny. And that's one of many things I could point out in this forum that are less than the respectful discourse Michael has discussed as being his goal, but it's the one I chose because it's the first that came to mind. It's a thread in which less-than-gentlemanly behavior seems not just tolerated but endorsed, since there are mods who participate in that thread. We could just as easily talk about the "Hey can you somehow sneak pics of the hot blonde intern in your office and post them so we can see how hot she is and compare her physical attributes to another pic we posted here and all talk anonymously over the internet about whether or not we'd [expletive] her or a German beer girl?" thread, which I also brought up but no one seems very interested in defending the merits of because, I'd assume, we're collectively smarter than that and understand how abhorrent that thread is. Neither that thread or the babes thread meets the goal of being civil and respectful that Michael has said is his wish, so if ICE should go, that whole babes thread should be wiped out, and the one about the intern should be wiped out, and an awful lot of less-than-respectful individual posts should be wiped out.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by lukethedrifter »

go birds is right that there is a pecking order, of sorts. It's just human nature. But it's going to have a lot more to do with how many interesting, funny or poignant threads and posts someone has made rather than whether they're in the IN crowd. If your threads aren't flying here, maybe it's because they just aren't that interesting to this particular crowd.

Michael
GRB Founder
Posts: 35304
Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
Location: Chicago, IL
Contact:

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Michael »

Sorry for being away from the party folks. I've been spending time with my family during this glorious holiday weekend.

Anyway, back to business...
themiddle54 wrote:
haltz wrote:Saying that looking at pictures of beautiful women is objectifying is hyper-PC nonsense.
(sighs)

As per norm, haltz, you've missed my point and cherry-picked one thing to hyperbolically pick at.
middle I'm going to have to pick on you.

I think everyone pay attention to this part of the reply right here. This is exactly the type of stuff I'm going to start monitoring right here. I don't want to see posts with this type of tone anymore. End of story.
You must have me confused with some pro-womyn mid-90s campus type. Sorry to say I'm not that guy.

Saying that looking at pics of beautiful women, and posting pics on these pages and saying "I'd [expletive] her, wouldn't you? Doesn't she have great [expletive]?" are the same thing is not something I agree with. The latter veers into the territory of objectifying women and misogyny. And that's one of many things I could point out in this forum that are less than the respectful discourse Michael has discussed as being his goal, but it's the one I chose because it's the first that came to mind. It's a thread in which less-than-gentlemanly behavior seems not just tolerated but endorsed, since there are mods who participate in that thread. We could just as easily talk about the "Hey can you somehow sneak pics of the hot blonde intern in your office and post them so we can see how hot she is and compare her physical attributes to another pic we posted here and all talk anonymously over the internet about whether or not we'd [expletive] her or a German beer girl?" thread, which I also brought up but no one seems very interested in defending the merits of because, I'd assume, we're collectively smarter than that and understand how abhorrent that thread is. Neither that thread or the babes thread meets the goal of being civil and respectful that Michael has said is his wish, so if ICE should go, that whole babes thread should be wiped out, and the one about the intern should be wiped out, and an awful lot of less-than-respectful individual posts should be wiped out.

It seems some posters (again, I hate to pick on you middle) want to turn ICE's banning in to more than it is. That banning was purely because he had the inability to communicate with all posters in a respectful manner (particularly in BT, our most important forum). This isn't "stat vs scouts" or "gentlemen vs Leroy". As greenback noted earlier ICE's issue was about discussion. Respectful discussion is my primary focus here.

That said, I do agree there has been an increased about of misogyny in GRB, and as mods we have curbed some of it and we will continue to monitor it. I do appreciate that feedback. Regarding the babes thread, to be honest I rarely go in it, so I can't comment many specifics. I will say that I don't think simply posting and viewing maxim magazine style photos means you hate woman or you are not a gentleman. Furthermore, outside of that thread I do try and curb that type of posting. I know many can attest that I've deleted avatars, sigs and photos in threads because I don't want GRB to descend in to a complete NSFW cesspool. IMO it's all about context. Personally I hate it when there is a good baseball discussion in BT and someone drops a NSFW photo. It simply doesn't belong there and it annoys people who are posting at work. On the other hand a "hot or not" poll it makes more sense because it's expected.


As for the temp banning idea, I do think it is a conversation worth having, however I have never seen it implemented successfully on another forum. My primary influence is NSBB and I never saw great results (although they do moderate slightly differently). Besides, as thrill noted, these are adults who know the rules. I can confirm I gave ICE and final warning yet his behavior continued (snyake didn't get one, but that's a whole 'nother story). He knew better but he had the inability to control himself. Personally I don't see how temporally bans will teach someone restraint, but we're open to changing our policy.

Finally, I want to address the concept of "baiting". Although "baiting" is not acceptable behavior, neither is replying to baiting with snark. If you feel like you're being baited, PM a mod. Taking out your frustrations in the forums is unacceptable and in my eyes makes you just as bad as the person who baited you.

Again, I appreciate everyone's feedback and I apologize that I haven't responded to everyone directly. I hope this discussion continues.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by cpebbles »

I'm curious how wanting to [expletive] a woman is construed as misogyny. Then again, we might be really, really repulsive.

Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10952
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Spider John »

I've always been impressed with intelligence level of this forum. We have doctors, lawyers, engineers, college professors, accountants and other professionals, college students and just regular people who participate. I think 99% of us here know what we post is inappropriate at the time we type it. If we cross the line, we know it. We shouldn't need a warning. We just need to show some self control.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Richie Allen »

themiddle54 wrote:
haltz wrote:Saying that looking at pictures of beautiful women is objectifying is hyper-PC nonsense.
(sighs)

As per norm, haltz, you've missed my point and cherry-picked one thing to hyperbolically pick at. You must have me confused with some pro-womyn mid-90s campus type. Sorry to say I'm not that guy.

Saying that looking at pics of beautiful women, and posting pics on these pages and saying "I'd [expletive] her, wouldn't you? Doesn't she have great [expletive]?" are the same thing is not something I agree with. The latter veers into the territory of objectifying women and misogyny. And that's one of many things I could point out in this forum that are less than the respectful discourse Michael has discussed as being his goal, but it's the one I chose because it's the first that came to mind. It's a thread in which less-than-gentlemanly behavior seems not just tolerated but endorsed, since there are mods who participate in that thread. We could just as easily talk about the "Hey can you somehow sneak pics of the hot blonde intern in your office and post them so we can see how hot she is and compare her physical attributes to another pic we posted here and all talk anonymously over the internet about whether or not we'd [expletive] her or a German beer girl?" thread, which I also brought up but no one seems very interested in defending the merits of because, I'd assume, we're collectively smarter than that and understand how abhorrent that thread is. Neither that thread or the babes thread meets the goal of being civil and respectful that Michael has said is his wish, so if ICE should go, that whole babes thread should be wiped out, and the one about the intern should be wiped out, and an awful lot of less-than-respectful individual posts should be wiped out.
This seems more like an argument that if ICE goes, other stuff should go along with him. Do you really even want the chick post to go away or are you simply trying to make a point? Comes across to me like you're just out to piss all over other people's fun while you have absolutely nothing to gain. Pick your battles.

maddash
is eerily well-versed on Project Runway and irony
Posts: 8508
Joined: June 26 06, 3:07 pm

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by maddash »

I don't think a suspension is really about teaching as much as it is about forcing someone to cool down. Thrill himself, as well as others, have noted the benefits of an extended break. And isn't having to repeatedly PM and then ban a poster already more moderation than you should really have to do for an adult? I'm not sure how a suspension is that much more hand holding than what you're already doing. But that's just my opinion, of course.

Online
User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by ghostrunner »

themiddle54 wrote: Saying that looking at pics of beautiful women, and posting pics on these pages and saying "I'd [expletive] her, wouldn't you? Doesn't she have great [expletive]?" are the same thing is not something I agree with. The latter veers into the territory of objectifying women and misogyny. And that's one of many things I could point out in this forum that are less than the respectful discourse Michael has discussed as being his goal, but it's the one I chose because it's the first that came to mind. It's a thread in which less-than-gentlemanly behavior seems not just tolerated but endorsed, since there are mods who participate in that thread. We could just as easily talk about the "Hey can you somehow sneak pics of the hot blonde intern in your office and post them so we can see how hot she is and compare her physical attributes to another pic we posted here and all talk anonymously over the internet about whether or not we'd [expletive] her or a German beer girl?" thread, which I also brought up but no one seems very interested in defending the merits of because, I'd assume, we're collectively smarter than that and understand how abhorrent that thread is. Neither that thread or the babes thread meets the goal of being civil and respectful that Michael has said is his wish, so if ICE should go, that whole babes thread should be wiped out, and the one about the intern should be wiped out, and an awful lot of less-than-respectful individual posts should be wiped out.
The intern thread was pulled about 5 days after it was posted.

I think a lot of people are going to disagree with you about the babes thread. There's a lot of hyperbole and locker room talk in that thread, but are you saying "I'd hit it" is a misogynist statement? I suppose that's debatable, and the debate is certainly welcome. I's not exactly the zenith of human intellect, but I don't think it's hateful or disrespectful either. If the thread starts reading like Tiger Woods' text messages, that's a different story. The Casey Anthony thread veered in that direction and I believe some things were removed or deleted there. If not they probably shouldn't have been.

And again, you seem to be advocating a zero-tolerance policy (if x goes, y goes), which isn't how things are moderated here. If 50% (just pulling that out of my head) of the babes thread was misogynist, I'd say kill it. I don't think that's the case. For the most part, it seems okay to me. As Michael alluded to, a lot of stuff just gets missed, which is where reporting comes in. I've contributed to that thread, but I don't go in there much either. I actually have images turned off in my settings, so I can't see a lot of it unless I deliberately open each one. As far as users being banned, that's typically only going to happen after repeated warnings and PMs. I think it's fair to say things have to get to a certain level. None of us mods has the time or the desire to play whack-a-mole all the time.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by lukethedrifter »

Not that it would have made much difference- or maybe it would have- but I wish I had told ICE to chill the [expletive] out because I'm going to miss the bastard.

Post Reply