I used to post like a fiend. Was a mod here for years. Can't do it anymore because of time constraints and other responsibilities. Would love to see more people posting, but even that doesn't affect me much. Outside of a few threads that catch my attention everything else passes me by.
If you want more conversation and more topics, start some! Or invite other people over. This is a forum of members who provide 100% of the content.
There's a bit of a pecking order here that makes this option pretty unrealistic.
I've noticed lots of topics go by the wayside if they aren't started by one of the ole veterans. I think alot of people here have the jim mentality in that if they don't like a poster they just skip over their posts/topics.
And that's fine, but mods here can't complain about the lack of substance or interest in the board when that type of thing runs rampant.
I think that's why you don't see a lot of new posters--it's because a lot of people here have the same mentality as ICE, only not quite as abrasive.
It's all whatever though. In the end, it's just a message board. People shouldn't take things that seriously.
Number of examples where TheMiddle gave some form of validity to GRB posters opinions:
...
I agree w/ Michael that the board should be civil and gentlemanly.
I agree w/ you, Theo, that there are a lot more people giving validity to what I'm saying that I'm giving validity to what they're saying. Mostly because I think the defense of the big boobie thread is silly. And the idea that a double-standard does not exist w/r/t acceptable behavior/what's offensive or inappropriate is equally silly. The idea that there are two sets of rules, one for Social and one for BT, also strikes me as silly. How do you say, hey, over here it's ok to objectify women, it's ok to talk about drunken sex with your brother's girlfriend or whatever, but hey, over here, in BT, we insist on civility?
I don't understand the argument. Topics aren't civil or uncivil. With rare exceptions, I don't think any topic is going to be off limits. How they're discussed is the issue here. There are some comments in the babes thread and in other threads that I have thought crossed the line. And it's possible some of those got warnings. Or some may have been missed. Or they may not have been changed at all after the person was warned. Sometimes threads get locked, moved or deleted. Sometimes we might just comment in an effort to steer the conversation in a better direction. Same goes for individual posts. There's a variety of ways mods can approach something. Steel doors are not going to drop down at the slightest hint of rudeness or incivility.
Point is - it's not like some things are being moderated and other offenses are being ignored. As has been said, this is a situation that built up over time, where repeated warnings weren't taken seriously.
ghostrunner wrote:Point is - it's not like some things are being moderated and other offenses are being ignored. As has been said, this is a situation that built up over time, where repeated warnings weren't taken seriously.
no offense to anyone, but why would they be? Two years and 20,000 posts where the worst thing that happened was a PM lecture or a deleted post and threats that likely seemed idle. This is why punishments escalate and you get detained, suspended and expelled in that order. Maybe if ICE or Snayke had gotten suspended a couple of times (if they did I apologize) they would've taken it a bit more seriously instead of it building to a head where these steps were necessary. You see it on other boards all the time.
edit - I guess what I mean is with this system I could see these guys feeling like they were sort of untouchable save for a slap on the wrist and the mods being lenient for so long that at some point they are completely fed up when it seems like these guys are giving them the finger (and they are even though they might not know it) over and over again. I dunno, I'm repeating myself and rambling and it's only a suggestion, but before someone gets permabanned, having them sit out for a week a couple of times might get the point across and also the mods might not feel like they are just spinning their wheels. We're all adults (except for PJ) so this really shouldn't be necessary but it works really well at other places.
Last edited by haltz on September 3 11, 2:52 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I used to post like a fiend. Was a mod here for years. Can't do it anymore because of time constraints and other responsibilities. Would love to see more people posting, but even that doesn't affect me much. Outside of a few threads that catch my attention everything else passes me by.
If you want more conversation and more topics, start some! Or invite other people over. This is a forum of members who provide 100% of the content.
There's a bit of a pecking order here that makes this option pretty unrealistic.
I've noticed lots of topics go by the wayside if they aren't started by one of the ole veterans. I think alot of people here have the jim mentality in that if they don't like a poster they just skip over their posts/topics.
And that's fine, but mods here can't complain about the lack of substance or interest in the board when that type of thing runs rampant.
I think that's why you don't see a lot of new posters--it's because a lot of people here have the same mentality as ICE, only not quite as abrasive.
It's all whatever though. In the end, it's just a message board. People shouldn't take things that seriously.
Very few posters are on my "skip over" list. And I doubt that even those on my skip over list I actually skip over on the initial thread. It's more like I've seen a thread and a few comments, see that persons name, and don't even have to read it to know what they said. There was a poster or two that when a thread talked about the MI, and you saw there name on a reply, you could almost recite their response before you read it. It was that predictable, that uninformative, and that un-funny.
Ignoring a post based on who did it is the exception, just wanted to make sure I got that point across.
To second haltz's suggestion, a few weeks away from the board gives people time to cool down and more importantly puts things into perspective. That can often correct a poster's style enough to prevent future problems. Maybe a suspension - forcing someone to take that break - would be a good idea before a permaban.
Personally, I think that while yes, a line must be draw, we should also try to work with good posters so we don't lose them. Frankly, if the banning of Snyake didn't improve the BT situation, I'm not sure how ICE's will. Not saying he shouldn't have been punished, but as a means of prevention, I don't see it being effective.
haltz wrote: This is why punishments escalate and you get detained, suspended and expelled in that order..
I promise we are going to revisit this, but honestly, why should we have to hold an adult's hand to help them stay in line? Act like a grown up. We shouldn't have to bend over backwards to help a grown ass man control his immature urges. We clearly tell trouble posters what is expected of them and if they don't take us seriously we shouldn't have to help them do so.
haltz wrote: This is why punishments escalate and you get detained, suspended and expelled in that order..
I promise we are going to revisit this, but honestly, why should we have to hold an adult's hand to help them stay in line? Act like a grown up. We shouldn't have to bend over backwards to help a grown ass man control his immature urges. We clearly tell trouble posters what is expected of them and if they don't take us seriously we shouldn't have to help them do so.
Not going to make any difference thrill. You say stop and they don't stop. You say stop or I will tell you to stop again and they don't stop. Then you say stop or I will tell you that if you don't stop there might be consequences and they don't stop. Then you say stop or there will be consequences and they still don't stop. Then you say stop or you promise there will be consequences and they don't stop. And then you say stop or I will ban you and they don't stop. And they you say stop or I will ban you and I really mean it this time and they don't stop.
Then they get banned.
What's the difference between that and some graduated punishment thing?
Snayke got banned like two and a half years ago. In internet forum years, that's like a decade. Since then, I think boyer got banned. Oh, the Indiana sports kid got banned too. There might be some more I'm forgetting, but I'm drawing a blank right now.
Where are these rampant bannings taking place? Not here. They're rare here. So maybe that says something is working, but I guess some system where people get put in timeout like a 3-year old is worth considering. I dunno.