UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
- slide_into_first
- is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
- Posts: 14433
- Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
- Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
If there is a misconception about the Babes Thread, I would like to clear it up. It is not intended to be misogynistic. The younger men post pictures of lingerie models and actresses who represent their concept of perfect beauty, while the older men counter with women who are not perfect but nevertheless beautiful. It is part of a mentoring process which the older ones take seriously. I'm not kidding. No one believes a woman can be judged solely by her appearance.
- themiddle54
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 4524
- Joined: August 24 10, 2:49 pm
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
Not to be one of those message board jerks who insist on objective evidence outweighing gray area and stuff, but that whole thread is "Look at the X on Y"slide_into_first wrote:If there is a misconception about the Babes Thread, I would like to clear it up. It is not intended to be misogynistic. The younger men post pictures of lingerie models and actresses who represent their concept of perfect beauty, while the older men counter with women who are not perfect but nevertheless beautiful. It is part of a mentoring process which the older ones take seriously. I'm not kidding. No one believes a woman can be judged solely by her appearance.
- slide_into_first
- is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
- Posts: 14433
- Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
- Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
It may be that for you, but not for others.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
Great points popeye.Popeye_Card wrote:I will keep my thoughts on this matter simple.
On one hand, this feels pretty heavy-handed.
On the other hand, I know of many quality posters who have left this board or stopped doing much posting in BT because of the atmosphere in there, and to say that ICE was not a huge factor in that would be kidding themselves.
Let's also not get carried away with how many baseball facts he brought to the table. While a lot of us here like advanced metrics, they are by no means facts as to a player's value and potential. They are approximations, stated in numbers with far more decimal points than they deserve. CardsNumbers said it well--too often he dealt with black and white, and if you didn't like his side, well then you're stupid and wrong. So much of baseball is gray, and that is where the good discussion lies, IMO.
-
planet planet
- http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
- Posts: 24904
- Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
Unfortunately, he's one of the guys we sorely miss IMO.jim wrote:Great points popeye.Popeye_Card wrote:I will keep my thoughts on this matter simple.
On one hand, this feels pretty heavy-handed.
On the other hand, I know of many quality posters who have left this board or stopped doing much posting in BT because of the atmosphere in there, and to say that ICE was not a huge factor in that would be kidding themselves.
Let's also not get carried away with how many baseball facts he brought to the table. While a lot of us here like advanced metrics, they are by no means facts as to a player's value and potential. They are approximations, stated in numbers with far more decimal points than they deserve. CardsNumbers said it well--too often he dealt with black and white, and if you didn't like his side, well then you're stupid and wrong. So much of baseball is gray, and that is where the good discussion lies, IMO.
- stlouie_lipp
- Hallelujah Brother
- Posts: 13380
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
maybe he'll post more now? (i hope)planet pujolsian wrote:Unfortunately, he's one of the guys we sorely miss IMO.jim wrote:Great points popeye.Popeye_Card wrote:I will keep my thoughts on this matter simple.
On one hand, this feels pretty heavy-handed.
On the other hand, I know of many quality posters who have left this board or stopped doing much posting in BT because of the atmosphere in there, and to say that ICE was not a huge factor in that would be kidding themselves.
Let's also not get carried away with how many baseball facts he brought to the table. While a lot of us here like advanced metrics, they are by no means facts as to a player's value and potential. They are approximations, stated in numbers with far more decimal points than they deserve. CardsNumbers said it well--too often he dealt with black and white, and if you didn't like his side, well then you're stupid and wrong. So much of baseball is gray, and that is where the good discussion lies, IMO.
I didn't start this thread to be a referendum on the banning of ICE. I started it to give a shoutout to the mods who are in a tough position. For the most part, the members on this board police themselves. But, at the same time, there are pressures on the mods that they can't ignore - like making the decision to ban ICE.
Like many on here I enjoyed reading his baseball posts - slanted as there were, but generally had fun reading his posts. He was funny at times, annoying at times and offensive at times. The mods had to make a hard decision, and I respect them for that. I also think that we all need to remember that this is an internet forum and shouldn't let the banning of a poster get our collective panties in a bunch.
-
Spider John
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 10952
- Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
- Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
If the folks responsible for the board ask you time and time again to straighten up your act and you just ignore them,then you ought to get banned. It's disrespectful.
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11781
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois
Re: Rave: Mods
This thread has been an interesting study in philosophy, IMO. Different topics interconnected. It's almost like an audit or annual review taking place. Probably not a bad idea. But I'd like to expound upon the statements above.Lesson wrote:I think that's a problem that tends to be overlooked, IMO.TheoSqua wrote:A lot of the posters I used to log-in to read aren't posting often anymore, and the new posters that replace them aren't coming in as quickly.
My guess is, when this place first started, the majority of the members were single males under the age of 30. Looking at that demographically, you had a lot of people who had a decent amount of free time on their hands. They were lower on the totem pole at their jobs, so they could steal an hour (or more) away to post during the day.
But, as the majority aged and did things like get married, get a pet(s), have children, have increased job responsibilities, possibly own (and maintain) a home, etc., their free time started to dry up. They couldn't post as often. They matured as people and also learned more about the game, so their intelligence was/is sought after, but their posts became sporadic.
New blood comes in, as people either get their own computers (high school, college students) or leave other message boards for greener pastures or whatever reason it was that drove them here. They're probably youthful, so they're a little less mature than some of the "veterans" of the board, but they have both passion and free time. Hence, the cycle starts anew.
I fit right into this demo. When I was asked to come over here from CT (an invitation I am still thankful for), I didn't have children, tons of job responsibilities, Keith Law threatening lawsuits, etc. I thoroughly enjoyed both my daily time here, and even the significant effort of producing the "NL Central comments". But my free time has dried up. I don't have the time to be the poster I was 4-5 years ago. It would be nice if I could, but it's just not realistic.
Where am I going with all this? Well, I just wanted to point out the cycle of board members. I'm sure most boards face the same thing. The key, for me, is I still view this as a place to talk with other intelligent baseball fans. It's a place where I can get a laugh once in a while, too.
I'm not here enough to know why this member or that member got banned. I don't really care. It's not that I don't care about the person. It's that it's none of my business what they did to get banned. That's on them and has nothing to do with me. (Truthfully, I think Michael banned ICE because his post total was being threatened.)
I'll wrap up with this: The one thing everyone should keep in mind, and I think this speaks to what thrill and others have alluded to, is that (other than Michael) this place does not revolve around any one of us. It will go on, whether you participate or not. Don't interpret that as "you're worthless". Rather, enjoy it for whatever it provides you. If it's not giving that enjoyment to you, take a step back for a little while. Then come on back, and more than likely you'll find it again. There's too much good here to punt forever.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21912
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
Popeye_Card wrote:I will keep my thoughts on this matter simple.
On one hand, this feels pretty heavy-handed.
On the other hand, I know of many quality posters who have left this board or stopped doing much posting in BT because of the atmosphere in there, and to say that ICE was not a huge factor in that would be kidding themselves.
Let's also not get carried away with how many baseball facts he brought to the table. While a lot of us here like advanced metrics, they are by no means facts as to a player's value and potential. They are approximations, stated in numbers with far more decimal points than they deserve. CardsNumbers said it well--too often he dealt with black and white, and if you didn't like his side, well then you're stupid and wrong. So much of baseball is gray, and that is where the good discussion lies, IMO.
Yeah, I don't really get the "he brought the facts" thing. It's not like Fangraphs or Baseball Reference aren't used by all of us......... or at least most of us. The "facts" are the easy part. It's the other stuff that ICE tended to get uptight about........ because much of the mental aspect of the game is pretty arbitrary, and that makes some folks uncomfortable.
- Maclowery
- Child Pot Activist
- Posts: 7742
- Joined: June 15 06, 7:27 am
- Location: NYC
Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods
I'll tell you what threads really grind my gears here. First off, there's a 2400 post long thread just talking about money. Oh sure, it's all 'complex' and 'well-researched' and 'polite', but where are the jugs? Second, all these threads with random funny pictures and movies. Who needs it? A social forum on a baseball site should be about one thing only: More baseball statistical discussion. Maybe some jugs, also. I won't even begin to complain about the beer thread, movie thread, music thread, TV thread, and hiking thread, all of which have very-irritatingly helped me find new things I like. For shame. I think about two things: Jugs and baseball. Next thing you know, you're going to see expert-written threads explaining nuclear reactors and particle accelerators. Ridiculous.themiddle54 wrote:Not to be one of those message board jerks who insist on objective evidence outweighing gray area and stuff, but that whole thread is "Look at the X on Y"slide_into_first wrote:If there is a misconception about the Babes Thread, I would like to clear it up. It is not intended to be misogynistic. The younger men post pictures of lingerie models and actresses who represent their concept of perfect beauty, while the older men counter with women who are not perfect but nevertheless beautiful. It is part of a mentoring process which the older ones take seriously. I'm not kidding. No one believes a woman can be judged solely by her appearance.



