TheoSqua wrote:I looked at Baseball Talk and couldn't find a single interesting baseball discussion thread that's been contributed to in the last 2-3 days.
Unrelated response: I think people are just ready for winter and things slow down here till the Winter Meetings and ST.
While I understand the decision and Michael's point about snark and attitude being the culture and wanting to change that, I hope we don't over-correct. Condescension can be annoying and adds little if anything but some have mentioned warnings they felt were...undeserved. I'm sure sometimes it's a misunderstanding about unintentional wording that is misconstrued and it happens. No big deal. I just don't want things to become to stuffy and formal.
vinsanity wrote:While I understand the decision and Michael's point about snark and attitude being the culture and wanting to change that, I hope we don't over-correct. Condescension can be annoying and adds little if anything but some have mentioned warnings they felt were...undeserved. I'm sure sometimes it's a misunderstanding about unintentional wording that is misconstrued and it happens. No big deal. I just don't want things to become to stuffy and formal.
I'm glad you mentioned this.
I do want to be clear, I don't plan to overreact. I understand no one is prefect (including myself) and things can be misconstrued. As mods we really try to work with posters and that will continue. That said, once it's clear a persons behavior isn't going to change, I will take action.
Being honest, I knew ICE wasn't going to change despite working with him for literally for years but I let it slide for too long. That was my mistake.
Moderating is a tough job. Decisions are rarely black & white. Large decisions such as this are never easy...but at the end of the day, I trust that the mods made this decision for the betterment of GWRB for now and for the future.
TheoSqua wrote:I respect the opinion of posters that prefer more traditional means of taking in a season, but if that's all I cared about I'd be at CT and reading Jeff Gordon columns. What made GRB special in the past is the friendly interactions between different viewpoints and watching those conversations unfold. I don't want all negative attitudes and arguments over opinions and not facts, but I also don't want to see GRB without some of my favorite posters who just aren't posting as much as they used to.
What to do what to do.
I would argue we've been losing/not attracting great posters because of the nastiness. Because of a few posters too many threads descend in to a bickering condescending mess. They would just carpet bomb threads with an endless pissing match.
Honestly, if you were a prospective member and you looked at some of our threads would you bother?
I think letting certain posters with horrible attitudes stick around was a mistake. I'm not making that mistake again.
I know I can get flippant at times...but I think what Michael is saying is why I've taken several "breaks" from GRB (or at least BT) in the last 6 months.
Personally, I liked ICE when he wasn't trying to prove how right he was. I loved his insight when he wasn't cherry picking it. Flashchat with ICE was a freaking blast. But I definitely understand and see the point behind the decision.
I would argue we've been losing/not attracting great posters because of the nastiness. Because of a few posters, too many threads descend in to a bickering condescending mess. They would just carpet bomb threads with an endless pissing match.
Honestly, if you were a prospective member and you looked at some of our threads would you bother?
I think letting certain posters with horrible attitudes stick around was a mistake. I'm not making that mistake again.
Not that anyone cares, this is one reason why I am posting/lurking less at GRB. And I am sure there are few folks who thinks the same.
Michael, your explanation post was spot on. Thank you!