Slider wrote:I am back from the dead so to speak...never was banned before, nor even warned of being banned...still didn't have as many post as he did, but I am part of the original group that got invited over from CT.
Well, the original group that was invited over was from 2006... you may have been the second exodus. This isn't really germane to my point though. I will reiterate that I am not trying to undermine your importance here, in fact, I was shocked you had less than 1k posts. I am saying that someone with a few hundred posts being told to back off is not the same as someone with a significant presence on the board.
YES, YES... NECESSARY CAVEAT: Mods sent several warnings, ICE did not change, etc. etc..
I was invited over in 2006, I had a different name, I have been here since '06. Personally I would say that I am not an "important" person on the board and personally that is where I like to be. I think the very fact he had so many post in such a short time says plenty about the problem. For instance, I can be snarky at times...but snarky over 1,000 post in 3 years is not so bad...snarky over 20,000 post in 4 years is a bit excessive.
cardsfansince82 wrote:In summary, ICE got banned because one or two people didn't get his sense of humor or don't understand the concept of breaking each other's balls. Everyone else liked him. Yet there are posters that no one likes that get to stay despite doing everything they can to ruin any thread they post in because it's not aimed at any particular person.
This isn't true at all. I appreciated his knowledge and viewpoints, but really took exception with his overall tone. It was bad enough that I basically ignored him, so the good points never got across to me for that reason.
Isn't that the point though? If you don't like someone's posts, it's incredibly easy to just not read their posts. There are several posters that when I see their name on a post, I just move right along because of the quality or tone of their posts. It's easy to skim the content and go about your business on the board. We have strict filters on this board regarding language and images; superficial offenses are hard to find outside of FB's posts. I'm more bothered by the latent racism, misogyny, classism, religious intolerance, and personal attacks that show up ALL THE TIME on this board than I am by the abrasive rhetoric used in baseball arguments.
With that said, this board is still incredibly well behaved. There's a reason I am still on it 5+ years later, and I've posted about 60% of my content in the last 2 years, so clearly I am not questioning my moral compass over board behavior... but I will really miss ICE's baseball insight and I think the board just became substantially less informed because of it. I didn't always agree with him, but he always backed up his arguments with research rather than anecdotal [expletive]. Caustic? Yes. Flippant? Of course. So what? I've always thought of this board as the equivalent of hanging out at the bar with the guys (ladies of the board included) arguing sports and shooting the [expletive]. What do you think we should do this offseason, what the [expletive] is LaRussa doing, and did you end up with that girl last night?
Last edited by JackofDiamonds on September 2 11, 1:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.
JackofDiamonds wrote:With that said, this board is still incredibly well behaved. There's a reason I am still on it 5+ years later, and I've posted about 60% of my content in the last 2 years, so clearly I am not questioning my moral compass over board behavior... but I will really miss ICE's baseball insight and I think the board just became substantially less informed because of it. I didn't always agree with him, but he always backed up his arguments with research rather than anecdotal [expletive]. Caustic? Yes. Flippant? Of course. So what? I've always thought of this board as the equivalent of hanging out at the bar with the guys (ladies of the board included) arguing sports and shooting the [expletive]. What do you think we should do this offseason, what the [expletive] is LaRussa doing, and did you end up with that girl last night?
I have to agree with this.
However, it's hard to judge when we don't know all of the circumstances. Having been a moderator elsewhere, sometimes you have to draw a line in the sand, even with valuable members of the board.