The U is in serious trouble, or Phins vs. The World

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10952
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by Spider John »

Before all of this broke I read about how the death penalty for SMU set them back for many more years than was expected, and because of that it was unlikely to happen again. I guess we may see.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Allen was part of the Miami staff.
Wait is it illegal for staff members to take presents/money from boosters?

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by phins »

robbotis wrote:
phins wrote:If you think I'm in denial over anything, you haven't been reading. I've been saying wait for everything to come out, including facts.

There has been absolutely zero proof to show he was paying for most of the things he alleges. Having a receipt for something doesn't show you bought it for a Miami player etc.

On the flip side, it seems like he has proof of a bunch of smaller violations.

As for the NCAA, they haven't said word one about what they believe and don't believe, so anything you're reading regarding that is purely speculation. Lest we forget, media outlets write stories for hits and clicks, writing a story that says, "Wait for something to come out, I don't have an opinion of hearsay," is not going to clicks like "Miami should get the death penalty," will.
What proof are you looking for?
There's photos of players on his yacht, in private rooms at clubs, corraborating reports from several players.
I'm not sure what more proof there is.
The photos on the boat are said to be while the players were pro's. He has to prove they weren't pro's. I imagine he'll be able to for some. Minor violation if he can.

Guys, you think photos at a club really prove anything? You know how many photos these guys take while they're out, parties they go to, clubs they go to, friends they go to events with? I imagine we all have photos with some athlete or other. Photos out at a club certainly do not prove a single thing other than they were both in the same place at the same time. It is not illegal for these players to be out at a club if they're of age. It's illegal if they took benefits.

Prove that he paid them money. Prove it. Prove that he paid for their drinks specifically. Prove it. Prove that he was financing some large ring like he says.

And, oh yeah, where are the corrobarating stories? None of the players who have graduated will say a word. Yahoo says they have players corrobaration, but none on the record except for Moss, who has recanted (and looks bad now).

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by phins »

Transmogrified Tiger wrote:
robbotis wrote:What proof are you looking for?
There's photos of players on his yacht, in private rooms at clubs, corraborating reports from several players.
I'm not sure what more proof there is.
For real. Maybe I got back-paged before, but this is all stuff that corroborates Shapiro and directly implicates the coaching staff.
• Yahoo! Sports has acquired a photo of Allen in Shapiro’s luxury box during the 2009 season, with then-recruit Jeffrey Godfrey standing in the background.

• Yahoo! Sports has acquired a balance sheet from Shapiro’s bankruptcy, showing $92,300 in recorded transactions from Shapiro to Allen between April 2008 and January 2009. Yahoo! Sports also acquired $55,800 in canceled checks signed by Allen for some of the aforementioned transactions.

• A LinkedIn business profile belonging to Allen shows he worked for three sports agencies that survived in various forms – Axcess Sports (with Shapiro), Luke Sports & Entertainment (with recording artist and avid Hurricanes fan Luther Campbell), and The Players Agency (also with Shapiro).

• Yahoo! Sports acquired a canceled $2,500 check to corroborate Shapiro’s claim of giving Hurtt an interest-free loan. The check, which includes a signature on the back, is dated July 31, 2009.

• One source corroborated Shapiro having paid for bills for Hurtt and a large group of athletes at Café Grazie on two occasions. The source said that on each occasion, Shapiro called the restaurant and made the owners aware that Hurtt would be bringing a large group in for a meal, with explicit instructions that the bills be charged to the booster’s American Express black card.

• Two sources present at Patchan’s alleged visit to Shapiro’s home corroborated the presence of the recruit and his family, as well as the presence of two Miami assistants and multiple Miami players.

• One source corroborated Shapiro’s account of Hill and Clint Hurtt being present when the booster had impermissible recruiting contact at his mansion with Andre Debose, Ray-Ray Armstrong and Dyron Dye.

• Three sources present at Patchan’s alleged visit to Shapiro’s home confirmed the presence of the recruit and his family, as well as Pannunzio, Stoutland and multiple Miami players.
First one, not a violation. Players meet boosters on recruiting visits all the time.

Second one, Allen did not work for Miami during that time frame.

Third one, Allen did not work for Miami during that time frame.

Fourth one, I believe is legit. Hurtt paid the loan back, but the interest free part is a violation. I don't know how the interest free part is proven, unless a cancelled check for $2,500 is your proof. Hurtt hasn't come out and said anything, so I don't know if he will say other payments were made or not (to constitute interest).

Fifth one, what source? You see this in the media a lot. The source matters, and what exactly they can attest to and how they'd know, matters.

Sixth one, is a violation. Patchan didn't go to Miami by the way.

Seventh one, DeBose has been cleared, and proven he wasn't there. If DeBose wasn't there, the whole thing is a lie. Even if that didn't already come out, what's the impermissable contact? That matters.

Eighth one, hasn't the Patchan allegation already been made? Must not have been too much going on there. Patchan, a legacy Cane, did not even go to Miami.

Two things on the list are violations. One was a loan that was paid back, but allegedly without interest. Allen, I say again, is not alleged to have done one thing while he was employed by Miami in this entire report. The dates were all while Allen was not employed by Miami. Some proof there. Any player that went to his agency signed with another agency first, except for one player. That player is not allged to have received benefits in the Yahoo! story.

What exactly does that list constitute? Certainly not LOIC. At least not in my eyes. It looks like some impermissable parties and TWO dinners, with an unnamed source. Whoa. Earth shattering stuff.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by phins »

Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Allen was part of the Miami staff.
No he wasn't.
Allen was a student manager for the Hurricanes from 2001 to 2005. From 2005 to 2007, he worked for sports agency ventures for both Nevin Shapiro (Axcess Sports for nine months) and Luther Campbell (Luke Sports & Entertainment for 14 months). After 16 months in the private sector, Allen again returned to work for Shapiro for six months as a consultant on a potential sports representation firm called “The Players Agency.” He returned to Miami in August 2009, and has been on staff as an assistant equipment manager since that date.
Notice how those dates fall outside of these?
Yahoo! Sports has acquired a balance sheet from Shapiro’s bankruptcy, showing $92,300 in recorded transactions from Shapiro to Allen between April 2008 and January 2009. Yahoo! Sports also acquired $55,800 in canceled checks signed by Allen for some of the aforementioned transactions.

• A LinkedIn business profile belonging to Allen shows he worked for three sports agencies that survived in various forms – Axcess Sports (with Shapiro), Luke Sports & Entertainment (with recording artist and avid Hurricanes fan Luther Campbell), and The Players Agency (also with Shapiro).

•

User avatar
Transmogrified Tiger
Puppy Murderer
Posts: 9323
Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
Location: Across the River

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by Transmogrified Tiger »

If you're going to distance Allen's involvement with the Miami staff, then it pushes the eye towards the fact that Shapiro had heavy involvement in player representation agencies, which is probably even worse.

Also, players don't meet boosters in their luxury box at pro stadiums all the time. Never mind with former staff/employee of player representation agency present.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by phins »

Transmogrified Tiger wrote:If you're going to distance Allen's involvement with the Miami staff, then it pushes the eye towards the fact that Shapiro had heavy involvement in player representation agencies, which is probably even worse.

Also, players don't meet boosters in their luxury box at pro stadiums all the time. Never mind with former staff/employee of player representation agency present.
You're quite nimble on your feet. Are you already planning your next argument after your original is proven false?

Pro stadiums. Hilarious. You do understand the University of Miami plays their home games there, correct? And yes, recruits do mingle with boosters on visits all the time.

Shapiro was a silent investor in a player agency. That is already well established.

Godfrey was never offered a scholarship by Miami, and was on an unofficial visit, by the way. He never visited Miami officially.

Shapiro was scraping everything up he possibly could and seeing what stuck. Again, there are obviously some minor violations, but I'm waiting to see the true proof of major violations. I think suspensions are coming, and I think improprieties took place, but the vitriol being spewed by people in the media is for clicks.

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by cardsfansince82 »

phins wrote: And yes, recruits do mingle with boosters on visits all the time..
You can find this on any school's website with a simple google search, including Miami's. Here's a little refresher to remind you what constitutes violations. This is only a partial list.

From Arkansas' website:
NCAA Rules Regarding Student-Athletes

You May Not provide a student-athlete any benefits or special arrangements.

You May Not provide room and/or board or any type of transportation during the summer for a student-athlete with eligibility remaining.

You May Not provide room, board, or transportation costs incurred by friends or family of an enrolled student-athlete with eligibility remaining.

You May Not expend funds to entertain student-athletes, their friends or relatives. Things such as buying a soda or a cup of coffee for them could jeopardize their eligibility.

You May Not provide any payment of expense or loan of any automobile for a student-athlete for any reason.

You May Not provide awards or gifts directly to a student-athlete or his/her family or friends for his/her athletic performance. All awards financed by boosters must first be approved by the athletic department and meet NCAA award requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Who is a prospective student-athlete?

A prospect is any student who has entered the ninth grade. A student who has not started classes for the ninth grade becomes a prospect if the University of Arkansas provides that individual (or friends and relatives) any financial assistance or other benefits the University does not provide to prospects generally.

Q: Can a booster contact a prospect or their parents on or off campus?

Boosters cannot have any in-person recruiting contact with a prospect or the prospect's parents or legal guardian (s) or relatives on or off campus at any time.
I honestly stopped reading your rebuttal to TT's list after the first one when you said a booster having a recruit in his luxury suite is not a violation. And that list is hardly everything this guy has alleged. You want proof? I'm not sure you'll ever be satisfied in that department since we aren't going to know what the NCAA has been told behind closed doors and by whom. There isn't going to be a check made out to a hooker co-endorsed by Shapiro and Kellen Winslow. But Shapiro has provided a mountain of circumstantial evidence in addition to hard evidence like photos, receipts and the phone records that you've neglected to mention.

And it's pretty funny that you think no one in the media would be making money writing about supposed holes in this guy's story. Everyone is following this story and a lot of major media players have big money invested in college football so they have an incentive to downplay the whole thing if they could. Maybe sports writers hate money even more than they hate Miami? Everything I have read since the original story broke has painted a pretty bleak picture for the school and more or less corroborated what he said. What gets more "clicks"? Writing the same thing everyone else is, or being a lone dissenting voice? No one has come out and called him a liar. It's a lot of no comments and statements of disappointment. Perhaps you should prepare yourself for the inevitable.
Last edited by cardsfansince82 on August 23 11, 10:41 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
slide_into_first
is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
Posts: 14433
Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by slide_into_first »

Miami should be penalized for all the things you know happened when Jimmy Johnson was there. Also for Jimmy Johnson's hair.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by phins »

I'm saying that boosters talk to players all the time. Ex-players are considered boosters of the University, and if you think they don't talk to recruits you're crazy. Funny, you should mention Canesport, considering Rivals and Yahoo! have an affiliation.

I shouldn't have said not a violation, I should have said, not a violation that's actually enforced. At Missouri State (where I was actually recruited to play and so was my little brother), they have a place called Bearfest Village that has all these tents etc. set up for fans before the games. They have this one tent filled with ex-football and basketball players milling around. You meet and talk with these players. Guess what else you do? You take pictures with them!

Bryant McKinnie openly chatted with Seantrel Henderson before he committed to Miami. It was in the media etc. and not a peep about it from the NCAA, because it is normal.

You can stop reading whenever you want. That's your choice. You've already made up your mind on the case anyway.

Post Reply