Yeah, but the players aren't "supposed" to be getting anything more than scholarships out of the system. Universities are getting a TON out of the system, some players are getting a lot, too, but against the "rules".Socnorb11 wrote:Michael wrote:
If they opened up the process the athletes would get a scholarship and money. Obviously these universities want to stop that from happening. It honestly blows my mind when the press vilifies these players for accepting gifts. The system is unfair and broken. I say blow it up.
Why do you think the universities don't want the players to get money? It's happening right now, to a large degree, and the universities certainly aren't making much effort to prevent it.
I just disagree that the system is unfair. Currently, the universities and the players are both getting something out of the system.
The U is in serious trouble, or Phins vs. The World
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: The U is in serious trouble
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: The U is in serious trouble
That's the point, Mizzou is already playing minor league football, just not formally recognized.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Then you have to drop the association with the universities for their tax-exempt status. I love Mizzou football, but I couldn't care less about the Mid-Missouri Tigers playing less than NFL football against the West Texas Red Raiders.stlouie_lipp wrote:Minor League football with four divisions: SEC, Big10, PAC10 and Big12 or Big East or ACC?
Go ahead and drop the charade of "student athlete" for these big programs and remove any ties to academics.
If it is just the name changes that bother you, then don't change the names. The universities could "liscense" their name to these minor league teams! Cha-ching!
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21912
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: The U is in serious trouble
pioneer98 wrote:That's the point, Mizzou is already playing minor league football, just not formally recognized.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Then you have to drop the association with the universities for their tax-exempt status. I love Mizzou football, but I couldn't care less about the Mid-Missouri Tigers playing less than NFL football against the West Texas Red Raiders.stlouie_lipp wrote:Minor League football with four divisions: SEC, Big10, PAC10 and Big12 or Big East or ACC?
Go ahead and drop the charade of "student athlete" for these big programs and remove any ties to academics.
I disagree. Maybe I'm really naive, but I think the majority of student athletes are actually there for the scholarship/degree, and because they love the game. Why else would they be there? Most of them will never play at the next level, and most of them aren't good enough to be getting booster support.
- Transmogrified Tiger
- Puppy Murderer
- Posts: 9323
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
- Location: Across the River
Re: The U is in serious trouble
It's not simply name change, it's the complete separation from the university. Within a year or two, that team won't have any true association to anything that matters to me, or thousands of other people. Plus there's the issue of all the stadiums/facilities still being at the universities themselves, and the universities won't want to give up what is such a big driver for them in dollars and in enrollment. It's something that wouldn't "fix" things, would lead to a widespread decrease in interest, and would never happen in a million years anyway.pioneer98 wrote:That's the point, Mizzou is already playing minor league football, just not formally recognized.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Then you have to drop the association with the universities for their tax-exempt status. I love Mizzou football, but I couldn't care less about the Mid-Missouri Tigers playing less than NFL football against the West Texas Red Raiders.stlouie_lipp wrote:Minor League football with four divisions: SEC, Big10, PAC10 and Big12 or Big East or ACC?
Go ahead and drop the charade of "student athlete" for these big programs and remove any ties to academics.
If it is just the name changes that bother you, then don't change the names. The universities could "liscense" their name to these minor league teams! Cha-ching!
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: The U is in serious trouble
Other than the facilities and the gym class that the coach might teach, football is already a separate animal from the university. It is like on another planet from about anything else related to the university. There's nothing else at the university that operates even close to the same way. Unless you know some physics major recruits who were taken on a bender by academic boosters.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:It's not simply name change, it's the complete separation from the university. Within a year or two, that team won't have any true association to anything that matters to me, or thousands of other people. Plus there's the issue of all the stadiums/facilities still being at the universities themselves, and the universities won't want to give up what is such a big driver for them in dollars and in enrollment. It's something that wouldn't "fix" things, would lead to a widespread decrease in interest, and would never happen in a million years anyway.
I disagree that paying players would not "fix" things. These crazy antics like we are hearing about from Miami simply do not happen in minor league baseball, where guys get paid. Yes, guys get caught doing silly (and maybe even illegal) things like what Shelby Miller just did. But that is his own fault. He was not aided and abetted by boosters of his team while the team itself pretended not to see. Paying the players their market value would extract the university from this conflict of interests (winning recruits versus following the rules).
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: The U is in serious trouble
You're right, there probably are guys out there still playing for the degree and love of the game...but it seems to be fewer and fewer guys like that every year. And it sounds like the SEC is more rampant with this stuff than some of the other leagues.Socnorb11 wrote:I disagree. Maybe I'm really naive, but I think the majority of student athletes are actually there for the scholarship/degree, and because they love the game. Why else would they be there? Most of them will never play at the next level, and most of them aren't good enough to be getting booster support.pioneer98 wrote:That's the point, Mizzou is already playing minor league football, just not formally recognized.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Then you have to drop the association with the universities for their tax-exempt status. I love Mizzou football, but I couldn't care less about the Mid-Missouri Tigers playing less than NFL football against the West Texas Red Raiders.stlouie_lipp wrote:Minor League football with four divisions: SEC, Big10, PAC10 and Big12 or Big East or ACC?
Go ahead and drop the charade of "student athlete" for these big programs and remove any ties to academics.
FYI - the teams that use all these illicit tactics to recruit players refer to the teams that don't as "losers".
This is my whole problem with the thing. It's not that different from steroids in baseball, except its at the team level, and not the individual player level. You don't know which teams are clean, which ones aren't, and you'll be left wondering, "Hmmm, did they cheat to win that bowl game, or was it legit?" We may never know, so it ruins the whole sport, even for the clean teams.
- Transmogrified Tiger
- Puppy Murderer
- Posts: 9323
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
- Location: Across the River
Re: The U is in serious trouble
The point is that it becomes minor league baseball, and no one cares about minor league baseball. Maybe in some regions without pro teams and diehard fans like in SEC country, but after a few years you'd see widespread disinterest and big attendance drops. Add in that you now have the whole team on the payroll, and it's even more of a losing proposition. Plus the best talent would sue for the right to go to the NFL right away, and then you'd have a talent drain on top of it.pioneer98 wrote:Other than the facilities and the gym class that the coach might teach, football is already a separate animal from the university. It is like on another planet from about anything else related to the university. There's nothing else at the university that operates even close to the same way. Unless you know some physics major recruits who were taken on a bender by academic boosters.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21912
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: The U is in serious trouble
pioneer98 wrote:Other than the facilities and the gym class that the coach might teach, football is already a separate animal from the university. It is like on another planet from about anything else related to the university. There's nothing else at the university that operates even close to the same way. Unless you know some physics major recruits who were taken on a bender by academic boosters.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:It's not simply name change, it's the complete separation from the university. Within a year or two, that team won't have any true association to anything that matters to me, or thousands of other people. Plus there's the issue of all the stadiums/facilities still being at the universities themselves, and the universities won't want to give up what is such a big driver for them in dollars and in enrollment. It's something that wouldn't "fix" things, would lead to a widespread decrease in interest, and would never happen in a million years anyway.
I disagree that paying players would not "fix" things. These crazy antics like we are hearing about from Miami simply do not happen in minor league baseball, where guys get paid. Yes, guys get caught doing silly (and maybe even illegal) things like what Shelby Miller just did. But that is his own fault. He was not aided and abetted by boosters of his team while the team itself pretended not to see. Paying the players their market value would extract the university from this conflict of interests (winning recruits versus following the rules).
There are no boosters in minor league baseball, because the kids don't have a choice of which team to play for. They play for whomever drafts them. Boosters can't influence that.
I think stringent punishment could fix most of the problems in college football. Give Miami the death penalty. Frankly, it might help if the boosters could somehow be prosecuted, as well. I doubt if this sort of thing will be entirely eliminated, but there have certainly been more leaks and busts within the last few years than ever before. Maybe they can get it under control.
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: The U is in serious trouble
Let's make the claim that college football is like the minor leagues. The total value of what college football athletes get is much better, in the large majority of cases, than those of minor league baseball players.
- pioneer98
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22007
- Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
- Location: High A Minors
Re: The U is in serious trouble
Let me know when they get it under control. I might tune in again then.Socnorb11 wrote:pioneer98 wrote:Other than the facilities and the gym class that the coach might teach, football is already a separate animal from the university. It is like on another planet from about anything else related to the university. There's nothing else at the university that operates even close to the same way. Unless you know some physics major recruits who were taken on a bender by academic boosters.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:It's not simply name change, it's the complete separation from the university. Within a year or two, that team won't have any true association to anything that matters to me, or thousands of other people. Plus there's the issue of all the stadiums/facilities still being at the universities themselves, and the universities won't want to give up what is such a big driver for them in dollars and in enrollment. It's something that wouldn't "fix" things, would lead to a widespread decrease in interest, and would never happen in a million years anyway.
I disagree that paying players would not "fix" things. These crazy antics like we are hearing about from Miami simply do not happen in minor league baseball, where guys get paid. Yes, guys get caught doing silly (and maybe even illegal) things like what Shelby Miller just did. But that is his own fault. He was not aided and abetted by boosters of his team while the team itself pretended not to see. Paying the players their market value would extract the university from this conflict of interests (winning recruits versus following the rules).
There are no boosters in minor league baseball, because the kids don't have a choice of which team to play for. They play for whomever drafts them. Boosters can't influence that.
I think stringent punishment could fix most of the problems in college football. Give Miami the death penalty. Frankly, it might help if the boosters could somehow be prosecuted, as well. I doubt if this sort of thing will be entirely eliminated, but there have certainly been more leaks and busts within the last few years than ever before. Maybe they can get it under control.
I'm not holding my breath.

