Leroy wrote:I haven't yet read everything in this thread and the story sounds terrible. But someone made a good point the other day. If I'm a theater major in college and I get a gig on Broadway, no problem. If I'm on a full ride as a violinist and I get a summer gig in Nashville, no problem. If I'm on an accounting scholarship and prepare tax returns for cash, no problem.
I don't know the answer, but the existing system kind of sucks.
It does, no doubt. Maybe they should get a little stipend.
But this is a little different. This is paying players to come to your school. That is, and should be illegal. Otherwise, the best programs will be the ones w/ the biggest boosters, end of story.
Uh, gee, what programs do you think are the best right now?
Last year's Heisman winner's family received a couple hundred K to go to school...oh, but it was a "charitable donation", I forgot.
Put in a salary cap or luxury tax system. Sign players to big giant contracts to come to your school. Put clauses in the contract about it being void if the player is ever caught with a hooker.
Yeah, turning it pro would mean some schools would be perennially favored over others. But that's exactly what we have now. Going "pro" would remove the schools from having to bribe with illegal activities, at least. If the players want to buy drugs or hookers with the money they make, then it's on them and not the university.
T Boone Pickens- biggest booster there is, OSU hasn't even won a conference title.
Northwestern-I'm sure has tons of super loaded boosters- Nada
Auburn, Alabama, Oklahoma, Texas, Ohio State, do those have the biggest booster's is that what you're saying?
Then T Boone Pickens aint trying hard enough!!!! He needs a yacht, a jet to take these kids to Miami Beach, hooker parties, and to hang at the best nightclubs! I could totally see Boone doing that.
It's like any other kind of sport - recruiting is only one aspect of a winning program. It's a biggie, but not the only one. It's like payroll in baseball - doesn't guarantee a winner, does it?
Northwestern FYI still holds their athletes to a pretty high academic standard as well. That might be holding them back. Because I bet if they let loose, they could wine and dine like few others in the Windy City!
there's a growing internet theory on the universities forming the 4 "super" conferences, then breaking away from the NCAA and running their own athletics. Probably will never happen, but would be pretty interesting.
Michael wrote:I think the NCAA should be abolished. Just open up the process to the free market and be done with it.
Is there a constituency for that position?
Absolutely. The NCAA is designed to enrich universities off the backs off of many poor students under the guise of that it's about competition and scholarship. That's absurd. It's about money.
Just pay these players and be done with it.
I'm not even sure that there is a guise anymore. There is value in the scholarships, there is value in the opportunities being presented (which these student athletes wouldn't otherwise get).
Socnorb11 wrote:You think colleges should be reponsible for supporting athletes' families, too?
Boosters are supporting athlete's families as we speak. Cam Newton's dad's "charity" got $180,000 in the most recent Heisman scandal.
Interesting question whether it should be the universities paying them or not. The boosters might come up with enough cash on the universities' behalf to get the job done - just make it legal and over the table instead of all this illegal under the table crap.
longhornbaseball wrote:I don't think the universities should pay them, but they shouldn't be prevented from getting paid for endorsements and the like.
What do you mean by endorsements?
Like could Booster X from Any Given State University offer to 'endorse' Top Prospect from Any Given High School 1 million dollars if he agreed to shoot a commercial or two for Booster X's business and that offer was contingent upon Top Prospect from AGHS going to AGSU? Because that is likely what would happen.
What about Agent X offers to pay Top Prospect from AGSU 1 million dollars if he simply agreed to sign with Agent X's company when he entered the draft?
I have no problem with any of this, fwiw, I was just curious if you had thought about this or were just saying that.
Socnorb11 wrote:You think colleges should be reponsible for supporting athletes' families, too?
Boosters are supporting athlete's families as we speak. Cam Newton's dad's "charity" got $180,000 in the most recent Heisman scandal.
Interesting question whether it should be the universities paying them or not. The boosters might come up with enough cash on the universities' behalf to get the job done - just make it legal and over the table instead of all this illegal under the table crap.
clevername wrote:there's a growing internet theory on the universities forming the 4 "super" conferences, then breaking away from the NCAA and running their own athletics. Probably will never happen, but would be pretty interesting.
clevername wrote:there's a growing internet theory on the universities forming the 4 "super" conferences, then breaking away from the NCAA and running their own athletics. Probably will never happen, but would be pretty interesting.
Wouldn't independent conferences inevitably lead to these programs directly paying their players? Why on Earth would the schools that are making a killing off their athletes want to do that?
Socnorb11 wrote:You think colleges should be reponsible for supporting athletes' families, too?
Boosters are supporting athlete's families as we speak. Cam Newton's dad's "charity" got $180,000 in the most recent Heisman scandal.
Interesting question whether it should be the universities paying them or not. The boosters might come up with enough cash on the universities' behalf to get the job done - just make it legal and over the table instead of all this illegal under the table crap.
And pay taxes on it, of course.
Absolutely! Legalize it and tax the crap out of it.
It would fall under The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, Explosives, and FOOTBALL!!!!