Harry Potter criticism of the day

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by Cronos »

Maclowery wrote:goes to re watch MirrorMask
Damn, I forgot about MirrorMask and how good it was. I have to pick that up on Blu-ray sometime.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by cpebbles »

quidditch: No, not the absolutely ridiculous golden snitch thing. Retarded as it is, it's a natural offshoot of the Harry Potter is the center of the universe shameless escapism that the series is built around.

Here's what bothers me more: The stupid snitch is not worth 15 points, it's worth 15 goals, which happens to be 150 points. Yeah, goals are worth 10 points. What kind of BS score inflation is that? I know JK Rowling is from a country where they don't play real sports, but this is inexcusably dumb. Touchdowns are worth more points because there are other ways to score. Is a soccer game where only one score happens any more exciting if you call the score 10 to 0? If so, why not 20? 100?

The only remaining explanation is that they're doing this to pump up a lot of little kids' self esteem, but is that really a good idea? Our "everyone's a winner!" society has already turned the last couple of generations into an insufferable batch of entitled brats. Do we really want to do that to a bunch of little kids that have been taught to kill anyone who bursts their stupid little bubbles with a flick of their wrists?

User avatar
Transmogrified Tiger
Puppy Murderer
Posts: 9323
Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
Location: Across the River

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by Transmogrified Tiger »

Hermione had to go to school before she went to Hogwarts, right? So other people presumably know she exists? What do her parents say when people run into them at the grocery store and ask what happened to her?

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by cpebbles »

Dumbledore being gay: Rowling correctly surmised that nobody wants to know about the sexual proclivities of a fictional 70 year old man, so she didn't write about them. Like the rest of the characters, he is asexual as far as I can tell. You don't get to then go back and make a meaningless, totally inconsequential declaration that he's gay. If that was a part of his character, it would have been written into the books. But as long as we're throwing arbitrary sexual preferences onto fictional characters: Gandalf has a foot fetish, and Lando Calrissian cries after every time he has sex.

Online
User avatar
obucard
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8181
Joined: April 18 06, 11:04 pm
Location: Central AR

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by obucard »

cpebbles wrote:Dumbledore being gay: Rowling correctly surmised that nobody wants to know about the sexual proclivities of a fictional 70 year old man, so she didn't write about them. Like the rest of the characters, he is asexual as far as I can tell. You don't get to then go back and make a meaningless, totally inconsequential declaration that he's gay. If that was a part of his character, it would have been written into the books. But as long as we're throwing arbitrary sexual preferences onto fictional characters: Gandalf has a foot fetish, and Lando Calrissian cries after every time he has sex.
In her defense, she was asked if Dumbledore had ever loved anyone. She gave her answer, which prompted most people to latch on the fact that said character was male. Also, I can't totally blame her here, given the accusations of homophobia she got after certain other characters turned out not to be gay.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by cpebbles »

I should probably point out that this thread is just me picking on a cultural phenomenon I've never really understood. I haven't read any books and I'm not even sure if I've seen all the movies (Except the last two, which I know I haven't seen).

User avatar
JCShutout
MacGyver of Underwear
Posts: 13368
Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
Location: South City

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by JCShutout »

I read all the books for the first time between Christmas and New Years and really enjoyed them. I saw the 1st movie and thought it was very good. Very close to the book. I then saw the 7th movie in theaters and was completely unsatisfied, though, perhaps that's because I hadn't seen the rest of the movies. The series is a bit sexist, but otherwise they are very good stories.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by cpebbles »

Hagrid: Just how many times do the dangerous animals that he has such a fondness for have to come close to killing little kids before he crosses firmly over into villain territory? Giant spiders, hippogryphs, the big giant... I'm pretty sure he had something to do with that big three-headed dog from the first movie. Reading wiki I was right on that, plus he's got a poisonous dragon that either slipped my mind or appeared in a movie I didn't see.

The guy is basically a Bond villain, except he's considered a good guy because he's just too stupid to learn his lesson about keeping killer animals around sticky-fingered, stupid children.

maddash
is eerily well-versed on Project Runway and irony
Posts: 8508
Joined: June 26 06, 3:07 pm

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by maddash »

cpebbles wrote:Hagrid: Just how many times do the dangerous animals that he has such a fondness for have to come close to killing little kids before he crosses firmly over into villain territory? Giant spiders, hippogryphs, the big giant... I'm pretty sure he had something to do with that big three-headed dog from the first movie. Reading wiki I was right on that, plus he's got a poisonous dragon that either slipped my mind or appeared in a movie I didn't see.

The guy is basically a Bond villain, except he's considered a good guy because he's just too stupid to learn his lesson about keeping killer animals around sticky-fingered, stupid children.
And he's a convicted sex offender.

User avatar
Radbird
There's someone in my head but it's not me
Posts: 62390
Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II

Re: Harry Potter criticism of the day

Post by Radbird »

JCShutout wrote:I read all the books for the first time between Christmas and New Years and really enjoyed them. I saw the 1st movie and thought it was very good. Very close to the book. I then saw the 7th movie in theaters and was completely unsatisfied, though, perhaps that's because I hadn't seen the rest of the movies. The series is a bit sexist, but otherwise they are very good stories.
That's a lot of pages in a week's time. Took me a couple of months to get through all seven books. And I've seen all the movies except the current one and thought they all sucked because of the things they changed/left out.

Post Reply