Wait a minute ....KyCardinalFan wrote:I totally understand, sigh. I'm usually a very mild-mannered teacher, and I always stress to my lovely students that if they run into a problem with the class or any papers that I assign, that they should speak with me. I invite them to give me drafts to look at, and even give them the chance to revise for full credit.
But this semester I had a stupid student who never bothered to read the assigned material, never bothered to meet with me about her drafts, often didn't come to class, and begorra! here she comes with three revised papers. I take a look at one--it starts out poorly, then all of a sudden, the prose is great. Like the posters of GRB. Big long words, flowing sentences, and I'm thinking . . . hang on . . . you don't write this. You don't think like this. Let me Google this . . .
So far, I've caught her plagiarizing from five different sources, and this is just the tip of the iceberg. Two different papers are plagiarized, and I haven't even gotten to her final paper. Worse yet, she's a real mony, mony, phony-baloney, and I fully expect crocodile rock tears. But, hi ho, hi ho, off to the dean she goes.
Plagiarism
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Plagiarism
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Plagiarism
jim-isms are public realm.
- cardinalkarp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 18750
- Joined: May 4 06, 8:44 am
Re: Plagiarism
You have to keep us updated on this. I want to hear about this girl going down in flames. As a student who busts my ass to put out a good paper & not just throw a bunch of stuff together that was written by others it's nice to see people that do cheat get what's coming to them.
There was a girl who sat next to me in class that would never read the assigned material and for the papers we would have to write (and I'm talking short 2-3 page papers so it's not as if they were hard) she would simply go online find others analysis of the material and use it as her own. This teacher didn't use the site I spoke about earlier so she was able to get away with it, but that didn't keep me from being pissed that she was doing it. I guess she'll get what's coming to her at some point.
There was a girl who sat next to me in class that would never read the assigned material and for the papers we would have to write (and I'm talking short 2-3 page papers so it's not as if they were hard) she would simply go online find others analysis of the material and use it as her own. This teacher didn't use the site I spoke about earlier so she was able to get away with it, but that didn't keep me from being pissed that she was doing it. I guess she'll get what's coming to her at some point.
- redbirdjazzz
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 4921
- Joined: April 17 06, 10:50 am
- Location: Columbia, MO
Re: Plagiarism
I caught my first plagiarizer on Thursday night, but the professor I'm working for didn't want to deal with the hassle (nor was it anywhere near as egregious as Sigh's case), so he wouldn't let me do anything about it. I was very disappointed.
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Plagiarism
Sorry to hear that, redbird.
Well, I turned in all evidence to the dean's office--a two-page, single-spaced letter detailing all the instances of plagiarism, together with all lifted quotations highlighted in the original sources, the student's plagiarized papers with highlighted plagiarized passages, the original assignment guidelines, my syllabus with its plagiarism statement, and all relevant e-mails. There's so much stuff that it took hours to compile, hours to write the letter, and a half-hour to photocopy and collate it all.
This is as solid a case as can exist in the known universe.
I'm not going to respond to the student any more, though. One of the advisers assured me that I've done enough to turn the material in. It's all up to her now. She could appeal to the Academic Discipline Committee, although I seriously doubt she will. She has no idea how much material I uncovered, but she has to suspect that I've found something. I really don't mind if she does appeal, since I would enjoy letting other faculty see just what she has done.
The worst part of it is that she's in the School of Education and wants to be a teacher. I don't want this person anywhere near a student.
I'll keep you informed, but I really think that this is the end of it.
Well, I turned in all evidence to the dean's office--a two-page, single-spaced letter detailing all the instances of plagiarism, together with all lifted quotations highlighted in the original sources, the student's plagiarized papers with highlighted plagiarized passages, the original assignment guidelines, my syllabus with its plagiarism statement, and all relevant e-mails. There's so much stuff that it took hours to compile, hours to write the letter, and a half-hour to photocopy and collate it all.
This is as solid a case as can exist in the known universe.
I'm not going to respond to the student any more, though. One of the advisers assured me that I've done enough to turn the material in. It's all up to her now. She could appeal to the Academic Discipline Committee, although I seriously doubt she will. She has no idea how much material I uncovered, but she has to suspect that I've found something. I really don't mind if she does appeal, since I would enjoy letting other faculty see just what she has done.
The worst part of it is that she's in the School of Education and wants to be a teacher. I don't want this person anywhere near a student.
I'll keep you informed, but I really think that this is the end of it.
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: Plagiarism
Keep fighting the good fight, Sigh.
There really seems to be a common mentality among students these days similar to your specimen. Students who believe they are entitled to an A no matter what effort they put in. I have a good friend who's a professor at SLU and he tells me all his stories about students going after him when he gives them something less than an A. He's had students threaten him over a B before.
I caught a few students in my days of grading papers for professors. Things where students clearly copied another student's work. Our dean has a philosophy that "you should work with your peers, but don't copy your friend's mistakes"... well, when you have a problem where the units are in inches and 3 students all have the exact same wrong answer given in centimeters, it sets off an alarm.
When I taught a Physics lab course, after every lab students would have to turn in a report. I found students of the same nationality tended to copy the most. I compared my reports with other TA's to check for duplicates, and often we had students from Saudi Arabia and China submit the same paper in different classes.
The professor in charge of the labs only let me punish them with a 0 for the paper, though.
There really seems to be a common mentality among students these days similar to your specimen. Students who believe they are entitled to an A no matter what effort they put in. I have a good friend who's a professor at SLU and he tells me all his stories about students going after him when he gives them something less than an A. He's had students threaten him over a B before.
I caught a few students in my days of grading papers for professors. Things where students clearly copied another student's work. Our dean has a philosophy that "you should work with your peers, but don't copy your friend's mistakes"... well, when you have a problem where the units are in inches and 3 students all have the exact same wrong answer given in centimeters, it sets off an alarm.
When I taught a Physics lab course, after every lab students would have to turn in a report. I found students of the same nationality tended to copy the most. I compared my reports with other TA's to check for duplicates, and often we had students from Saudi Arabia and China submit the same paper in different classes.
The professor in charge of the labs only let me punish them with a 0 for the paper, though.
- TheoSqua
- Next Gen Wart
- Posts: 8951
- Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
- Location: St. Louis
- Contact:
Re: Plagiarism
So what exactly is defined as plagarism? I've never really been fully sure and when I was in college 5-6 years ago every teach had a different definition of it at the community college I went to. There wasn't really a unified policy.
I mean when you think about it, the bulk of our knowledge is plagiarized. We read books and analysis from other people and use that to form our critical thinking. So if you hit every unoriginal thought in an essay you'd likely have to fail 99% of papers.
For example when I was in college I'd commonly find information on my topic that I agreed with and then reword that information and use it in my essay. If it was more than a sentence or so i'd use the other material as my source (I almost always used it as a source since I was too lazy to find more than the required number of sources), but the end result wasn't really that different from plagarism: I found material that supported my personal opinion and used that in my essay to support it.
It seems in some cases you're more handicapped for not being as skilled at writing as someone else. If I hadn't been as good at rewriting information to better suit my personal writing style, would I have been plagiarizing?
I mean when you think about it, the bulk of our knowledge is plagiarized. We read books and analysis from other people and use that to form our critical thinking. So if you hit every unoriginal thought in an essay you'd likely have to fail 99% of papers.
For example when I was in college I'd commonly find information on my topic that I agreed with and then reword that information and use it in my essay. If it was more than a sentence or so i'd use the other material as my source (I almost always used it as a source since I was too lazy to find more than the required number of sources), but the end result wasn't really that different from plagarism: I found material that supported my personal opinion and used that in my essay to support it.
It seems in some cases you're more handicapped for not being as skilled at writing as someone else. If I hadn't been as good at rewriting information to better suit my personal writing style, would I have been plagiarizing?
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Plagiarism
Here is the statement from my syllabus:
In other words, acknowledging is important. So I don't get the idea "99% of all knowledge is plagiarized." Nor do I demand a unique idea about every story or poem. Some ideas are obvious--Rip Van Winkle fell asleep--and you wouldn't be plagiarizng for stating the obvious, or for stating common knowledge, such as George Washington is the first president.
Besides, for an undergraduate course, I'm not looking for a unified field theory, or a knowledge of 300 years of Shakespeare scholarship. Just tell me what you think, and back it up with evidence. But I do expect people to read--which this student, again, didn't do.
As for not being skilled at writing--well, that's why I gave feedback on all papers and let students revise for full credit. I always do this, because that's part of learning--practice, feedback, revision. There's also a wonderful Writing Center at the university. On this woman's first paper, I wrote more in comments than she did on the paper. That should say something--none of it about how unclear or arbitrary my standards were.
She never came to a single office hour or office minute. During class discussions, she would shake her head to indicate to other students that she hadn't read the material.
No, she simply blew that class off.
The student did 1 and 2. Copious amounts of 1 and 2.According to the section on academic dishonesty, plagiarism is “representing the words or ideas of someone else as one’s own in any academic exercise, such as”:
1. Submitting as one’s own a paper written by another person or by a commercial “ghost writing” service,
2. Exactly reproducing someone else’s words without identifying the words with quotation marks or by appropriate indentation, or without properly citing the quotation in a footnote or reference,
3. Paraphrasing or summarizing someone else’s work without acknowledging the source with a footnote or reference,
4. Using facts data, graphs, charts, or other information without acknowledging the source with a footnote or reference. Borrowed facts or information obtained in one’s research or reading must be acknowledged unless they are “common knowledge” . . . . The specific audience for which a paper is written may determine what can be viewed as “common knowledge”: for example, the facts commonly known by a group of chemists will differ radically from those known by a more general audience. Students should check with their teachers regarding what can be viewed as ‘common knowledge’ within a specific field or assignment, but often the student will have to make the final judgment. When in doubt, footnotes or references should be used. (27)
In other words, acknowledging is important. So I don't get the idea "99% of all knowledge is plagiarized." Nor do I demand a unique idea about every story or poem. Some ideas are obvious--Rip Van Winkle fell asleep--and you wouldn't be plagiarizng for stating the obvious, or for stating common knowledge, such as George Washington is the first president.
Besides, for an undergraduate course, I'm not looking for a unified field theory, or a knowledge of 300 years of Shakespeare scholarship. Just tell me what you think, and back it up with evidence. But I do expect people to read--which this student, again, didn't do.
As for not being skilled at writing--well, that's why I gave feedback on all papers and let students revise for full credit. I always do this, because that's part of learning--practice, feedback, revision. There's also a wonderful Writing Center at the university. On this woman's first paper, I wrote more in comments than she did on the paper. That should say something--none of it about how unclear or arbitrary my standards were.
She never came to a single office hour or office minute. During class discussions, she would shake her head to indicate to other students that she hadn't read the material.
No, she simply blew that class off.
- TheoSqua
- Next Gen Wart
- Posts: 8951
- Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
- Location: St. Louis
- Contact:
Re: Plagiarism
I may have done number 3 a few times, but that was probably be the worst of my offenses. And you make a good point about communication. For the bulk of my writing classes I was working 45 hours a week while taking 15 credit hours, so I tended to not have a whole lot of time to polish essays and the like. But all my professors were well aware of it and tended to work with me.
It's really dumb for someone like her to cheat with you when it seems like you give her more than enough leeway in getting the assignment done. If you're gonna cheat you'd think it'd be in a class not nearly as accommodating.
It's really dumb for someone like her to cheat with you when it seems like you give her more than enough leeway in getting the assignment done. If you're gonna cheat you'd think it'd be in a class not nearly as accommodating.



