Page 1 of 2
Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 2:45 pm
by Magneto2.0
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 4:56 pm
by mikechamp
Well... so much for a 2027 MLB season.
Who's excited for MiLB the show 2027?
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 5:09 pm
by Socnorb11
I feel like we've known this for about 2 years.
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 5:20 pm
by jagtrader
Rich people don’t feel like they’re accountable anymore. Watching the government the past two years has emboldened them.
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 5:25 pm
by ghostrunner
I don’t know if he believes that but I think he’s wrong. Not saying there’s no world where they get a cap but I think it’s really about how long players will hold out and I think that’s a very long time.
I kept meaning to post an article about this from Craig Goldstein formerly of BP, but never got around to it. Basically his point was there’s a time pretty early where teams start losing enough revenue and the urgency of that becomes too much. Tickets, broadcast, merch, etc… And I think an extended lockout means future losses due to disinterest that affects the teams and baseball itself more acutely than it does individual players.
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 5:38 pm
by santimirovasergij
Ghostrunner’s point cuts both ways: owners may feel the revenue hit sooner than players feel missed paychecks, but they also control the schedule and can wait longer. A cap alone is a nonstarter for the MLBPA; a meaningful floor is the only plausible trade. The real question is whether the floor is high enough and phased in fast enough to offset the cap’s drag on free-agent money. If Manfred is drawing a public line this early, that suggests the owners want the fight—and probably a shortened or canceled 2027 season—more than they want a quick deal.
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 6:48 pm
by CardsofSTL
The players should say they won't accept a deal where the commissioner is just the owners mouthpiece.
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 7:56 pm
by ghostrunner
CardsofSTL wrote: ↑November 18 26, 6:48 pm
The players should say they won't accept a deal where the commissioner is just the owners mouthpiece.
That’s another thing. A diverse commission (major and minor league players, owners, some form of fan and or host city reps, etc ) who then vote on an impartial commissioner and then open books ought to be their conditions. I’m skeptical of a cap, but open to it and that’s a decent trade given where we are. Not that I think most players care about those things, but owners would likely say hell no and then we’re done.
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 8:17 pm
by WAR God
Socnorb11 wrote: ↑November 18 26, 5:09 pm
I feel like we've known this for about 2 years.
Yeah, 100%. They’re going to the mattresses on this one.
Re: Rob Manfred says the owners will not budge on instituting a salary cap and floor
Posted: November 18 26, 8:40 pm
by Popeye_Card
Without seeing any sort of numbers on what a cap and floor would be yet, it seems to me like the players as a whole have more to gain by getting a salary floor than they have to lose by having a cap imposed. The luxury cap threshold already acts as a de facto cap, with only a few teams willing to venture above it. Meanwhile there's no floor, and a whole bunch of teams willing to spend absolutely nothing on free agents.
I know I said this plenty during the last CBA, but the real barrier to a consistently competitive league is between large revenue vs. small revenue owners, and veteran players vs. pre-arb and minor league players.