Page 1 of 1

Future = three catchers in the lineup?

Posted: May 13 26, 9:03 am
by MansSearch
When Rainiel is ready for prime time:
Herrera - LF
Crooks and Rainiel Rodriguez - split catcher and DH.

Unfortunately, Ivan has shown us that he can't prevent base stealers. The poor guy hasn’t thrown out a runner since September 1, 2024.
His MLB career is 6 for 89. Ouch. I have to think he'd be playable in LF, although one concern is that his sprint speed was relatively good before the knee injury, but he's gone from 27.3 mph in 2024 (great for a catcher or LF) to 26.3 last year to 25.5 so far this year. But he is athletic and agile, so among the three, it has to be him. I've watched RR and he is slow and short and I can't see him in LF (or 3b).

So later this year and starting in the offseason, get Ivan lots of time in LF so we know when it's RR time.

Re: Future = three catchers in the lineup?

Posted: May 13 26, 11:31 am
by CardsofSTL
I think if LF were a true option for Ivan then we'd be seeing him out there now with Church in CF rather than Fermin or Saggese. You also have to factor in that he made it very clear that he wanted to catch.

More likely he'd split DH/1B time with Burleson; but I don't think they want to do too much of that because they want Burly to be comfortable at 1st.

You have to think one of them will end up being traded at some point. They won't worry about it until after the CBA.

Re: Future = three catchers in the lineup?

Posted: May 13 26, 11:43 am
by GeddyWrox
MansSearch wrote: ↑
May 13 26, 9:03 am
When Rainiel is ready for prime time:
Herrera - LF
Crooks and Rainiel Rodriguez - split catcher and DH.

Unfortunately, Ivan has shown us that he can't prevent base stealers. The poor guy hasn’t thrown out a runner since September 1, 2024.
His MLB career is 6 for 89. Ouch. I have to think he'd be playable in LF, although one concern is that his sprint speed was relatively good before the knee injury, but he's gone from 27.3 mph in 2024 (great for a catcher or LF) to 26.3 last year to 25.5 so far this year. But he is athletic and agile, so among the three, it has to be him. I've watched RR and he is slow and short and I can't see him in LF (or 3b).

So later this year and starting in the offseason, get Ivan lots of time in LF so we know when it's RR time.
Maybe belated, but welcome to the board!

It's a very interesting problem to have, for sure. I think you might see Crooks traded (possibly for LF help [or pitching and LF signed via FA]) once they're sold on RR being able to stick in the bigs.

Also agree with Cards that likely nothing will happen until after the CBA gets straightened out.

Re: Future = three catchers in the lineup?

Posted: May 13 26, 11:47 am
by GeddyWrox
We also should mention Bernal, too. He might draw some interest in the trade market as well.

Re: Future = three catchers in the lineup?

Posted: May 13 26, 1:03 pm
by jagtrader
This will sort itself out. Not all of them will be useful major leaguers.

Re: Future = three catchers in the lineup?

Posted: May 13 26, 5:49 pm
by MansSearch
GeddyWrox wrote: ↑
May 13 26, 11:43 am
MansSearch wrote: ↑
May 13 26, 9:03 am
When Rainiel is ready for prime time:
Herrera - LF
Crooks and Rainiel Rodriguez - split catcher and DH.

Unfortunately, Ivan has shown us that he can't prevent base stealers. The poor guy hasn’t thrown out a runner since September 1, 2024.
His MLB career is 6 for 89. Ouch. I have to think he'd be playable in LF, although one concern is that his sprint speed was relatively good before the knee injury, but he's gone from 27.3 mph in 2024 (great for a catcher or LF) to 26.3 last year to 25.5 so far this year. But he is athletic and agile, so among the three, it has to be him. I've watched RR and he is slow and short and I can't see him in LF (or 3b).

So later this year and starting in the offseason, get Ivan lots of time in LF so we know when it's RR time.
Maybe belated, but welcome to the board!

It's a very interesting problem to have, for sure. I think you might see Crooks traded (possibly for LF help [or pitching and LF signed via FA]) once they're sold on RR being able to stick in the bigs.

Also agree with Cards that likely nothing will happen until after the CBA gets straightened out.
Thanks for the welcome message. Looks like a congenial group with good discussions.

Re: Future = three catchers in the lineup?

Posted: May 13 26, 8:59 pm
by phins
Herrera has only cost the Cardinals one run from his throwing according to his FanGraphs' page, so while the percentage is putrid, the metrics seem to think he's fairly decent at everything other than framing (which is reducing in importance). Herrera is a stick, no doubt, but he can catch at the big league level in a tandem to my eyes.

Re: Future = three catchers in the lineup?

Posted: May 14 26, 12:37 pm
by ghostrunner
phins wrote: ↑
May 13 26, 8:59 pm
Herrera has only cost the Cardinals one run from his throwing according to his FanGraphs' page, so while the percentage is putrid, the metrics seem to think he's fairly decent at everything other than framing (which is reducing in importance). Herrera is a stick, no doubt, but he can catch at the big league level in a tandem to my eyes.
Sounds like both he and the Cardinals are committed to him catching. At least going by all the online/podcast/journalist sources I've heard talk about it. But also he likely won't be the only catcher. So whatever happens between Crooks and Rodriguez, it'll likely be one of them swapping C/DH with him for a while. And the other being traded or Rodriguez moved to first. Unless they just lose faith in Herrera back there.

I'm surprised it's only been 8 steals against Herrera so far. I know he's only catching two pitchers, and they had Pages catch Pallante against the Brewers, but still.