Steve Adams' NL Central comments
Posted: April 21 26, 11:51 am
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on April 14. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)
This is from last week. I'll have his chat from today posted a little later.
Even fewer questions this week, so I included 1 bonus Q&A about free agent year motivation. Enjoy!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/04/ ... t-120.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Tell me you were wrong about Jordan Walker!!
Steve Adams
Do this for another few months and I sure will.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Sal Stewart the real deal?
Steve Adams
Sal can mash.
Fully in on him as a legitimate middle-of-the-order type at first base.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see 18-20 saves from a not-so-obvious closer this year?
Steve Adams
I suppose Lucas Erceg doesn’t count, but he’s better than Carlos Estevez anyway.Texas situation is pretty up in the air. I don’t think Junis will hold it. Cole Winn is probably my favorite of the arms in that bunch. Griffin Jax in Tampa has been hit hard but is SO talented that I could see him running with the closer role at some point. I am perpetually the “down” guy on Emilio Pagan among the MLBTR staff and I like Graham Ashcraft in the ‘pen, so that’s intriguing to me. But Pagan’s going to have plenty of leash if he’s healthy.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Has CJ Abrams’ hot start upped his value to the point where middle infielder needy teams may be ready to bite the bullet on Taboni’s trade ask? Thoughts on possible suitors?
Steve Adams
Nothing thus far has really changed my view of him. I touted him as a high-end trade piece all winter and think he was and still is just that. He’s had huge three-month performances to start each of the past two seasons before collapsing. The challenge is getting him to maintain and also finding a new defensive home.Abrams is hitting the ball harder and walking more, if you’re looking for positive indicators, but 60 PAs isn’t enough for me to read much into either, especially when he’s chasing a bit more and his overall contact rate is down considerably.
I think Abrams should command a very strong return if the Nats move him this summer — multiple top prospects — and he should hold interest to a pretty wide swath of teams. He’d be better suited at 2B or in the OF than shortstop. A team like the Pirates could try him at 3B. Pittsburgh, Toronto, Kansas City, Detroit, Boston … I can see plenty of clubs having real interest.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If McMahon doesn’t start to hit soon can you see them making rumored trade going around of Gil for Shaw?
Steve Adams
I hadn’t seen this “rumor” so I searched for it before the chat. It’s really just one speculative “hey this makes sense to me” from a prominent Yankees blogger. There’s no real rumor there, and I’d rather have Luis Gil than Matt Shaw personally, although I’m probably more down on both players than most.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Team that has been playing beyond expectations? Pittsburgh, Minnesota?
Steve Adams
Both? Haha!
Pirates’ offense has been far better than I expected. In general, I thought expectations were too high for the group. I still think that’s true, but Oneil Cruz is an MVP-level talent in the batter’s box (not so much on the defensive side, yeesh), so if this is the beginning of a true breakout, then hell yeah they’re going to be exciting. Twins’ start is hilarious and entertaining but seems entirely unsustainable.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Picks for Rookies of the year?
Steve Adams
I picked DeLauter and Griffin prior to the season.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I’m not a Noelvi Marte fan, but it feels like Francona set him up to fail. Sporadic at-bats, platoon against LHP knowing that Marte hits RHP better. Is this the end of Marte or is he someone who needs to be traded to a new team?
Steve Adams
I do not understand Cincinnati’s fixation on Will Benson. I’d have had Marte playing every day in right field. I still think he can be a solid corner outfielder, and the current big league group is shaky enough that he can hit his way back into another opportunity if he gets right. I’m curious to see if Rece Hinds can maintain any of the small-sample contact/plate discipline gains he’s made in AAA though. He’s chasing less, making way more contact — especially in the zone. It’s not a lot of data to go off, but it’s encouraging, and there’s never really been any doubting the blend of raw power+speed … it’s just a matter of making enough contact/getting on base enough.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Brandon Lowe continues to play well (not 5 RBIs a game well), what kind of contract is he looking at next year?
Steve Adams
It’s still a 2B-only profile without much in the way of defensive chops, and he’ll be 32 in July (turning 33 year one of the contract). Something like Jorge Polanco’s 2/40 would be my limit probably.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you believe players heading into free agency play a lot harder to collect all the counting stats to oversell themselves to prospective teams?
Steve Adams
Teams don’t really pay anyone based on counting stats in 2026. The one exception I could see is maybe guys running a bit more on the bases, but no one’s giving someone an extra year or two because they stole a handful of extra bags.I do still wonder if there was some of that at play with, say, Josh Naylor last summer. And then once he gained confidence in his reads and picking his spots, he just went wild with it.In general, I feel like the whole “contract year” narrative is overblown. There are countless examples of guys having huge years before free agency but just as many instances of someone cratering in his walk season.
Year-to-year performance is volatile.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
This is from last week. I'll have his chat from today posted a little later.
Even fewer questions this week, so I included 1 bonus Q&A about free agent year motivation. Enjoy!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/04/ ... t-120.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Tell me you were wrong about Jordan Walker!!
Steve Adams
Do this for another few months and I sure will.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Sal Stewart the real deal?
Steve Adams
Sal can mash.
Fully in on him as a legitimate middle-of-the-order type at first base.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see 18-20 saves from a not-so-obvious closer this year?
Steve Adams
I suppose Lucas Erceg doesn’t count, but he’s better than Carlos Estevez anyway.Texas situation is pretty up in the air. I don’t think Junis will hold it. Cole Winn is probably my favorite of the arms in that bunch. Griffin Jax in Tampa has been hit hard but is SO talented that I could see him running with the closer role at some point. I am perpetually the “down” guy on Emilio Pagan among the MLBTR staff and I like Graham Ashcraft in the ‘pen, so that’s intriguing to me. But Pagan’s going to have plenty of leash if he’s healthy.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Has CJ Abrams’ hot start upped his value to the point where middle infielder needy teams may be ready to bite the bullet on Taboni’s trade ask? Thoughts on possible suitors?
Steve Adams
Nothing thus far has really changed my view of him. I touted him as a high-end trade piece all winter and think he was and still is just that. He’s had huge three-month performances to start each of the past two seasons before collapsing. The challenge is getting him to maintain and also finding a new defensive home.Abrams is hitting the ball harder and walking more, if you’re looking for positive indicators, but 60 PAs isn’t enough for me to read much into either, especially when he’s chasing a bit more and his overall contact rate is down considerably.
I think Abrams should command a very strong return if the Nats move him this summer — multiple top prospects — and he should hold interest to a pretty wide swath of teams. He’d be better suited at 2B or in the OF than shortstop. A team like the Pirates could try him at 3B. Pittsburgh, Toronto, Kansas City, Detroit, Boston … I can see plenty of clubs having real interest.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If McMahon doesn’t start to hit soon can you see them making rumored trade going around of Gil for Shaw?
Steve Adams
I hadn’t seen this “rumor” so I searched for it before the chat. It’s really just one speculative “hey this makes sense to me” from a prominent Yankees blogger. There’s no real rumor there, and I’d rather have Luis Gil than Matt Shaw personally, although I’m probably more down on both players than most.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Team that has been playing beyond expectations? Pittsburgh, Minnesota?
Steve Adams
Both? Haha!
Pirates’ offense has been far better than I expected. In general, I thought expectations were too high for the group. I still think that’s true, but Oneil Cruz is an MVP-level talent in the batter’s box (not so much on the defensive side, yeesh), so if this is the beginning of a true breakout, then hell yeah they’re going to be exciting. Twins’ start is hilarious and entertaining but seems entirely unsustainable.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Picks for Rookies of the year?
Steve Adams
I picked DeLauter and Griffin prior to the season.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I’m not a Noelvi Marte fan, but it feels like Francona set him up to fail. Sporadic at-bats, platoon against LHP knowing that Marte hits RHP better. Is this the end of Marte or is he someone who needs to be traded to a new team?
Steve Adams
I do not understand Cincinnati’s fixation on Will Benson. I’d have had Marte playing every day in right field. I still think he can be a solid corner outfielder, and the current big league group is shaky enough that he can hit his way back into another opportunity if he gets right. I’m curious to see if Rece Hinds can maintain any of the small-sample contact/plate discipline gains he’s made in AAA though. He’s chasing less, making way more contact — especially in the zone. It’s not a lot of data to go off, but it’s encouraging, and there’s never really been any doubting the blend of raw power+speed … it’s just a matter of making enough contact/getting on base enough.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Brandon Lowe continues to play well (not 5 RBIs a game well), what kind of contract is he looking at next year?
Steve Adams
It’s still a 2B-only profile without much in the way of defensive chops, and he’ll be 32 in July (turning 33 year one of the contract). Something like Jorge Polanco’s 2/40 would be my limit probably.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you believe players heading into free agency play a lot harder to collect all the counting stats to oversell themselves to prospective teams?
Steve Adams
Teams don’t really pay anyone based on counting stats in 2026. The one exception I could see is maybe guys running a bit more on the bases, but no one’s giving someone an extra year or two because they stole a handful of extra bags.I do still wonder if there was some of that at play with, say, Josh Naylor last summer. And then once he gained confidence in his reads and picking his spots, he just went wild with it.In general, I feel like the whole “contract year” narrative is overblown. There are countless examples of guys having huge years before free agency but just as many instances of someone cratering in his walk season.
Year-to-year performance is volatile.
-----------------------------------------------------------------