Page 1 of 1

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: March 9 26, 11:48 am
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on March 8.

About the same amount of questions as last week. There are 2 bonus questions: one about getting nasty and the other about Bill James. Don't deny it; you're intrigued. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/03/ ... t-113.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Where do you see the Pirates rotation falling in the NL Central? Is it the best?

Mark Polishuk
A good chunk of the Pirates’ rotation is still operating on potential more than proven MLB results, so I think I’ll still put the Cubs slightly ahead overall.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Did the Mets overpay for Peralta or did the Orioles underpay for Burnes? Seems like there’s a pretty big disparity in the prospect return.

Mark Polishuk
Peralta is earning only $8MM in 2026, while Burnes was earning over $15MM in his final year of team control. Peralta’s salary meant he had a wider field of possible suitors, since he could’ve fit into any team’s payroll. An argument can be made that Burnes also could’ve easily fit into payroll for just a one-year commitment, but still, the Brewers probably had a slightly tougher time finding trade partners.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Reds have the best rotation in the NL Central and it’s not close.

Mark Polishuk
Hunter Greene’s elbow issue gives me pause about crowning the Reds’ rotation. But, it’s a testament to their depth that even if they did lose Greene for any extended amount of time, their rotation wouldn’t be devastated.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Should the Reds have traded Greene in the offseason?

Mark Polishuk
This question might have some 20-20 hindsight attached given what happens with Greene’s elbow, but I agree with the Reds’ decision to hang onto him.

Obviously we don’t know what exact offers might’ve been on the table for Greene, but it would’ve had to have a major return (or even a clear overpay) for the Reds to move a guy who has looked like a frontline starter when healthy. Having rotation depth is one thing, but purposely dipping into that depth to account for trading away your #1 is another thing altogether.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Was the Burleson to the Astros thing Rosenthal said an actual rumor or just him speculating?

Mark Polishuk
It was speculation on Ken’s part, just because the Cards are open to business on a lot of their roster and the Astros need a LHH outfielder. Even then, it was a reach because Rosenthal noted a third team would need to be involved in a trade (with that team getting one of Houston’s infielders).

Rosenthal’s piece was also written before Pena fractured his finger, temporarily relieving the Astros’ infield surplus.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Kyle Harrison, gave up some runs but 8 Ks in 3 innings today. He definitely is the player with the most upside in that trade right?

Mark Polishuk
Given how the Crew develop pitching, it would surprise nobody if Harrison figured it out in Milwaukee.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who are the 5 best pitching labs in baseball?

Mark Polishuk
Brewers, Dodgers, Yankees, Astros I’d put in the top four. Padres, Guardians, Rays, maybe the Pirates all deserve attention for the fifth slot.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who should the Reds attempt to extend now that Elly has rejected them?

Mark Polishuk
Abbott makes some sense. The Reds are in the awkward position about not knowing yet what they really have in so much of their roster, so among the younger guys, Abbott is perhaps the most reasonable choice as a legit extension candidate.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Have the Cards become a team who will perennially look primarily and perhaps only to improvements from within à la Rays and other poorer teams with that model?

Mark Polishuk
To be fair, this is how St. Louis operated for decades. The Cards have never really been huge spenders in free agency. They make the occasional splash (i.e. Contreras, Matt Holliday, etc.) on the open market, but most of their biggest spends have been on extensions for players developed in-house.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
As a fan of the Brewers who have had about a decade of competitiveness and the Bucks who got the ring but about to fall off a cliff.. give me the ring all day.

Mark Polishuk
As a fan of Toronto sports, ditto with the last decade of TFC/the Raptors over the last decade of Leafs hockey.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Who has the nastiest pitch in baseball today?

Mark Polishuk
as per Statcast’s “run value” metric, Tarik Skubal’s changeup (with a +25 RV) was the most effective pitch in baseball in 2025.

Tied for second with +23 RV is Chris Sale’s slider and Ryne Nelson’s four-seamer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think baseball would have been better if Bill James had never invented sabermetrics and algorithms, and Moneyball never happened? A lot of fans like looking at the back of a baseball card.

Mark Polishuk
Bill James didn’t “invent” statistical analysis in baseball, but was just the first writer to start writing at length about such concepts.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: March 9 26, 3:40 pm
by heyzeus
Love that last question. It's like asking if Newton hadn't invented gravity, we could just drop [expletive] without it falling to the ground.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: March 10 26, 8:40 am
by Famous Mortimer
I am far from the biggest fan of Bill James the writer (as a stat creator, he seems fine) but that's definitely an odd question.

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: March 10 26, 10:36 am
by sighyoung
Image

The mistake was to stop carving out baseball fields from fields of corn.

Image

Also, angelic women in white no longer stand during crucial at-bats in front of men in business attire.

Seriously, aren't the details on the back of a baseball card . . . stats?